3 ms·
> Hansen gives a sample goal of improving the economy, but what if you also want to protect the environment, take care of your old and sick, maintain a strong
by gwern 13y ago
> Hansen gives a sample goal of improving the economy, but what if you also want to protect the environment, take care of your old and sick, maintain a strong defense, educate your children, etc?
This is where the 'vote on values, bet on beliefs' part comes in (did you read the paper?). The voters' job is to specify how much importance they place on various goals or metrics, and the prediction markets are asked how to achieve the goals.
- DennisP 13y agoIt had been a while so I looked through it again. Throughout he talks about deciding everything with a single measure of national welfare (which could include things besides GDP, weighted). I'm not convinced that's realistic. That one function would get enormously complex, its exact definition hard to decide but very influential on policy, and instead of debating specific policies we'd have vicious debates on the right formula to use, mostly driven by self-interested actors attempting to gain advantage, with even more obscurity than we have now. In principle I like the idea, I'm just trying to figure out how to make it better.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThroughout he talks about deciding everything with a single measure of national welfare (which could include things besides GDP, weighted). I'm not convinced that's realistic. If your decisionmaking process is consistent then an objective function exists. That's just a topological fact. http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/metrics_manifesto.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/metrics_manifesto.htm...
- DennisP 13y agoI didn't mean it's mathematically unrealistic, but politically unrealistic to actually determine that function. Since the function decides all, it will become the focus of continual, intense debate by people attempting to adjust it to the advantage of their favored policies.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoOf course, but that's the whole point. Rather than debating policies which are nominally designed for one goal but secretly trying to promote another goal (e.g., social security, nominally a pension, secretly a redistribution scheme), we just debate the goals themselves. This actually increases transparency. For example, if some party wants to declare a War on Christmas (TM) or a War on Women's Bodies (R), they actually need to put 23 x Dead Santa or -6 x Women's Freedom into the objective function.
- notahacker 13y agoI think people are pretty concerned about means as well as ends. That's why all parties want to reduce crime, and yet none campaign for a policy of "dispose of crime reports after 24 hours" which is almost certain to fulfil the objective function for "reduce recorded crime" (and will probably get passed in "futarchy" if someone proposes it and the market acknowledges that the highly-weighted variable "crime rate" will undoubtedly fall as a result). Instead of voting for the party that wants to reverse something that directly impacts their welfare or they otherwise consider to be stupid or immoral, the electorate is forced to listen to a set of explanations of mathematical equations that try to reverse engineer how it could have been passed, and how to remove it with the least side effects. If I want to pay lower taxes I'd prefer to vote for the party that makes lower taxes for people like me a core plank of their platform, and not a set of equations purporting to show how a tax cut could feasibly be approved by the market in the current economic climate provided variables P, Q, R and S were held constant and Z was reduced by a couple of basis points. It's quite possible that a party advocating a high weight on lower-quartile average incomes and a negative weight on birth rate wouldn't want some nutters to propose the "compulsory abortions for offspring of the unemployed" law, and get it passed, but I'm not sure a welfare function that could avoid all such unintended consequences even exists, never mind one intelligible to the average voter.
- RobinHanson 13y agoStatistics about means can also be included in welfare measures.
- gwern 13y ago> That one function would get enormously complex, its exact definition hard to decide but very influential on policy, and instead of debating specific policies we'd have vicious debates on the right formula to use, mostly driven by self-interested actors attempting to gain advantage, with even more obscurity than we have now. I don't think it would be even more obscure. In the current system, we mingle incestuously goals and means to the point where we can't even tell the difference. Forcing a separation is going to be helpful.