3 ms·
Here's why I don't think it's extortion. Imagine you have a neighbor that hates bicycles. You agree to stop riding yours if she pays you $100,000. Is that ex
by jrockway 13y ago
Here's why I don't think it's extortion. Imagine you have a neighbor that hates bicycles. You agree to stop riding yours if she pays you $100,000. Is that extortion? Obviously not: you have the right to ride your bicycle regardless of whether or not your neighbor likes it, and you have the right to sell your professional services (not riding a bicycle, in this case) to whomever you like.
(Perhaps she wants to sell it to a like-minded buyer, and you're therefore devaluing the property. Too fucking bad, right?)
A problem that I could see the mugshot sites running into is that they imply guilt, when the mugshots were only for arrests. Intentionally misleading someone seems a lot like libel.
- hso9791 13y ago"Not doing something" as a professional service?
- shabble 13y ago"We put the Pro in procrastination!"
- notahacker 13y agoI'm pretty sure you could find yourself in trouble with the law if you (or a friendly intemediary) were advertising Not-Riding-a-Bicycle-as-a-service whilst riding your bicycle in a manner which whilst technically not violating any laws about use of the roads, was clearly intended to induce them to pay up. I think even many of the most ardent defenders of free press would take exception to a newspaper whose business model consisted of charging people not to write about them. Especially if they provided a bare minimum of factual information and then invited users to "tag" the photo with "suggested" terms like "scary, wtf, wino, beat-up", like one of the websites linked from the article.