5 ms·
Did anyone else feel like the description of people's appearance was judgmental? Maybe I'm reading too much into it. Edit: After a second reading, I think I've
by sp332 13y ago
Did anyone else feel like the description of people's appearance was judgmental? Maybe I'm reading too much into it.
Edit: After a second reading, I think I've cracked it. The author is describing Karp as currently immature, but gradually developing into CEO material. So the descriptions separate each aspect of his appearance and personality into "immature", "developing", or "CEO-like".
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI didn't think it judgemental but I did find it typical. As an engineer I've always been drawn to "functional" clothes (do the maintain the right temp, can I carry my stuff, do they launder easily) but that is not the 'norm' for a lot of people it seems. If you look for it you can easily identify how much emphasis people put on their outfit. So our author is somewhat focused on that, and a number of my east coast friends have been trained by social cues what "is" and "is not" acceptable dress, which they follow or don't in equal measure. It is one of the more observable culture differences in the US.
- pnathan 13y agoMy understanding is that the Northeast US care(s|d) a great deal about appearance, as contrasted with Silicon Valley. Does that agree with your experience?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIs Washington DC in the Northeast? Basically folks I have hung out with who are in that nominally urban region defined by New York, Boston, and DC are certainly more aware of appearances than folks in the Portland/San Francisco/San Jose region. I'm careful not to assign 'caring' or 'not caring' because it is that the attribute of caring is more evenly distributed, its more about awareness for me.
- nostrademons 13y agoBoston isn't that appearance-conscious, at least as far as clothes go. It's much snobbier about academic pedigree, which books you've read, and how much interesting trivia you can recall. I'd say that the fashion corridor runs from New York (epicenter) down the eastern seaboard. Paul Graham's "Messages cities send" piece is a pretty interesting reflection on this: http://www.paulgraham.com/cities.html http://www.paulgraham.com/cities.html
- kingraoul3 13y agoYou forgot Philly. It's cool. 5th largest city in the country and everything, but you know, whatever.
- dkuntz2 13y agoYou forgot Chicago, third most populous city in the US and everything, but you know, whatever.
- kingraoul3 13y ago? He was listing the cities in the Northeast corridor.
- pnathan 13y agoI do lump it in as sort of the bottom tip, in my mind. But thanks for the clarification regarding the attention paid.
- eth 13y agoWithout actually caring, I do agree. The choice to go into greater detail regarding appearances, as opposed to making some sort of sweeping statement about "hipsters" or "Brooklyn-folk", came across as mostly unnecessary.
- parennoob 13y agoTypical of a lot of the the writing/journalism crowd, they want to belittle people and make them social outcasts they were in high school again. Cannot bear the fact that those 'nerds' are now enormously successful, both financially and in their personal life. The writer's jealousy just shows through in this. "The enormous features that read so well in photos looked cartoonish in person: Chiclet teeth, rubbery grin, duck-feathery hair." Yeah, if it had been a slam poet, how much are we betting the writer would have said something like "Wavy hair, dreamy eyes, and delicate-boned face"?
- devindotcom 13y agoThe "writing/journalism crowd"? What is this new prejudice? There is no such "crowd," nor, if there were, would they share the features you describe. What an absurd generalization.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- revelation 13y agoHuh? Of course there is such a "crowd". Who do you think can be a journalist in this country? You need, at the minimum, a college degree. Since it is a rather popular field, you will need to do an internship for no or minimal pay (this pretty much disqualifies anyone without significant parental suppot). And to get any of the previously mentioned qualifications, it will help enormously if you have been socialized/grown up in an environment that 1) speaks the correct dialect and 2) fosters interest in things like politics. And then, of course, lots of publications have deeply ingrained political (even social) leanings that they more or less openly display; if you want to get a job there, you better share the mindset.
- parennoob 13y agoI mean a loosely defined aggregation of people who work in freelance writing, journalism, and content strategy who tend to be born into middle-to-upper class homes, are generally socially successful at high school and (often liberal-arts) college. They typically come from non-technical majors such as English Literature, "Communication", etc. Is there really no such group that comes to your mind? Alternately, let me put it this way. Is there anyone on HN who has a job at NYMag?
- badman_ting 13y agoYes, absolutely. I am getting really tired of this hoodie-bashing thing, after Zuckerberg and now Karp. People would rightly find it outrageous if a woman sold her company and all the media could comment on was her clothes.
- sp332 13y agoIs that sarcastic? I feel like that scenario is very plausible.
- Smudge 13y agoPlausible, perhaps. Still outrageous.
- chollida1 13y ago> People would rightly find it outrageous if a woman sold her company and all the media could comment on was her clothes. Half the Melissa Mayer pieces I read, spend a great deal o the article talking about her fashion sense. No only do people not mind it seems like it's a prerequisite for writing an article about her.
- dasil003 13y agoTo be fair, people comment on plenty besides Karp's wardrobe.