4 ms·
There's a difference: filtering spam and prioritizing mail is something that's done for the benefit of the user. However, scanning e-mails to maximize ad revenu
by greenyoda 13y ago
There's a difference: filtering spam and prioritizing mail is something that's done for the benefit of the user. However, scanning e-mails to maximize ad revenue (they can charge the advertisers more for "relevant" ads) is Google using the contents of your e-mail for their own benefit.
- natrius 13y agoMy hunch is that there's no law that makes such a distinction.
- gibwell 13y agoThen you didn't read the judge's opinion. The wiretapping statue apparently does make such a distinction.
- Oletros 13y agoJudge Koh actually didn't made the distinction, user profiles are also used for spam filtering and she talked about scanning for making user profiles OR targeting ads
- Flenser 13y agoRevenue which pays for the FREE service. If the choice was gmail with ads or no gmail I know which I'd choose.
- dingaling 13y ago> Revenue which pays for the FREE service Google also scans e-mails in paid Google Apps accounts. Edit: correction to myself. Whilst paid Google Apps accounts still show ads and Web Clips, Google now have this statement: If you are using Google Apps (free edition), email is scanned so we can display contextually relevant advertising in some circumstances. http://support.google.com/a/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=60762 http://support.google.com/a/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=60762 the implication being that the paid accounts are scanned only for virus, spam and Priority Inbox processing. Sorry, I was wrong.
- georganos 13y agoWould making money to pay for the services the users use count as being towards the benefit of the user?
- gibwell 13y agoAccording to the judge, quite possibly not because it's not instrumental in providing the service. And also because such an interpretation would allow any business model based on exploiting the contents of the users email for profit, which is clearly not the intent of the wiretapping statute.
- MAGZine 13y agoCould Google not argue that if GMail wasn't making money (through scanning email and serving ads), then they wouldn't have a business case for gmail, and it wouldn't exist? In this sense, ads are absolutely instrumental in providing service. spam filtering and prioritzation, on the other hand, are not.
- cynwoody 13y agoThat's true. However, spam filtering (for sure) and prioritization (maybe) improve the user experience, thus drawing in more clients and retaining the existing base. Spam filtering, etc., make the service more attractive, boosting the user base, which makes it possible to charge more for the opportunity to show ads to the customer base, which, of course, is how Google gets paid. Spam filtering, etc., are no different than improving the Search Engine. Both attract more eyeballs and, thus, more ad revenue!
- gibwell 13y agoAd supported email existed before gmail started scanning people's email, so it is clearly not absolutely instrumental in providing the service. The allegation is that Google is attempting to make illegal additional profits by monetizing the users messages rather than just the service itself.
- cynwoody 13y ago
- res0nat0r 13y agoIt is greatly beneficial to me. It keeps gmail free.
- gibwell 13y agoNo it doesn't. Free email existed long before Google started reading people's email. The email scanning just makes extra profits for google and their advertisers at the expense of people's privacy.
- res0nat0r 13y ago15GB of free email service to 400+ million people costs a little bit of money to keep running. I'm going to go with the premise that advertising helps fund the cost of keeping this service up and running.
- gibwell 13y agoThat isn't in dispute. The problem isn't advertising. It is reading people's email.
- res0nat0r 13y agoHonestly I don't see much merit in this suit and suspect nothing will come of it. No human is "reading" your email in so much as an SMTP server "reads" it to know where to route your email next. Automated scanning is inherent in allowing gmail to be free. You submit to this when singing up for the service. 3rd party users emailing a plaintext email across the internet also have no expectation of privacy, just like mailing a postcard to someone across the world.
- gibwell 13y agoAutomated scanning is in no way inherent in allowing gmail to be free. Repeating this won't make it true. Advertising is what supports Gmail. Advertising does not require automated scanning of email, as is clearly demonstrated by the existence of free advertising supported email providers who do not scan email. The judge has already stated that users signing up for email do not understand that their email will be scanned, so no, you don't submit to it when signing up. The reason for the email scanning is to make extra profit for Google, and to increase the detail of their user profiles - which are also used when targeting ads outside of gmail. It is certainly false that users sending plaintext email have no expectation of privacy, both in law and in fact. The consequences if this were true would be profoundly destructive, because it would permit network operators to set up transparent proxies and sell access to email for any purpose. There are wiretapping laws for a reason. You can't just ignore this because you like Google. There is a reason why Google were the first to start scanning people email for advertising - because everyone else thought it was wrong. It turns out that the law might well agree.
- cynwoody 13y agoGoogle and the Gmail user both benefit. This why there are so many Gmail users! The Gmail user gets a free email account with a large storage allowance, an effective search engine, and a dynamite spam filter. Google gets to collect revenue in excess of cost (Google is very good at server farms) for the opportunity to show said user relevant ads. Thus, Google's access to the content of the user's email benefits both Google and the user!
- gibwell 13y agoIllegal activity doesn't magically become legal just because the proceeds are used to give something away for free.