6 ms·
One meteorologist explains why he won’t fly again
- rjshade 13y agoThere's an interesting response to this, in which the author argues that "for the sake of the planet, please fly!": http://qz.com/131024/its-ok-to-have-a-big-carbon-footprint-and-pay-others-not-to/ http://qz.com/131024/its-ok-to-have-a-big-carbon-footprint-a...
- scotty79 13y ago> http://qz.com/131024/its-ok-to-have-a-big-carbon-footprint-and-pay-others-not-to/ http://qz.com/131024/its-ok-to-have-a-big-carbon-footprint-a... It's bit like saying "it's ok to each caviar at charity dinner". It may be right economically but it's very morally shady if costs of caviar and benefits it brings to fundraiser aren't carefully, unambiguously calculated.
- kylemaxwell 13y agoNot at all what I expected. But this feels like the very definition of a power law problem: the few people out of the human population who fly regularly have so much more impact than the rest combined.
- Zigurd 13y agoClimate change is alarming enough, and has been for long enough that I don't get responses such as these. Wikipedia says a 747 rates 91 passenger-miles per US gallon. We need big changes to the energy supply system that will be incredibly difficult to attain. We don't need irrational responses. The hard problem is to de-couple energy from coal and oil from wealth. Without accomplishing that, air travel won't matter one way or the other.
- mikeash 13y agoNew people are convinced of its truth or severity every day. As usual, there's an xkcd for it: http://xkcd.com/1053/ http://xkcd.com/1053/
- npsimons 13y agoAnd what is the carbon footprint of VTC/telecommuting? I agree that travel by flight is ridiculously efficient compared to cars (and also ridiculously safer), but this guy did an analysis of his own carbon footprint and decided that the biggest chunk was his flying. All that said, I can heartily agree that we need to find a way around depending on coal and oil, both as wealth and fuel. I can't wait for the day to get a driverless electric car.
- Ma8ee 13y agoAir travel do matter and there is nothing irrational in doing our best to decrease it. Just because Americans first compare it with cars that is the most inefficient way to travel doesn't mean that air travel is efficient compared to busses, trains or boats. (Also, 91 passenger miles per gallon is slightly less than me and my wife gets when travelling in our Prius together.) The point is that we have to learn to live with travelling much less. Both me and my wife are scientists, and we have become used to 2-4 intercontinental trips (back and forth) per person and year for conferences and collaborations. That contributes much more to our total carbon footprint than everything else we do summed together. It just have to stop.
- Zigurd 13y agoOK, but that may say more about the limits of carbon reduction in discretionary actions by individual consumers than about air travel as a problem. At some point you have to start transforming the supply balance at a significantly faster pace than demand growth, or you can't make a dent in the absolute components of coal and oil in the energy supply, nor will carbon-conscious consumers like you be able to achieve further savings.
- Ma8ee 13y agoWe must do both. Of course we need to change how our energy is produced, but we must also decrease the amount of energy we consume at the same time. Otherwise we have no chance to succeed. And of course I am know very well that what I and my wife do is just a piss in the sea. The point is that it is much easier to argue that you should do your part to decrease the amount of greenhouse gases you are responsible for, and even support legislations that forces you to, if we already have done our part and a little more. It would be much easier for the US to ask China to do something about their greenhouse gases if the US per capita emission wasn't something like 4 times as high as China's.
- MarcusBrutus 13y agoThis is South Park material. I would love to see an episode with ManBearPig, Al Gore and the crying meteorologist.
- jordanthoms 13y agoThis is serial!
- archgoon 13y agoAnd this is the type of poisonous, vacuous comment that makes Hacker News a worse place. If you want to make an argument that Climate Change is not an issue: Make it. If you want to say that this person's reaction is irrational, make that argument. Don't be snide and claim "This person's emotional response is obviously stupid, and he deserves to be mocked without justification". As it stands, we have no idea why you feel that this is stupid (though your reasons are probably crap). You're simply being offensive, and not adding anything to the discussion. People who disagree with you are disadvantaged, because you've made no actual points; and so you can dodge any criticisms with "Where did I say that?". Which of course, is the main point, you haven't said anything. You're just being an ass.
