3 ms·
Let's not dance around on this. That warrant was different because it was for Edward Snowden. Lavabit clearly feels he is a legitimate whistleblower. There is
by nl 13y ago
Let's not dance around on this.
That warrant was different because it was for Edward Snowden.
Lavabit clearly feels he is a legitimate whistleblower. There is a reasonable argument that protecting a whistleblower from surveillance is morally valid (especially when his opposition to surveillance is the core of ).
Whether or not one thinks Lavabit should have done this probably depends on one's views on what Snowden did.
- tedunangst 13y agoI'm not certain that lavabit should be unilaterally deciding who the good guys and bad guys are. That's something that happens later.
- 59nadir 13y agoWell, if everyone decided that "happens later" he'd most likely be dead or in Guantanamo Bay right now, so... Someone has to make a decision based on their own values at some point. Not everyone completely lacks conviction and ideals, you know.
- tedunangst 13y agoWhen was the last time somebody was shipped off to Guantanamo Bay? And seriously, dead? The first warrant the FBI requested was dated June 28th. Snowden was already in Moscow. How would Lavabit cooperating with the warrant have resulted in dead?
- zero_intp 13y agoIt could mean ill things for any of the people who are holding his insurance policies.
- fetbaffe 13y agoYes, instead let the US government do that unilaterally. Clearly better.
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoHere's the thing. Whistleblowers do get protection... but mostly protection from retaliation for their whistleblowing. But if a proper investigation is obstructed, how are we to be certain they are a legitimate whistleblower (there are rules that need to be followed) and not just some guy spilling classified info? I would maintain that it was not Lavabit's place to render a verdict of not guilty and defy the court order. If the cops show up at my house with a search warrant for my wife's closet, I don't get to just tell them I don't think she did it and close the door on them.
- fetbaffe 13y agoYes, lets trust the organization that the whistleblower whistled against to define who is a legitimate whistleblower.
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoYes. Lets. Oh... we already do. Why not this time? Should we let 4chan or Reddit define it? Who then? Not every single person in every single department in every single 3-letter org is a corrupt asshole just waiting for their chance to stick it to some innocent.
- fetbaffe 13y agoOf course they are not. That is not how tyranny works. It works by everyone doing there part, asshole or not. The tyranny is ingrained in the system itself so its seems just normal. And we can all see what is normal in the US today.
- nl 13y agoI guess the question is "at what point is it morally correct to resist government powers, even if those powers are legally granted?". All would agree it comes at some point (insert references to morally repugnant dictatorships etc). Even democratically elected governments cross the line (insert historical references to 1930's Europe). Even "good" governments cross the line (insert reference to numerous examples of legal persecutions of minority groups in most democracies). Sometimes civil disobedience is a the morally correct thing to do. Was it in this case? Personally, I'm not sure either way. While I agree 100% that Lavabit's actions were unlawful, just saying "there are rules" isn't enough to convince me that those same actions were "wrong".
- acqq 13y agoNo it was not different because it was for Edward Snowden, but because even if Snowden was named in the order, the FBI wanted the access to everything by installing their own device on the point where nothing is encrypted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6487778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6487778