2 ms·
Perhaps it is technically true, No it isn't. The government isn't entitled to jack shit. They can demand whatever they want, and they may be able to take it
by mindcrime 13y ago
Perhaps it is technically true,
No it isn't. The government isn't entitled to jack shit. They can demand whatever they want, and they may be able to take it through force, or threat of force, in 99.99999999% of cases, but if the request is bogus, it's bogus, and an individual certainly has the right to take a moral stand and say "no, fuck off".
Now, that individual will probably have their name drug through the mud, be bankrupted, and wind up spending the rest of their life at Gitmo, but they can say "no" if it's important enough to them.
Some people are willing to die for causes they believe in, so it's not such a stretch to think that somebody, somewhere, would tell the govt. to fuck off in a case like this.
- Zak 13y agoNo it isn't. The government isn't entitled to jack shit. They can demand whatever they want, and they may be able to take it through force, or threat of force Your claim here appears to be that the government has only power, not authority (i.e. power + some sort of legitimacy or moral right to use that power). Is that your position? If so, under what, if any conditions do you believe the use of power against other people is legitimate?
- mindcrime 13y agoIf so, under what, if any conditions do you believe the use of power against other people is legitimate? Self defense. I hold basically the same position as Bastiat, in thinking that government can only legitimately be considered the "collective extension to our individual right to self defense".