- MarcusBrutus 13y agoMan-made climate warning is most likely a hoax that fuels a multi-billion-dollar industry and is used, among other things, to erect protectionist barriers against Chinese and Indian cars. So there are extremely powerful vested political and economic interests to ensure that there's no possibility of an honest debate, even to the point of falsifying data I would suspect (never mind the indoctrination of young children across most of the western world). Even if that weren't the case it would still be pointless to worry about it as trying to change people's behavior outside the marketplace can only be done with totalitarian methods, which is exactly what environmentalists propose. Not to mention, since this is Hacker News after all, that I would love to see CO2 concentrations go up 50 times to reach those recorded during dinosaurs' time (sorry, too lazy to check exact era), as a much denser atmosphere would allow almost car-sized airships to be built, or even human flight with wings and how cool would that be. Environmentalism is the new communism and Gaia-worshiping is a religion with Al Gore as its main tele-evangelist. The guy has even set up his own company selling carbon credits. I am certainly not going to write a lengthy exposition identifying the errors in Benn Hinn's theological doctrine. Ridicule saves time.
- ars 13y agoHe won't fly? Or he won't travel? Big, big difference. Because flying is one of the MOST efficient ways to travel. FAR more efficient than even taking a bus. > If more would cut down on just one long-distance flight per year, he maintains, that would also have a major impact. That's terrible advice because people will drive instead. And adding "long-distance" makes the advice worse since long-distance flights are more efficient than short ones (most of the work is getting in the air, not staying there). The ONLY was to cut down CO2 emissions is nuclear power plants. Nothing else is practical. If you care about CO2, and you have the opportunity, lobby to have a nuclear plant installed near you[r city].
- philwelch 13y agoOr migrate to places with abundant hydroelectric power.
- ced 13y agoThat's terrible advice because people will drive instead. Or - more likely - they'll choose a closer destination for their summer vacation and avoid losing six days driving the round trip from New York to San Francisco.
- patmcguire 13y agoI don't think you're right about efficiency. Trains and boats are definitely more fuel efficient than flying, and cars are close. The figure for planes is about 90 passenger-miles per gallon, for fully loaded (55 people) deisel buses it's about 330. (All from this lovely article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transportation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transporta...) Of course it depends on your stopping and starting.
- gizmo686 13y agoThere is also a question of how efficient a mile is. When talking about transportation efficiency, the distance you want to talk about is the distance from point A to point B. When you talk about miles per gallon, you generally are talking about the total distance traveled which, unless you are moving in a perfectly straight line, is greater than the distance between the two points. I assume that air travel would travel closer to a straight line, so a single air mile gets you further than a single bus mile. I haven't actually checked this, and have no idea if this difference is large enough to cover factor of ~4 difference you are citing.
- ars 13y agoHe says he recycles. What does he recycle? Because only metal is worth recycling, everything else is not worth the extra pollution and water.
- alextingle 13y agoCombustible garbage can be usefully turned into electrical energy.
- VLM 13y agoThe city I grew up in, did just that with all of its garbage in the 60s/70s and had to shut down in the 80s because it was a net loss once the full cost of exhaust scrubbers, disposal of whatever they scrub out, etc, was taken into account. They were having profitability issues as it was once labor costs, boiler certification and related costs, maintenance, and ash disposal were factored in, so it didn't take much environmental cleanliness regulation cost to wipe out any profit from the incinerator. Or rephrased, you can burn trash to make X units of electricity, it'll just n*X units of electricity to operate the plant, pay the workers, clean the fumes from the smokestack, maintain the boilers, operate the facility... Some factors are O(1), some O(n), some probably O(polynomial) if not exponential so simply making a bigger facility doesn't help (and a bigger facility means burning more diesel to haul the trash, no free lunch...)
- Vivtek 13y agoYou realize that was fifty years ago, right? This is like saying computers are impractical because their vacuum tubes require too much power - here in the 21st century, Sweden has actually run out of combustible garbage because it's working for them. They now have to import garbage as a fuel for power generation.
