3 ms·
(Disclaimer: not an economist, it's likely I'm talking nonsense) This is one of those situations where it's hard to grasp what exactly is right to do, and where
by smcl 13y ago
(Disclaimer: not an economist, it's likely I'm talking nonsense)
This is one of those situations where it's hard to grasp what exactly is right to do, and where the media doesn't really help. Individually it makes sense to save money, but as many people will no doubt note it is harmful if everyone does it - less money circulating meaning a slower recovery overall. It's also slightly counter-intuitive, the financial crisis came about due in no small part to under-capitalised banks so therefore it seems reasonable to think that more savings deposits and fewer mortgages\loans is a healthy sign.
Another confusing thing I've seen during reporting on the financial crisis is conflicting views on the prices of housing. Prices were sky-high during the boom, and to me it seems plainly obvious that they were not the correct value and needed to return to normal. Yet falling house prices are reported negatively, and rising prices are cheered. I can see why individually some people (home owners) would want to have rising prices, but surely overall a return to the sort of pre-boom valuations overall are what we should be aiming for. Oh well, not entirely sure what I'm trying to say, maybe just "Finance is weird"?
- gutnor 13y agoAll the various scandal just showed the regular people that the investment market is a professional market with lots of insider privileges. If you play, you play by rules you do not control through the proxy of institution that do not have your interest at heart. Combined that with a depressed real-people economy (money economy is doing fine, working people economy, no so much) it is a lot safer to build a good interest rate on your savings by simply saving more.
- maxerickson 13y agoEspecially for consumer banks, under-capitalized is just a bad euphemism for over-leveraged. As far as regional markets and economies, the trend of housing prices is an important health indicator, hence the tendency to cheer rising prices.
- vidarh 13y agoAs a home owner, I want dropping prices, with some caveats. The people who want rising prices probably quite often would also benefit from dropping prices. People who treat their primary home as an investment and/or have investments in property may benefit from rising prices. Even if it is by second mortgages or by trading down to release equity. But I'd guess most home owners want to trade up or get something roughly the same most of the time when they move - our choice of house is usually constrained by price. And then dropping prices is generally preferable, as we'll get more for our money. The caveat is that I of course don't want the prices to drop so far that I'm left without equity for a new deposit. A slow steady drop that leave us able to finance a decent deposit after covering our mortgages would be the best deal for most house owners, and generally far better than price increases (that it is probably pretty much impossible is another matter - it'd distort demand badly because people would suddenly want to wait, and be able to aim far higher when they do make the jump) The reporting of house prices, as you say, really badly reflects this. Presumably because people see the value of their home as a proxy for their wealth, given that it is likely to be substantial compared to savings and other investments for most house owners.
- mseebach 13y agoActually, what you're arguing for is less rapid growth - which is perfectly reasonable. Less rapid growth may look like a period of growth, then a period of contraction.