8 ms·
s/TouchID/Face Unlock/g and back up about 2 years and you can find all the same things said about Ice Cream Sandwich. It's a cute feature. It's not going to c
by ajross 13y ago
s/TouchID/Face Unlock/g and back up about 2 years and you can find all the same things said about Ice Cream Sandwich.
It's a cute feature. It's not going to change the world, sell another billion phones, push other companies out of the market, or save anyone from serious attacks. It's probably a good idea to enable it anyway.
- gfodor 13y agoI don't think you can call something a cute feature when it's turned on on most phones and is used to unlock them. I would guess that by far the majority of iPhone 5S's have TouchID enabled. I wouldn't be surprised if it's more than 90%. The feature is just that well executed.
- Kylekramer 13y agoI would be very surprised if it is that high now even with the early adopter skew. Reports say that last year it was around a quarter of smartphone users use passcode locks on their work phone (http://www.welivesecurity.com/2012/02/28/sizing-up-the-byod-security-challenge/ http://www.welivesecurity.com/2012/02/28/sizing-up-the-byod-...). I imagine 5S rates are higher than that, but 90% would be insanely impressive. When it comes to computer security, as usual, people's apathy is the biggest problem.
- 3825 13y agoIsn't passcode required to get exchange email on iOS?
- rossjudson 13y agoThat's an option set by your IT department. Annoyingly, mine does the same thing. It doesn't have to be that way.
- cstrat 13y agoAt my work they have allowed the TouchID to be used with our security policy. I just haven't shelled out the money to buy a new phone.
- pfranz 13y agoI'm sure opt-in/opt-out is a major factor, too. I don't have a 5S, but I'm pretty sure it's opt-out. I think even after upgrading to iOS7 I had to opt-in again to turn on the numerical pass code.
- gfodor 13y agoiOS setup flow basically points the user in the direction of setting it up.
- ISL 13y agoIt is more difficult to defeat a touch sensor than face unlock. With face unlock, I just need a photo of the phone's owner. With a fingerprint unlock, I need to go to at least a little trouble to fake the fingerprint.
- ajross 13y agoDepends on scenario. If you steal a phone from a bag on the subway, you'll never be able to get that photo but can probably lift the print right off the phone itself. So maybe iOS has better-yet-still-mediocre protection against snooping yet inferiorly-mediocre guards against identity theft. Yawn. In neither case is the phone meaningfully protected against serious attack. Why must we have this argument? It's a cute feature. Use it.
- glhaynes 13y agobut can probably lift the print right off the phone itself That doesn't seem to be the case to my knowledge. The evidence from the successful attack is that you need an excellent-quality print from one of the specific fingers that has been programmed into the phone. Some phones probably have that on them, but it appears likely that many do not.
- diminish 13y agothere ll be an app for that. edit: build an app, get your colleague, significant other etc touch it on any touchscreen phone or get on camera and create a 3d printed finger. 3d printing vs touchid...maybe
- roc 13y agoI'm pretty sure the GP was talking about the likelihood of a given phone having an appropriate-quality print [1], which does seem low. But putting that aside, your hypothetical app would -- using the demonstrated method -- 'lift' that excellent quality print, scan it at 2400 dpi, (clean up said print), print it on a transparency at 1200 dpi, mask it onto photosensitive PCB, develop/etch/clean the PCB, spray graphite and apply wood glue to the mold. It might make for a slightly-more-plausible-than-normal gadget sequence in a Mission Impossible movie, but it's not much of a concern for the target market. [2] [1] Despite what decades of shows like CSI might lead us to believe, this is not a simple or error-free process. And each mistake irrecoverably destroys the print. [2] Most of that market doesn't even use a passcode today and many that do are still using surprisingly bad PINs (birthdays/anniversaries/1234)
- Steko 13y agoPeople keep making this analogy but Face Unlock is not being promoted as ever being used for anything but unlocking the phone. Touch ID is the foundation of an entire mobile identity/payment scheme.
