3 ms·
Peer review is receiving a bad review, no pun intended. Please remember that good journals exist, and insiders know good from bad. A bad acceptance from a heret
by jvanderbot 13y ago
Peer review is receiving a bad review, no pun intended. Please remember that good journals exist, and insiders know good from bad. A bad acceptance from a heretofore-unknown journal with a seeming credible title is not indicative that all peer review is flawed or done by impatient baboons.
And I say this having had a terrible time getting a decent review in recent conferences. But my journal review process has been largely positive, helping to improve my paper significantly, even if they miss some things. Certainly, when I receive a paper to review, I and my colleagues give it our best shot, but we largely work only for the established upper-echelon in our field.
- jnazario 13y ago"insiders know good from bad" while often true, science and scientific journals do not serve solely the scientific community, they serve humanity, which includes the non-professional public. while you may be an honest person and would never knowingly abuse wrong information to harm others, gain, or advance a broken agenda, plenty of people do. the "vaccines lead to autism" people, for example, do that. the history of science shows that careful, accurate and correctly performed experiments and publications are what give humanity progress. their absence, history has again shown, causes humanity to retreat, sometimes with disastrous consequences. this is not an idle, "i sure wish more 'scientists' could publish" debate, at some level the very question of human progress is at stake.