5 ms·
When you know the end results, "connecting the dots" is much easier. True, but "connecting the dots" is much easier when it's your job, and something you've sp
by untog 13y ago
When you know the end results, "connecting the dots" is much easier.
True, but "connecting the dots" is much easier when it's your job, and something you've spent decades practicing.
Not to say that you're wrong, but there's no evidence to back you up. We might as well assume that the NSA is behind everything, ever.
- kevincennis 13y agoNot sure why this appears to have been downvoted. Seems like a pretty reasonable point, even if you happen not to agree with it.
- Larrikin 13y agoIn this current age, its more likely that the NSA is behind it. We are at a point where we need evidence that the NSA didn't help.
- dubfan 13y agoThen at that point you are no better than 9/11 truthers and moon landing hoaxers.
- Larrikin 13y agoTheres no basis in reality for 9/11 truthers and moon landing hoaxers though
- fivethree 13y agoThat's the point.
- intslack 13y agoDenying reality isn't healthy: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intelligence-laundering https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intel... http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/08/05/us-dea-sod-idUSBRE97409R20130805 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/08/05/us-dea-sod-idUSBRE...
- fivethree 13y agoDelusions of Grandeur aren't either.
- zero_intp 13y agoI see what you did there, Mr NSA. No seriously, the whole parallel construction dialogue for NSA feeding DEA tips is exactly the situation suggested here. Why do you equate published journalism with hoaxes and factually devoid crazies. It is insulting to a fairly civil discussion.
- arjie 13y agoAh, so the NSA's spying does have positive effects. It helped capture a drug king-pin who hires hitmen. I'd believed that dragnet capture of Internet traffic presents problems in trying to isolate relevant evidence, but you claim that this is not an issue. This certainly bolsters the claim that the NSA's surveillance is doing society good. I'm not comfortable with that, but there it is.
- mikeryan 13y agoWe are at a point where we need evidence that the NSA didn't help. So we now have to prove a negative or the NSA did it? Logic has officially left the building.
- bsullivan01 13y agoFirst and foremost, I didn't state as a definite fact. The rest of your argument ...oh well.
- ctdonath 13y agoIt occurs to me: a great tool of a "know everything" government is the ability to exclude dots, leaving the dots which merely need connecting. Just like the sculptor's aphorism "I just remove everything that isn't the subject, and there it is", a near-omniscient police force can address a crime by eliminating everyone it knows wasn't involved (by their near-continuous presence on metadata, cell tower triangulation, security cameras, etc.), eliminating everywhere it knows the remaining 'dots' couldn't have been, and eliminating every action it knows couldn't have been performed ... leaving a very limited "negative space" for the inferred suspects to operate in. A lot of data to mine, but given NSA-levels of awareness, NSA et al could respond (legally!) to requests for information with a vast list of who/what/where wasn't involved, leaving a conspicuous implication of the guilty.
- fleitz 13y agoThats the general idea of police work, you start with everyone as a suspect and then use evidence to narrow it down. It tends to work well from a prosecutorial POV as well because anyone who is accused by that process has little evidence to exclude them.
- ctdonath 13y agoGeneral idea yes, but takes on new implications & scope when operating at NSA levels of universal surveillance exceeding police work by orders of magnitude of orders of magnitude.
- tedks 13y agoWell, we know the NSA is behind some things, or else it wouldn't exist. We also know this is an incredibly high profile case. It's in the interests of the DEA and FBI to lean on their contacts in the NSA, even. That said, the FBI is very good at what it does, and finding this sort of thing isn't just what the FBI does, it's what any investigator does. (I have personal experience with this area that I can't disclose, but trust me, everyone knows how to link usernames between websites.)