5 ms·
Researchers find critical vulnerabilities in Yahoo site, offered $12.50 per bug
- aspensmonster 13y agoI'm sure there are other marketplaces that could offer a better price...
- hsod 13y agoOne day you walk outside and you notice your neighbor left his keys on top of his car. You knock on his door and let him know, he says "wow thanks for the heads up, I'll buy you a beer sometime" You think to yourself, "A beer?? I just saved his car from being stolen-- that's worth a lot more than a beer" A week later you walk outside and see he did it again. Instead of knocking on his door, you walk into the alley and tell a local criminal about it in exchange for 500 dollars. This is essentially what you're advocating.
- eric_the_read 13y agoMore like you get a nickel, and next time, you think, "what a cheapskate", and don't bother mentioning it. After you walk by, a car thief steals it.
- invalidOrTaken 13y agoThe difference is that noticing it is much harder than "walking outside one day," and he's not just some homeowner. Rather, it's a bank, and through your advanced knowledge of structural engineering, and at least several days of work, you find a weak point in the wall that would allow for easy, noiseless drilling, allowing their vault to be emptied in ten minutes. I agree completely that Yahoo doesn't owe them a penny, and it would be reprehensible to find a "different market," as the grandparent alludes to. But it's not quite the same.
- icebraining 13y agoI don't see any advocating; it's more a statement of fact.
- amalag 13y agoUnless you had a full time job looking for your neighbors keys.
- jessaustin 13y agoThis is essentially what you're advocating. You have constructed an analogy so inapt that it threatens to suck all other dumb, unenlightening analogies on HN over its event horizon until it forms a sort of inapt hole from which dumb analogies could never escape. Which would be a good thing, so good job!
- Yen 13y agoI don't know if OP is advocating it, per se, but those marketplaces do exist. Even though it's morally and legally wrong, there is an incentive to sell exploits to the bad guys, instead of disclosing them to the company. The analogy is a bit off, as 'a beer' is relatively good compensation for the disclosure of the car-key vulnerability, compared to the potential black-market value, and the potential loss to the owner. With this example, it's more like you told your neighbor about his forgotten keys, and they gave you a nickle and a pat on the head.
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoA beer for the 3 minutes that you take to notice the key and tell him is about $120/hr. By contrast, assuming the vulnerability in Yahoo's system took just one work week, their offer was $0.31/hr. That's 384 times worse than your neighbor giving you a beer for finding his key. This is why your neighbor gets his key back for a beer and people are recommending black marketing Yahoo's vulnerabilities.
- borlak 13y agoDoes Yahoo have a public bounty program?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- paulgb 13y agoOr threatened litigation, the hallmark of companies who have no clue about security policy. Edit: the parent was deleted while I posted this but the gist was that 5-10 years ago all you would get for reporting an issue was a thank you and maybe a T-shirt.
- dkroy 13y agoI don't understand what Yahoo did wrong. They didn't have to pay a cent but they did. I understand that it is nominal, but it is better than nothing. I guess just not in the case where the press can get a hold of it.
- magicarp 13y agoIf they don't compensate security researchers enough, the incentive to find security holes goes away. People do this for a living.
- gradstudent 13y agoMy understanding is that nobody hired these guys to do anything and no bounty was offered for anything. So why should there be any expectation for a financial reward?
- jdiez17 13y agoSecurity researchers' time is valuable. They spend their own time trying to find vulnerabilities that black hat hackers would use against their users, possibly at a profit. They report it to the company giving them a chance to fix their problems. It's called responsible disclosure, and the compensation keeps the smart guys on your side. It doesn't even have to be monetary - for example, GitHub maintains a list[1] of people who have responsibly disclosed vulnerabilities, and they often send them a shirt or something similar. [1] https://help.github.com/articles/responsible-disclosure-of-security-vulnerabilities https://help.github.com/articles/responsible-disclosure-of-s...
- tedunangst 13y agoThis sounds remarkably like how the squeegee men operate in a big city. Oh, hey, I just washed your windshield, you owe me some money. No? Oops, terribly sorry about that scratch as I walked by.
- 13y ago
- cvburgess 13y agoThe comments [1] from a similar article [2] discussed the merits of this rather thoroughly. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6472965 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6472965 [2] http://grahamcluley.com/2013/09/serious-yahoo-bug/ http://grahamcluley.com/2013/09/serious-yahoo-bug/
- joejohnson 13y agoChristopher Soghoian tweeted about this and I thought it was a joke: https://twitter.com/csoghoian/status/384799909917884416 https://twitter.com/csoghoian/status/384799909917884416
- johngalt 13y agoThere is something about offering a small amount of money that is worse than offering none. Like leaving a waiter a penny. If cash is part of the equation, pay the going rate. If it's not, then acknowledge that someone did you a favor. Anything in between could be perceived as an insult/cheap.
- yogo 13y agoYep it says I'm a cheap fuck. It was better for them not to pay and offer some other form of recognition if they weren't going to shell out some real money.
- orofino 13y agoI'm confused. If I put code out into the wild, as a website, as an application, as... whatever, I'm supposed to compensate people that take it upon themselves to poke holes in it? I mean, I appreciate the effort and the time, but just because you run a large web service or any web service doesn't mean that I should pay you for vulns. You should receive my gratitude, anything more than that is being extra nice. Now, is there value in posting that there is some bounty for these things? Will it result in better, more frequent disclosure and give me the ability to close holes before someone nefarious comes along? Absolutely. Until I do that, people shouldn't speculatively be doing research and then retroactively bitching about how little they got paid. If you do work like that, please let me know, I've got some projects you can work on that I might decide to pay you for.
- bcbrown 13y agoIf you run a large web service, how much is it worth to you for vulnerabilities to be reported directly to you, versus being sold on the grey market to someone looking for an exploit?
- gliese1337 13y agoThat is a question you should be asking when you decide to post bounties. It is not a question you should be forced to ask after someone goes and finds vulnerabilities all on their own without your knowledge and then comes to you and asks for payment unbidden. That is called extortion.
- jfoster 13y agoYou're right. As a result, white-hats should spend zero time with Yahoo (as the company in the article has indicated they will). The result of that is that only black-hats will be finding Yahoo vulnerabilities. Not a good end result. What should happen is that Yahoo should have bounties in the first instance. They don't have to, but not having them leads to a bad outcome for everyone except black-hats.
- kmfrk 13y ago
- dreamdu5t 13y agoYahoo didn't do anything wrong. The researchers did by not selling vulnerabilities for more.
- tarice 13y agoSince the article itself only linked to it: "Each of the discovered vulnerabilities allowed any @yahoo.com email account to be compromised simply by sending a specially crafted link to a logged-in Yahoo user and making him/her clicking on it."[1] [1] https://www.htbridge.com/news/what_s_your_email_security_worth_12_dollars_and_50_cents_according_to_yahoo.html https://www.htbridge.com/news/what_s_your_email_security_wor...