5 ms·
This is similar to, although one step removed from, the anarcho-capitalist proposal in David Friedman's 1973 book The Machinery of Freedom [0]. In this proposed
by baddox 13y ago
This is similar to, although one step removed from, the anarcho-capitalist proposal in David Friedman's 1973 book The Machinery of Freedom [0]. In this proposed society, monopoly government is replaced completely by a market for everything that government currently does, including law production, law enforcement, arbitration (courts), roads and infrastructure, and even "national" defense. I'm admittedly a big fan of Friedman's proposal, and I wonder what supposed advantage this futarchy provides over Friedman's proposal. There's a decent 20 minutes illustrated summary video on YouTube [1].
[0] http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf
[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTYkdEU_B4o http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTYkdEU_B4o
- judk 13y agoHow do opposing parties decide on a court to settle their differences?
- baddox 13y agoIn the complete system, most or all parties would already be contracted with a rights enforcement agency, and each rights enforcement agency will already be contracted with an arbiter (court).
- judk 13y agoAnd what if they don't have a contract, either because the interaction was nonconsensual, or because it is insanely impractical to negotiate a contract when buying a stick of gum? Political scientists aren't all idiots, people. Social contract theory exists for a reason.
- ehmish 13y agoOne problem I can see with Friedman's private courts/Rights Enforcement Agencies, is that if you have bigger and smaller REAs, a sufficiently big REA would be able to compel smaller REAs to ignore violations by the customers of the big REA. Smaller REAs would go out of business, as the big REA would be a much better deal for anyone who doesn't want to get sued. Finally, you'd be left with one big REA, probably called "The Police" or something.
- DennisP 13y agoFriedman addressed that. It's been a while but I think he expected the small REAs to be smart enough to band together to resist the big one.
- notahacker 13y agoThe bit of David Friedman's book that stretches credulity beyond breaking point and into the realms of the laughable is where he explains how profit-motivated "Rights Enforcement Agencies" can solve all the difficult problems, like banding together to fight really dangerous enemies and contracting "fair" dispute resolution, and yet fails to explain why they wouldn't collude in simple ways that actually push their profits up, like forcing fresh entrants out of the market and fixing price demands and "territories"... the sort of things that protection rackets actually do.
- baddox 13y agoI think Friedman concedes that this certainly could happen. Of course, with government, all competitors are already pushed out, and it's already a complete monopoly.
- notahacker 13y agoThe difference representative democratic governments don't aim to maximise and retain their profits and as such are infinitely preferable to an emergent local mafia, even if the local mafia's protection racket is subject to regular challenge (by more people demanding money with menaces from you...)
- baddox 13y agoI disagree with all those claims. I think representative democratic governments do tend to aim to maximize and retain their profits, and they neither governments nor emergent local mafia are particularly preferable to the other.
- pdonis 13y agoI think you're misinterpreting what futarchy actually is. It is not replacing our current system of government with a "market". Hanson's description in the article is this: When a betting market clearly estimates that a proposed policy would increase expected national welfare, that proposal becomes law. This is not how a normal market works. In a normal market, everyone gets to choose their own strategy for how they are going to act. The market only conveys information to them, through prices, about how good (or bad) their current strategy is. In futarchy, the "market" would determine a strategy that everyone would then have to follow, because it's the law. In other words, it still retains the key feature that makes our current system of government broken: whatever is considered "a good policy idea" is imposed on everyone, instead of being tested by allowing people who think it's a good idea to try it out individually. To really fix the current system, we need to really look hard at all the things we currently think have to be decided by a single policy for everyone. There may be some things (like national defense) that actually do need to be decided that way. But a lot of things don't, yet our current system forces us to adopt a one-size-fits-all policy for them. Futarchy does not fix that: in fact it is likely, if anything, to make it worse by making it easier for special interests to simply buy the policy they want, by eliminating the middleman (instead of having to buy politicians and elections, just buy into the betting market).
- RobinHanson 13y agoA futarchy could approve a private law anarchy of the sort that Friedman suggests, if market speculators thought it would do better to achieve national welfare as voters have defined it.
- pdonis 13y agoAs I commented in another subthread, the root problem is not that we need a better mechanism for determining what policy will best improve national welfare as voters have defined it; the root problem is the very concept of "national welfare as voters have defined it". We do not have a single concept of "national welfare". We have a multitude of things that various people think are part of national welfare, but different people pick different sets of things, and they often conflict with each other. Many of these conflicts are fundamentally irreconcilable. In our current system, we force people who do not agree with a certain policy goal to abide by laws aimed at achieving that goal, if there is a sufficient majority to pass such laws. That is bad. Futarchy would not change that. Imposing private law anarchy on everybody because the betting market says it would best achieve national welfare is just as bad as imposing, say, the Federal Defense of Marriage Act on everybody because a particular Congress passed it into law. But futarchy adds another bad thing to this already bad system: now not just individual policies, but the measure of success for any policy, the definition of "national welfare", gets decided by majority vote, and that measure of national welfare gets imposed on everybody, whether they agree with it or not. So futarchy imposes more things on everybody against their will than the current system does. That makes it worse than the current system, not better.