2 ms·
I guess the question is "at what point is it morally correct to resist government powers, even if those powers are legally granted?". All would agree it comes
by nl 13y ago
I guess the question is "at what point is it morally correct to resist government powers, even if those powers are legally granted?".
All would agree it comes at some point (insert references to morally repugnant dictatorships etc).
Even democratically elected governments cross the line (insert historical references to 1930's Europe).
Even "good" governments cross the line (insert reference to numerous examples of legal persecutions of minority groups in most democracies).
Sometimes civil disobedience is a the morally correct thing to do. Was it in this case? Personally, I'm not sure either way.
While I agree 100% that Lavabit's actions were unlawful, just saying "there are rules" isn't enough to convince me that those same actions were "wrong".
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoI think a better question is "at what point does anyone get to tell anyone else that their morals must match?" I'm glad we can agree that Lavabit's action were unlawful... but please don't quote me out of context. "There are rules" was with regard to there being certain rules that need to be followed in order to qualify as a legitimate whistleblower. If you would like to argue that those rules need not be followed then I'll respectfully decline.