5 ms·
As an alternate perspective, here's Philip Greenspun: http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science
by jseliger 13y ago
As an alternate perspective, here's Philip Greenspun: http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science .
- melindajb 13y agoI'm curious. did you read the parent article? or do you just post this in reaction to all articles on women in science? What is your response to the original article?
- jseliger 13y agoYes. Especially this section: But he said he never encouraged anyone to go on in math. “It’s a very hard life,” he told me. “You need to enjoy it. There’s a lot of pressure being a mathematician. The life, the culture, it’s very hard.” When I told Meg Urry that Howe and several other of my professors said they don’t encourage anyone to go on in physics or math because it’s such a hard life, she blew raspberries. “Oh, come on,” she said. “They’re their own bosses. They’re well paid. They love what they do. Why not encourage other people to go on in what you love?” which reminds me of Greenspun. The more interesting question, which he raises, is that given the hours, job prospects, and pay, especially relative to the alternatives, why does anyone want to get a PhD in the sciences? That being said, the NYT's discussion on how other cultures view women in science was most interesting to me.
- geebee 13y agoI'm not jslieger, but I did read the parent article. The nytimes essay does mention briefly the claim that women may be "happier" in "people" fields like medicine, but it presents this more in terms of the intrinsic rewards of the field. I'm a PhD dropout myself, and I am a little bewildered that so many articles can lament the shortage of US Citizens or women in academic science research roles without at least considering the growing body of research that confirms that science is a risky and relatively poorly paid career path. If you'd like something less caustic than the greenspun article, try out the RAND study that concludes that the american aversion to science careers is rational and market based (just google "RAND scientist shortage"). As I mentioned in a previous comment, what I said above is in now way intended to suggest that there is no problem here. I can claim sour grapes, and I can advise others that those grapes are sour, but that doesn't justify discrimination. I do see a problem for women in science. But those grapes really are pretty sour. It makes no sense to discuss the shortage of group X in science without acknowledging this. It's not the only thing to be discussed, and I'd agree it is not the only problem. But to leave it out is a glaring omission.
- melindajb 13y agoI agree with your point, insomuch as encouraging more people regardless of gender/orientation/race to take up STEM careers is good for the world.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIncreasingly, it's like discussing a shortage of nuns versus an abundance of monks. The fundamental recruiting problem is that monastic lifestyles are not fulfilling or desirable for the overwhelming majority of the population. Hell, I really like CS research, I'm a grad-student, but I'm always looking over my shoulder asking if I really want to be on an academic career path, or what the hell else to do with myself.
- scott_s 13y agoMake an academic webpage! Mention all of your interests, past and current work! Put the URL in your HN profile! That exclamation points are because I care. I just spent ten minutes googling around to find your work. Computer science is nice in that researchers can get jobs in industry, and not just academia. But you have to be discoverable first.