5 ms·
Here is a real case of this happening: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair
by IgorPartola 13y ago
Here is a real case of this happening: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair
- jnbiche 13y agoDid you read the blog post? It discusses a much more update-to-date case of this happening, by a reported who just recently submitted a fake paper to a bunch of open-access journals, some of whom accepted it. He then wrote the experience up and submitted it to Science, who is spinning it as something typical of open-access journals. More more notable than the fact that some fly-by-night, pay-to-play "open access" journals accepted a scientifically and ethically dubious paper is the fact that there now exists a large body of established, high-quality open access journals who roundly rejected the paper and pointed out its many flaws. Meta publication bias strikes again.
- housel 13y agoThe point of the Sokal affair seems to lean more towards proving that postmodern cultural studies as a field is lacking in substance than to demonstrating the ineffectiveness of peer review in general.
- primelens 13y agoWhat bugs me about the Sokal affair is the implication that they didn't catch a bad review process but proved an entire discipline to be a sham (a discipline which they understood relatively little of to begin with). So, when you get junk accepted in a humanities journal, its because the field is about bullshitting anyway - when you get junk into a science journal it's a hitch with the review process?
- lmm 13y agoWas the Sokal paper published with inadequate review? Or was it passed by experts in the field?
- magicalist 13y agoAll it takes is reading the wikipedia article... But yes it was and no it didn't. That's always bugged me about the Sokal affair and people holding it up as an example of anything. While the editors did publish the paper, which is a basic problem in and of itself, they claim they wanted big revisions that Sokal refused to make, but then they published it anyway. Since the whole point of that journal at the time was to get wide-ranging viewpoints, I think there is some merit in the editor's claim of a simple betrayal of trust: they assumed Sokal was being straightforward, and the worst that would come of publishing his piece would be a bunch of letters telling him to stick to his day job. In any case, I don't know if we'll ever a definitive story of what really happened, how carefully they vetted the paper, etc. Regardless, the journal he submitted the paper to was not peer reviewed, so the whole thing demonstrates nothing about the peer review process.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mzs 13y agoThe first part is referring to the Felisa Wolfe-Simon controversy.