3 ms·
"That's terrible advice because people will drive instead." More likely, given the time, and $XYZ in the bank account, people will probably find something to d
by VLM 13y ago
"That's terrible advice because people will drive instead."
More likely, given the time, and $XYZ in the bank account, people will probably find something to do other than pointless movement. The local, momentary optimum of what to do with my spare time and spare money rarely randomly rolls the dice "fly!" although on rare occasions it does.
If he buys land and plants a forest on it while meditating, well, thats probably a net positive. On the other hand, having the extra money laying around maybe he gets a second car or a ski boat or spends the time installing a fireplace in his house, that's probably a net negative.
Rather than fly to Ireland this summer my kids drove out in the country where my cousin at his vacation cottage pulled them around behind his speedboat and/or rode around on my cousin's son's jet ski. I'm not sure which possibility ruined the earth more. Probably the amortized environmental capex of a vacation home and all the gas powered toys greatly exceeds any actual consumed fuel environmental cost by a couple orders of magnitude so they may as well burn a little gas to get something out of the damage caused by creating the infrastructure to burn it. Merely not flying isn't going to automatically fix anything.
The real tragedy of the story is the inhumanity of it. So flyers are treated like worthless cattle by employees, like freely abusable guilty until proven innocent enemy of the state terrorists by .gov, ripped off by the airlines, and all that inhumane treatment is perfectly OK with this guy, its just that he doesn't like some numbers on a report that won't really affect anyone anyway. And that is the inhumane tragedy of it. It would be like protesting the holocaust ovens not on moral and ethical ground but merely as an air pollution issue. Or protesting slavery pre-civil war not because the whole thing is inherently wrong, but because human slavery messes up financial reports somehow. The whole concept of the story makes me feel icky when seen in this light.