- VLM 13y agoIts much older than 50 years, thinking about thermodynamic cycles and power generation and all that. Its not like burning a piece of paper in 1960 magically produced more watts, or modern plastic burns cleaner than ancient wood. It would be interesting to find a full analysis of the situation in Sweden. My guess is a lot of cheating... They don't count their labor costs because if they closed all the workers would be on welfare making the same expense, or sure we burn 10K gallons of diesel to transport 1K gallon equivalent of garbage. Everyone gets health care for free, oh hows it paid for, we all pay for it, we just don't budget for it. Sure the capex for the boilers is huge, but the local .gov paid for it so the depreciation cost is "zero" on our budget, although in the real world maybe it would cost $5M/year. I'm just not seeing it work for a legit operation in 2013, because a legit operation in the 60s couldn't run a profit while totally disregarding environmental issues, not seeing how paying $4/gallon for gas instead of fifty cents and actually caring about the environment suddenly makes the budget swing positive. You can run a .gov project and even issue pretend financial statements, but the laws of thermodynamics are not to be denied.
- Kequc 13y agoAccording to what I assume is a 100% scientific pie chart the leading cause of global warming is fire. So I don't know why this guy is concerning himself with air travel. http://i.imgur.com/AvIHovx.jpg http://i.imgur.com/AvIHovx.jpg
- homeomorphic 13y agoWhat do you feel that this adds to the discussion? Seriously - if you want to express yourself, please do so in a way that adds to the conversation. (I realize that this very comment of mine also does not add anything.)
- tehwebguy 13y agoAnyone else get auto redirected from Salon to Candy Crush Saga in the app store (on iphone)?
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoI don't want this to sound the wrong way. I certainly accept human caused climate change and all that. However, I think this is an example of how some people are just too dramatic for their own good and really should avoid quick fire social media tools.
- smoyer 13y agoI just flew throug SFO last week and what made me sad was the skid marks in the grass reminding me of the recent crash.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoRight, and that's pretty normal.
- jonemo 13y agoWhat some of the other comments here seem to miss is that he isn't suggesting to replace air travel with other modes of transport. He suggests cutting back on unnecessary long distance travel. And if you have ever seen scientists' travel schedules, you might be inclined to agree. I find it bizarre that those people who should be the first to understand climate change are among the most active producers of CO2. As a grad student I once flew half way around the world (18 hours + 2 hours flight time) to present a paper to a room of 10 people who had traveled similar distances to get there. Because the paper was more or less mistakenly assigned to a "robots for hazardous environments" session, exactly none of the people in the audience cared. And because I was last to present in a session of 6 presentations and the 5th presenter didn't show up, I started mine ahead of schedule. A few acquaintances who wanted to stop by just to see me present came in just after I finished. Nobody gained anything from this 15 minute presentation. If I had skipped the trip, my paper would not have been included in the conference proceedings. Publishing papers at conferences is one thing you have to do to be considered a successful scientist and this was only my second conference paper. The story is only one anecdote, but the entire system of science is built around encouraging people to travel long distances frequently. It's stupid.
- steven777400 13y agoSimilar story. When I was grad student, I was flown half way around the world (Oregon -> Italy) to present someone else's paper (!) because they were feeling ill. I had only the most rudimentary knowledge of the contents, since it was such a last minute affair. So, as in your experience, the presentation was hardly worthwhile at all, much less the expense (environmental or financial) of sending me, in aggregate, all the way around the world.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ggreer 13y agoThis guy is reducing his quality of life to save the environment (or so he believes). That's more than most of us are willing to do, and that's why his sacrifice is futile. He's the exception that proves the rule. I don't think any civilization has ever voluntarily reduced its resource consumption. Adapting to climate change or reversing it with geoengineering is probably easier than changing human nature.
- gaius 13y agoYou can fly and drive all the miles you please knowing that you will never impact the planet as much as someone who has 2 or God forbid more kids. Because there is one and only one thing that will save the planet, and that's fewer us.
- angersock 13y agoHow haughty to assume that the onus is on us to "save" the planet. How absurd to also assume that the only way we could accomplish this is by some quota of human beings.
- gaius 13y agoOh the planet will do fine without us, but using the commonly accepted meaning of the phrase to mean preserving a familiar ecosystem, then yes, the only was todo that is to consume less. If we abandon modern tech that will happen anyway since we rely on industrial farming. So we can reduce our load on the ecosystem in a managed way likeChina did, or we can have it forced upon us, but it is going to happen.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoWe need to throw money at this kind of stuff - http://www.gizmag.com/eads-voltair-electric-airliner/18988/ http://www.gizmag.com/eads-voltair-electric-airliner/18988/