- mikestew 13y agoExcept TouchID, from what I gather, actually works. Not "works" in the sense of keeping bad people out, but "works" in the sense that when I use it my phone unlocks. I tried face unlock briefly on the Google Nexus I've got and disabled it shortly after when I found that it was unreliable. Poor lighting, too much lighting, a bad hair day, it wasn't even at 80% for successful unlocks.
- nobodyshere 13y agoTo be honest, I disabled face unlock the moment my brother unlocked it with his face... Yeah, touch id won't let that happen.
- foobarbazqux 13y ago> Not "works" in the sense of keeping bad people out, but "works" in the sense that when I use it my phone unlocks. I think that's the key distinction here. In any given authentication scheme it's important not to have false positives (incorrectly identifying a bad guy as you) or false negatives (incorrectly identifying you as a bad guy). In this case false positives break security, false negatives break usability. However, false positives won't outright stop adoption whereas false negatives will.
- diminish 13y agodoes touchid have the disadvantage of keeping your friends and family unable to use your phone in cases of emergency? 95% of the time, my phone isnt next to adversaries, but trusted parties. a password or code is transferrable, fingerprint isnt. edit; not 911emergency, but casual situations of full or dirty hands..
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sologoub 13y agoTouchID has some tangible implications for markets where some security is needed and convenience is already compromised. For example, my corporate policy disallows pattern lock and requires I use a pin. This is majorly annoying and is enough for me to consider a different device. The big enterprise market is an awesome place to get a foothold in - they are not really price-sensitive and hate change. Not that Apple has any problems in that segment, but extra lock-in doesn't hurt. Where this becomes semi-dangerous is in assuming that now your phone is ironclad and you can store whatever on it totally unprotected. The best route to safety is to make informed decisions based on your own risk-tolerance and not be a lemming.
- victorf 13y agoCertain Japanese cigarette vending machines had photographic age detection algorithms. Japanese children used photos of Bruce Willis to buy cigarettes. Getting a photo of your face would be much simpler than getting your prints.
- gcr 13y agoYou touch your iphone's screen to use it, right? Getting a latent print isn't exactly difficult.
- alwaysinshade 13y agoAcquiring a high-DPI scan of a fingerprint from someone's phone, printing it to a sheet of plastic with a high-DPI laser printer, then making a copy of the print out of liquid latex doesn't sound easy unless you're in the business of pentesting. Taking a picture of someone (or lifting it from a social network) to access their device does sound relatively easy. If I was the kind of person who was worried about someone accessing the contents of my phone, I'd simply turn off touch ID and use a long password (or spend less money on a phone that didn't have a feature I wouldn't use). I've gone down the route of using both a long password and touch ID simply because touch ID works so reliably - I've never had to enter my password. That way someone either needs my long password or a physical copy of my fingerprint to access my device. I'd say that's much better than the 4 digit numerical code I relied on previously - which had been seen by friends and family.
- gcr 13y agoSee the problem here is that a compromised fingerprint betrays more resources than the system it was meant to protect. Your iPhone has a picture of your fingerprint inside of it now. It's just a picture, and it's likely a very good picture at that. What happens when I swipe your phone for a second or two, plug it into my machine, and download the high-resolution picture of your fingerprint? Do you use a fingerprint lock at home? If so, I've just broken into your home. Do you use a fingerprint lock for the datacenter you administer? I've just gained access. Do you own a registered gun? How'd you like me to commit a murder with your fingerprint on it? This kind of attack is the missing piece of my argument. When someone figures out how to do this, these issues are going to become very important very quickly. Let's suppose that Apple introduces a feature that syncs your fingerprint across many devices. How convenient, right? Let's say that means keeping all of your fingerprints on Apple servers. Let's now suppose that, like a credit card database, an attacker is able to obtain a leaked copy of the fingerprint database of every iPhone user. The recent touchid hack shows that fingerprints can be spoofed for high-end scanners. What then? Sure, this scenario is very unlikely. I'm totally in slippery-slope land here. But when we choose to turn up the dial on convenience to sacrifice more security, we must be prudent, carefully considering the consequences of our intentional ignorance.