5 ms·
Absolutely not. I've interviewed people who had amazing Github profiles who couldn't write a simple loop on the whiteboard. Either they hadn't written the cod
by jedberg 13y ago
Absolutely not. I've interviewed people who had amazing Github profiles who couldn't write a simple loop on the whiteboard. Either they hadn't written the code in their github, or they code only by copy/paste.
ps. It might be a good idea to be slightly more gender neutral in your question. :)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- benaiah 13y agoAbout your PS: using "he" and its associated pronouns as the neuter pronoun is a well-established and common occurrence. It's not being sexist, or non-gender-neutral, it's just a way to have neuter pronouns without awkward constructions such as "they" or "he/she". Those are fine, but they read awkwardly to some people. Using "he" is a perfectly acceptable alternative.
- jedberg 13y agoI'm aware that technically he/him are both gender neutral, as they derive from "human"(Latin) and not "man"(German). None the less, in today's common usage, it has lost that multifaceted meaning and the preferred language today is using the 3rd person as the gender neutral pronoun, or s/he or he/she.
- benaiah 13y agoWhile "they" may be the more common usage (though I personally doubt it), it doesn't really matter: it's fine to use whatever you want, and there's no reason to call him on it when it's not actually sexist. I have no problem with you using "they", but I don't see any reason to have a problem with the OP using "he", either. That's the only point I was trying to make.
- cabalamat 13y ago> While "they" may be the more common usage (though I personally doubt it), it doesn't really matter In your opinion. It matters to some people. > it's fine to use whatever you want Be aware that if you use the "he" form with some audiences, you will get a negative reaction. As to whether this is "fine" it depends on the purpose of your communication.
- cabalamat 13y ago> I'm aware that technically he/him are both gender neutral, as they derive from "human"(Latin) and not "man"(German). No they don't. "He" is from Proto-Germanic *hi- http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=he http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=he And even if it was derived from that word, words change mening over time so the current meaning could be radically different from the ancient meaning. For example, "silly": http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=silly http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=silly > the preferred language today is using the 3rd person as the gender neutral pronoun "he", "she", "it" and "they" are all 3rd person pronouns. I'm guessing you meant the 3rd person plural pronoun ("they"). The singular they is actually quite old, dating from the 15th century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-specific_and_gender-neutral_pronouns#Singular_they https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-specific_and_gender-neu...
- eru 13y agoGerman `man' is actually gender-neutral. Or do you talk about `Germanic'-English `man'?
- ElongatedTowel 13y agoI think he didn't mean the actually word "man", but its translation "Mann" which isn't gender-neutral at all.
- bjourne 13y agoJust because something is well-established doesn't mean it is right. "He" is obviously not a gender neutral word because it refers to a male. Now why should you make an effort to use correct language here? Because it matters. Language forms thought and if we continue to add genders to professions such as programmer -> he, nurse -> she, laywer -> he, au pair -> she then that has detrimental effects for the excluded sex.
- benaiah 13y agoSo, the extent of your argument consists of telling me I'm wrong without even trying to back up that claim? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-neutral_pronoun#Generic_he http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender-neutral_pronoun#Generic_...
- bjourne 13y agoDo you deny that always envisaging programmers as males put female programmers at a disadvantage? Read the usage note here and think for yourself: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/He http://www.thefreedictionary.com/He
- benaiah 13y agoI don't think you're thinking this through. Using "he" as the neuter is not assuming the subject is masculine. It's reusing "he" for another purpose. It's one word with two meanings. It's fine if you don't want to use it, but it's not inappropriate or sexist when others do.
- bjourne 13y agoThat is exactly the same logic that people who use "gay" as a derogatory term uses. But it is wrong as it adds connotations to a word where none should be, such as gay=bad and he=the norm. Ask yourself why you would want to use imprecise language that can be misunderstood when exact alternatives are available?
- meerita 13y agoI hardly believe someone with a heavy code contribution on GitHub can't write a simple loop on the whiteboard.
- jedberg 13y agoI had trouble believing it too until it happened multiple times.
- eru 13y agoHire the guy as a manager (or headhunter), and hire the guy who actually did the coding as a programmer.
- lfuller 13y agoThis is very common, and there was a pretty lengthy discussion about interview anxiety on HN a few weeks ago. Had this person been tasked with writing a loop outside of an interview environment, they likely would have had no issues at all.
- jedberg 13y agoDefinitely not. I ask FizzBuzz. It starts with writing a loop to print out 1 through 100 in their language of choice. They can't even do that.
- DigitalSea 13y agoThis is the problem with the software industry right here. Managers who think it matters if a developer can draw code and solve problems on a whiteboard. In my whole 10 years and counting in the industry, I have never once seen a whiteboard used a pre-coding pad because at the end of the day, developers are hackers, not professors writing a code thesis on a whiteboard. The whole whiteboard approach is severely outdated, it might work for some companies, but it's 2013, not 1979, developers have the Internet to solve most of their problems now. I think the real test of a developers skill is to ask them to code something for you. As a developer myself, i would fail any whiteboard interview because most of the problems I solve aren't because of solutions I've come up in my head, they are because I knew what to search on Google to find the solution. And to anyone who thinks this makes a bad developer, round up a group of 20 developers and ask them how often they use Google searches to solve problems they encounter. The difference between good developers and bad developers is not if you can solve every problem on your own, it's having the skills to know what to search when you encounter a problem. Us developers are over-glorified web searchers with a simple understanding of the language we are developing in.
- randomdata 13y ago0% of the code on Github was written on a whiteboard. Perhaps it means the skills are not easily transferable between mediums?
- delimitted 13y agoI think the whiteboard experience is very loosely correlated to programming ability and hope that the simple loop fiasco was an exaggeration. Many good programmers have a great deal of social anxiety, and being put under the microscope is not how they work. A better test of their prowess would be to hire them as a contractor if they can talk shop and have some live projects/open source code out there that isn't obviously copied. Short of that you could always stick them in a room for half a day, with an internet connection for their own laptop, ask them to solve a problem, then have them explain their rationale, stepping you through the code when they are done. Either of these would be a much better measure of how the candidate would perform for you if hired.
- jedberg 13y agoIt's not an exaggeration. They can't do FizzBuzz. I would expect at least that without the use of Google.
- bjoe_lewis 13y agowell, honestly and with a guilty tone I write a lot of code, work on projects and do stuff, close to good at github. But, when put to test on my ability with time limits and sneak peeks, I do tend to forget why I'm writing that loop for.
- X4 13y ago@jedberg is totally right! It's like judging people by the way how they pack their suitcase. To be perfectly honest, you can obtain metrics from Github that have nothing to do with coding, but behavioral analysis. I'll not go into details, because I think it's an unfair advantage. Github is mostly used for personal projects. You can find a lot of dotfiles, frameworks, many smaller and some larger projects done for a hobby/friend/school/course or out of frustration/boredom. What my Professor did is the way to go! Just hire that guy for a project, see how it's going and come together in a meeting to talk about the code, the solution and rationale behind the thinking. Then either conduct another team project to understand how he integrates in your company, or just hire that guy. Simple as that.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]