3 ms·
Quote from the article: Futarchy seems promising if we accept the following three assumptions: Democracies fail largely by not aggregating available informati
by pdonis 13y ago
Quote from the article:
Futarchy seems promising if we accept the following three assumptions:
Democracies fail largely by not aggregating available information.
And we don't even need to go any further, because assumption #1 is wrong in two ways:
(1) Democracies fail because people have conflicting goals, not just conflicting beliefs about how to reach goals. Even people who have all the same factual beliefs can still have inconsistent goals. That is a problem in any system that requires everyone to adopt common goals in order to set policy.
(2) The "information" that would need to be aggregated doesn't exist anyway. Hanson assumes that there is some policy that, if imposed on everyone, would work; he never considers the possibility that the real problem is that assumption--that the root problem is the very act of imposing policies on everyone, not the particular policies that get imposed.
- RobinHanson 13y agoBut if there is no reason to think that problem is worse in this proposal, and the info aggregation problem would get better, you might still want to support this proposal.
- pdonis 13y agoIf the information that would need to be aggregated doesn't exist, then the "info aggregation problem" as you've defined it doesn't exist either, so it's meaningless to ask whether it gets "better". As for the problem of imposing policies on everyone, doing it by a mechanical procedure based on a betting market actually does strike me as worse than doing it the way we do it now, for a couple of reasons. But I'll respond further to that in the other subthread where we are having that discussion.