4 ms·
"Greenblatt wasn't daunted by this, he went ahead and formed a company too. So there were two companies to make Lisp machines. And Greenblatt's plan was success
by hga 13y ago
"Greenblatt wasn't daunted by this, he went ahead and formed a company too. So there were two companies to make Lisp machines. And Greenblatt's plan was successful enough even without the help of all the other old Lab hackers, that it's clear they were mistaken in thinking that it was a hopeless idea...."
Ummm, no, not even close. Speaking as a LMI employee during this critical period who then became for a few months one of RMS's roommates after leaving the company, right when he formally started the GNU project:
Yeah, LMI was with some angel investment able to build a run of CADR Lisp Machines just like the AI Lab did (25 vs. 75 or so that Symbolics did of its repackaged LM-2 version), but the company came to a dead end long before its next generation machine was ready. And went to Texas Instruments for money (TI even ended up buying Western Digital's engineering workstation unit, which LMI's processor was designed to work in).
For a couple of months the management said "We've cut your paychecks and put them in the safe, working is of course optional", we all continued to work and TI then made their investment (a loan followed by buying a 25% stake exactly 30 years and 1 month ago). But even then the company would have failed, for the hardware talent consisted of Greenblatt and a physics student who'd learned the basics of digital design on the job and they couldn't get the wirewrapped prototype(s) to work.
I even considered doing that (I was also a scientist type, could program and do system administration, was hired as the only person in the community with a foot in both Lisp Machine and UNIX(TM)), but I managed to recruit a graduating classmate who'd in his digital design class made a baby Lisp Machine (and I then left the company in frustration after about 9 months of never being in a position to do what I'd be hired to do and ran out of "make work" like sending a software update to our existing clients).
He then put in many "100 hours weeks" and with Greenblatt and the physics student (and perhaps some help from a couple of other friends I'd recruited) got the LMI-LAMBA processor working.
See http://web.archive.org/web/20110719154038/http://danweinreb.org/blog/rebuttal-to-stallmans-story-about-the-formation-of-symbolics-and-lmi http://web.archive.org/web/20110719154038/http://danweinreb.... as fsck--off linked to for the viewpoint of a Symbolics founder, although not from the AI-Lab (he took a detour to a LLL Navy supercomputer project), a very honest guy who's name was also on the Lisp Machine manual like RMS's.