4 ms·
The article suggests that a stall is a horrible outcome. Old style biplanes used to do "stall landings" all the time. If you know the characteristics of the w
by grandalf 17y ago
The article suggests that a stall is a horrible outcome.
Old style biplanes used to do "stall landings" all the time. If you know the characteristics of the wing, then a stall can be anticipated and is not necessarily cause for alarm.
How is it that the autopilot system (or other systems on the plane) would not be programmed to handle a stall gracefully?
In a stall the wing loses lift, but as the plane falls the air thickens and the angle of attack decreases and the wing ought to regain lift sufficient for the pilot to be able to control the plane.
I'm not suggesting that handling a huge jet in a stall would be easy, but I would guess that knowing how to do it is part of the requirements for flying one.
- lutorm 17y agoThis was my question too. But I think stalls in large airliners are a very different thing than in GA aircraft. I'm pretty sure full stalls are still part of the test regimen, but I don't think normal pilots ever do a full stall. It may also be other factors playing in at high altitude, and of course in severe turbulence a recovery might be even more difficult.
- marvin 17y agoGlider pilot here. I have decent knowledge of aerodynamics, but have never studied large jets in detail. This is my personal theory - essentially what lies behind the words of a few articles I have read over the last few days, but the authors haven't been able to formulate it clearly. Assuming that the autopilot and fly-by-wire systems were somehow compromized, a full stall in the "Coffin Corner" (Q-corner) would be a very, very serious condition. A stall causes the nose to drop and speed to accumulate. Since the difference between the stalling speed and the never-exceed speed is so small at the altitude in question, this accumulation of speed could easily cause the plane to exceed its critical Mach number, causing supersonic shockwaves around certain parts of the airfoil. In planes not designed for supersonic flight, these shockwaves will eventually cripple the effect of the control surfaces. If the plane is in a nose-down position when it looses effect on its elevator rudder, the plane will overspeed and eventually suffer structural failure (essentially meaning the loss of some critical part) due to flutter (resonance in parts of the airframe) or aerodynamic stresses. A stall during normal flight conditions doesn't have to be a serious problem, but these weren't normal flight conditions. And the information that we have suggests that certain Airbus models have had problems with their pitot (speed measurement) systems in icing conditions, leading to erroneous speed readouts. The fly-by-wire system, which prevents the pilot from flying the aircraft into stall or overspeed, cannot function correctly without a correct speed measurement. And as I have detailed, a proper stall might be enough to doom the airplane.