3 ms·
Wouldn't basic income just lead to higher prices and inflation?
by Kiro 13y ago
Wouldn't basic income just lead to higher prices and inflation?
- sjwright 13y agoAt the income level they set, sadly yes.
- ck2 13y agoExactly like how in the US, college costs magically rise to the amount students can get in loans. It is a very bad idea to guarantee income instead of controlling costs. All it does is allow the people making money to make more money and possibly take that income out of their country for further investment.
- comicjk 13y agoA redistribution of consumption does not increase prices overall, although in the short run you would expect apples to be more expensive and yachts to be cheaper. An overall increase in consumption, because poor people save a smaller fraction of their money, does lead to inflation, though also to economic growth.
- notahacker 13y agoIt's redistributing from people that save most of their income (and often consume outside the Swiss economy) to people that consume most of their income (in Switzerland. The price of yachts on the world market won't move. The price of apples in Zurich will skyrocket, especially since the move simultaneously decreases the supply of low-end labour willing to work all month delivering or selling apples for 3200CHF per month. The combined effect of the two is likely to be massively inflationary. I'd be a lot happier with the Basic Income if I owned-low end rental property in Zurich than if I had a job, unless BI is funded by a property tax...
- justincormack 13y agoThe assumption is that the government will do this and still run a balanced budget; how realistic this is I do not know as there are no numbers. In which case its just redistribution, so no its not inflationary.
- marvin 13y agoRemains to be seen. That's why it's a great idea that a small country like Switzerland might test out this at scale, because then we can see if the vocal opponents who use your argument are right. You have a legitimate point, but I think a lot of the most vocal opponents of a basic income have a political agenda beyond wanting a system which is good for everyone.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoI'm not sure that a small country would yield applicable results, though.