4 ms·
It's hard to know the entire timeline of their investigation, but from how they describe it, the first lead they got was the username "altoid" posting what is a
by meowface 13y ago
It's hard to know the entire timeline of their investigation, but from how they describe it, the first lead they got was the username "altoid" posting what is apparently one of the first advertisements for Silk Road on a drug forum in January 2011, and then 2 days afterwards, an "altoid" posted on Bitcointalk looking for an IT pro to contact him at rossulbricht@gmail.com.
They implied this was the first thing they did. The interception of the fake IDs may have occurred before or after he was already under heavy suspicion of being Dread Pirate Roberts. I also believe there was some discussion that the fake IDs might've actually sent by an undercover agent.
Either way, I think it's very likely that they already had the idea that Ross Ulbricht == DPR before finding his Stack Overflow post.
- asveikau 13y agoRegarding the mailing of fake IDs and other stuff, I heard so many media accounts of Silk Road in the last week or so, and I really didn't understand this part: why bother to go through the trouble of all that crypto and anonymizing if in the end you are going to use your real street address? I thought this part was the dumbest aspect of the whole arrangement, but then I heard about posting on Stack Overflow to get your bugs fixed, and "contact me at rossulbricht@gmail.com kthxbye", and I begin to think that "criminal mastermind" is not exactly an apt description of this guy. I find it hard to contain my laughter at this.
- gwern 13y ago> why bother to go through the trouble of all that crypto and anonymizing if in the end you are going to use your real street address? I would have thought the server seizure demonstrated exactly why you would go to this bother: when you encrypt your address to the seller's public key, and send the encrypted address rather than the plaintext address, now all the FBI gets is an encrypted message they can't read. And the Tor connections means that they can't look up your IP in the logs, and so on and so forth.
- asveikau 13y ago> when you encrypt your address to the seller's public key, and send the encrypted address rather than the plaintext address, now all the FBI gets is an encrypted message they can't read. And how can I trust that the seller isn't an FBI agent? Still seems kind of risky. Even if they aren't an FBI agent, they're going to decrypt the address, and who knows what they'll do with it in plaintext? For one, they will write it on an envelope, leaving open the potential for exactly what happened with the fake IDs. If not these scenarios involving law enforcement, there's also the risk that the seller, who has my address, will extort me for cash or whatever.
- foley 13y agoThe Silk Road and similar protect the seller. There is just no way to protect the buyer, you are buying a physical product and at some point have to take physical possession of it there is no way to avoid this. Just as with buying drugs face to face you have to trust that the dealer is not malicious, is there a risk? definitely. But just as in the real world law enforcement have little interest in wasting their time on buyers.
- asveikau 13y agoNo way to avoid this, so we might as well just send everything via USPS to your front door? Sounds like a bit of a copout. It seems to me if you go out of your way to hide your identity you should, um, hide your identity. That would mean not trusting the post office just as you would not trust a sniffable network. Arrange a drop in a public place or some such. (Or do I see too many movies?)
- sneak 13y agoThis is harder than you think, especially with mail.
- gwern 13y agoYou can't trust that the seller isn't an FBI agent nor that they'll delete your address nor that they won't extort you, but as a basic matter of fact, the seller isn't an FBI agent and hasn't held onto your address (whatever good that would do) nor will extort you. There are thousands of sellers over time on SR, and how many turned out to be FBI agents busting a buyer? So far, it seems like maybe 1, and that was personally targeting DPR/SR staff and not any other buyers. There have been a handful of address leaks, with minimal consequences. Extortion was so rare I can't think of any examples. And it may seem risky, but that doesn't matter: we have the numbers. We have the statistics. The FBI has kindly told us exact numbers based on the SR database they seized. You can calculate the risk pretty easily. Take the number of sellers and/or transactions, get an estimate of number of buyers busted (for example, count instances in http://www.gwern.net/Silk%20Road#safe http://www.gwern.net/Silk%20Road#safe ), divide. This is like worrying that flying on an airliner might be really risky since the plane could fall out of the sky or be hijacked - certainly, but the worry is wrong, and you can go to faa.gov and look up the exact numbers and see for yourself how risky flying on an airplane is.
- dobbsbob 13y agoHe was living with people I think he found on craigslist, and gave them a fake name so I guess thought he could disappear from there at anytime. He would've been nailed going to a drop anyways they would have just waited for him. Why did he even need the fake IDs? They claimed it was to rent servers, which makes zero sense I've never been asked for ID when renting dedicated servers they just ask for money. PRQ certainly doesn't ask for anything except email address and payment. I guess he didn't read that story about the secret service running a sting operation for years posing as an ID vendor on fraud forums.