3 ms·
"There are many cases of people with no flight training whatsoever being able to successfully take off and fly, but are unable to land." I would agree with tha
by VLM 13y ago
"There are many cases of people with no flight training whatsoever being able to successfully take off and fly, but are unable to land."
I would agree with that and this strikes me as the kind of thing that isn't resolved by anecdotes but via someones first five minutes with a PC flight simulator. Anything beyond arcade level.
Some of the more outlandish claims I've read about flying pretty obviously come from people who's shadow has never darkened a keyboard of a PC running MS FS or X-Plane, or even talked to someone who has flown a plane or even played a PC flight sim. I did a ton of PC sim work to wrap my brain around navigation concepts (like the to/from VOR flag, and how approaches "feel" at speed while under cognitive load) and PC flight sims help a lot with nav, but latency combined with lack of feedback and weird controls made it not so useful to replace actual flight time.
As for straight and level that depends on having been properly trimmed, but its really not all that much harder than driving. I don't think an aircraft can be FAA certified if its not stable in at least some axes. I know several exotic research x-planes were not stable in some axes at some parts of the flight envelope and some .mil planes were (are?) not. If a plane is stable, hands off it'll more or less smoothly point to some velocity vector and nose direction (first noob pilot discovery is those two need not be pointed the same way, and almost never are... planes are in an eternal skid, sorta, unlike a car). That 3-d velocity vector might not be where you want, not at all, but it'll smoothly stabilize there unless you adjust the trim tabs.
- dTal 13y agoUm, your ground vector won't match your nose direction if there's a crosswind, but I can't quite make that fit into "planes are in an eternal skid, sorta, unlike a car". Any stable aircraft in a genuine skid will quickly weathercock until the nose is pointing forwards again, and if you hold it in a skid with the rudder it'll eventually raise a wing to bank in the direction the nose is pointing (and if you hold that wing down with aileron you'll gradually change course as your engine(s) pull(s) you around until you've flown in a large and stomach-churning flat circle). Incidentally, do they teach that you should crab into a crosswind for your entire final approach nowadays?
- VLM 13y agoBad word choice on my part as I was thinking of "skid" like a car as in aircraft spend about zero time at zero angle of attack on the airfoil, not skid as in poor rudder use during turns. I donno about crabbing all the way into the ground now a days but if you're crabbing when you hit the ground I suspect thats very hard on non-castering gear and/or its ground loop time.