3 ms·
Yes, that function is pure. Purity is a property of functions. The system formed by that function being repeatedly applied to the value of DB over time is sta
by colanderman 13y ago
Yes, that function is pure. Purity is a property of functions.
The system formed by that function being repeatedly applied to the value of DB over time is stateful. Statefulness is a property of systems.
Also, forget about CPU-level stuff. That's a straw man and is irrelevant to the discussion; everyone in this thread is talking about the holistic (i.e. system-level) definition of state, as that is what FRP manages.
Beside, the mathematical mechanism by which a stateful system (the CPU) can be considered to be holistically stateless (a purely functional program) is the exact same mechanism by which a stateless system (a functional description of a state machine) can be considered to be holistically stateful -- that is by the definition I gave above and will repeat below.
Again: the definition of a stateful system is one whose observable behavior is dependent on historical inputs. You are conflating this well-accepted notion of state with the independent concepts of referential transparency, (non)locality, and (non)determinism.