3 ms·
kfk's answer is good. Aside from his advice ignore advice merely to diversify and hope. Diversify advice comes from old people still thinking in 10% return er
by VLM 13y ago
kfk's answer is good.
Aside from his advice ignore advice merely to diversify and hope. Diversify advice comes from old people still thinking in 10% return eras long ago. If you're getting 10% and have 20 diversified investments the failure of one is no big deal, even if you lost it all thats only a 5% loss and everything else returned a 10% gain for the year, so you really only lost 6 months. On the other hand, if you're getting 2% and have the same investments and one fails, then you've lost 5% and thats 2.5 years of growth where you'd have been better off putting the money in the mattress. And over that 2.5 years some other company will probably tank too leading to a cascading effect where "investing" your money at 2% or whatever is basically speculation/gambling you're better off picking up pennies from in front of steamrollers.
Now diversification does help with "return OF capital" its just no longer useful as a "return ON capital" technique. You lose one of your 20 investments you're wiped out for a quarter decade, but at least you haven't lost all your money... yet.
- Fomite 13y ago"Diversification" in this era means multiple ETFs or mutual funds of different investment vehicles (Large Cap, Small Cap, Real Estate, Bonds, etc.), not "10 stocks". A relatively simple implementation of this has given me a 13.46% return over the past three years.
- tixocloud 13y agoThat's pretty impressive especially how the current trend is hitting on dropping mutual funds in favour of other investments. Side question: How long is one allowed to hold an ETF for?
- mynewwork 13y ago> Side question: How long is one allowed to hold an ETF for? As short or long as you want? You can algorithmically trade them in microseconds or buy and hold until you die and pass them to your heirs.
- Fomite 13y agoThe current trend may be to drop managed mutual funds, because between active management and fees they're not great on returns, but really stock picking is both time consuming and risk fraught - most investing advice I see these days is to pick an index fund, or index ETF. There's now a diversity of indexes, and that's where the diversification comes from. You can hold an ETF as long as you please, or as short as you please, they're traded exactly like stocks. The only caveat is that leveraged ETFs really are intra-day holdings only, because they can do very strange (and bad) things if you hold them long term.
- VLM 13y agoA non compounded IYY (A dow index fund) return would be 15.5% over the same interval if todays price of 85 and 3 years ago of 58 is correct. Too early in the morning for me to correct for compounding. The problem with low interest rates / low returns isn't so much a cherry picked three years from last trough to current near peak, but longer term. Look at the yield of the SP500 from 2000 to 2010 for a decade long perspective, for example. That's where losing a couple percent is a big deal.
- Fomite 13y agoThat wasn't cherry picked as much as "as far as my data goes". And the point remains however, that "Diversification" isn't really something that can be accomplished with 10 stocks.