3 ms·
Nock made me suspect Mencius is a Kabbalist. This metal and wood business confirms it. Hoon is still far and away the most WTF part of Urbit from my perspectiv
by samatman 13y ago
Nock made me suspect Mencius is a Kabbalist. This metal and wood business confirms it.
Hoon is still far and away the most WTF part of Urbit from my perspective. Nock: brilliant. Urbit proper: obviously the right thing. Hoon: line noise or poetry? I remain totally undecided.
Eagerly awaiting comprehensive documentation of the digraphs.
- aaronem 13y agoFrom chapter 4: > So if we had to read the above decrement, omitting the spaces (which only a real purist would pronounce), we’d say: “luslus dec sigfas cen dec bartis a tis pat sigbar soq dec soq ketcab pat wutgal tis pel zero a per tislus b tis pat barhep wutcol tis pel a lus pel b per per b buc pel b lus pel b per per.” Kabbalist? This sounds more Holy Roller to me. I plan to spend at least some of the upcoming weekend with Urbit. It should be interesting, to say the least.
- samograd 13y agoMy take on hoon is to use[2] the alphabetic names of the line noise operators to create words and use them to make a non-symbolic (if you take alphanumeric characters as non-symbolic) functional, executable conlang[3]. To me it's what Liebniz was looking for[1], but with funny looking words that make no sense to the uninitiated, which use the 'linguistic nodules' that cgyarvin is hoping to utilize, without the symbolic name decoding that using line noise requires (if you use the names in [2] rather than the line noise symbols). I personally think hoon looks like absolute brilliance, but I can't say yet that I've had the pleasure to write anything in it, which is the best thing to take that shiny feeling away by actually trying to use it. But as art, I think it's perfect. [1] http://sunsite.utk.edu/math_archives/.http/hypermail/historia/may99/0211.html http://sunsite.utk.edu/math_archives/.http/hypermail/histori... [2] As follows from http://www.urbit.org/2013/08/22/Chapter-4-syntax.html http://www.urbit.org/2013/08/22/Chapter-4-syntax.html: ace space gal < per ) bar | gar > sel [ bas \ hax # sem ; buc $ hep - ser ] cab _ kel { sig ~ cen % ker } soq ' col : ket ^ tar * com , lus + tec ` doq " pam & tis = dot . pat @ wut ? fas / pel ( zap ! [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructed_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructed_language
- samatman 13y agoThe numerous minor nitpicks I have with this scheme are a big part of what keeps me coming back to Urbit. The basic idea is so right-on that I can't help focusing on things like this: given that 2 billion people conflate "1" and "r", how on Urth did he settle on using those as primary distinguishments for every. single. brace. pair. O right, left and right. Similarly, every c in that scheme makes me kringe. Unless those are "chab", "chen", "chol", "chom", "butch" etc. Which, affricates, meh. This is of course the complement of damning with faint praise.