4 ms·
Beat me to it. Nice idea but isn't building from source more effective? Gentoo does this instead of attempting to hide complexity in one-size-fits-all packages.
by contingencies 13y ago
Beat me to it. Nice idea but isn't building from source more effective? Gentoo does this instead of attempting to hide complexity in one-size-fits-all packages. Also...
Fat kernel = huge attack surface.
Funky chroot / path stuff = source of bugs.
Multiple distro-specific APIs = n x sync latencies, n x diskspace, n x attack surface
Size of user community = 1 / n x 0.1337 (contingencies' constant)
- ParadigmComplex 13y ago> Beat me to it. Nice idea but isn't building from source more effective? Gentoo does this instead of attempting to hide complexity in one-size-fits-all packages. Oddly enough, the vast majority of Bedrock Linux users, from what I can tell, are ex-Gentoo people. If you've come to the understanding that building everything from source is a viable alternative to what Bedrock Linux is trying to do, you've misunderstood (which could be my fault for not being sufficiently clear). One of the things Bedrock Linux provides is a way to build your system with Gentoo's portage, but still have the option to get something else now from some other distro if you don't have the time or patience to compile it with portage. > Fat kernel = huge attack surface. Funky chroot / path stuff = source of bugs. Multiple distro-specific APIs = n x sync latencies, n x diskspace, n x attack surface. Size of user community = 1 / n x 0.1337 (contingencies' constant) This is addressed here: http://bedrocklinux.org/faq.html#why_not_use_bedrock http://bedrocklinux.org/faq.html#why_not_use_bedrock Basically, yes, you're correct. If you value such things very highly, Bedrock Linux isn't the distro for you. Maybe hardened Gentoo or Qubes OS would be better suited.
- zanny 13y agoI'd argue Arch improves on this. You can get standard software and anything already packaged elsewhere via pkgbuild, or just use the skeleton git repo pkgbuild to pull source and build it behind the scenes anyway. Best of both worlds - save some electricity and time and have access to all the softwares.
- contingencies 13y agoWasn't meaning to start a distro thread, but yeah I've noticed there's lots of nice docs from arch and the community seems quite large. Haven't tried it myself but understand its build system provides less configurability, so don't think I'd gain from a switch. (I use a lot of Gentoo USE config stuff, particularly on cluster and higher security node deployments to reduce dependencies and overall code bloat, which is one reason I really value Gentoo. Though still not perfect, it's pretty damn good for many of my use cases.)