4 ms·
One hidden assumption is the high growth of internet retail implies a high growth of fashion clothing growth. Not sure why that applies. Sounds good, just not
by VLM 13y ago
One hidden assumption is the high growth of internet retail implies a high growth of fashion clothing growth. Not sure why that applies. Sounds good, just not backed up by numbers.
Its hard to think of a commodity with more of a conspicuous consumption purpose than expensive fashion clothes, other than perhaps cars. The act of shopping for them, being seen shopping for them, the whole trying them on and looking a mirror, seems to reach or exceed the enjoyment of eventually wearing them in public.
I would imagine sizing is a complicated issue impacting possible 10% annual growth rates and all that. Tee shirt sizes are simple so online tee shirt sellers do well. I have bought my last four pairs of shoes on line because they're identical mfgr, model, size, width. I'm thinking high fashion clothing sizing might be somewhat more complicated. "do these stripes make my butt look fat" is hard to answer if you don't try the clothing on. As if thats ever an easy question to answer.
Finally you can increase annual sales of $300 fashion brand jeans by 10% per year for quite a few years, but eventually you bounce off declining median adjusted incomes, permanent decrease in economic activity, long term demographic decline stuff like that. It is very much like growing the 50+ foot sailing yacht market by 10% per year, you can do that for awhile, but eventually you run out of people capable of paying $300 for a pair of jeans, err, buying 50+ foot sailing yachts... The fashion market may not be big enough to make the subset of internet sales large enough to be viable. Perhaps walmart has more to fear from amazon than the major fashion brands... there's a lot more people buying $25 walmart jeans wanting to save $5 at amazon than people buying $300 jeans hoping to save $200.
(edited to add that if you agree with the assumptions of the article, its a well written and well analyzed article with no obvious mistakes. I just happen to disagree with several core assumptions which has quite an effect on my opinion of the conclusion.)
- jamiequint 13y agoApparel has actually been the driving force in e-commerce over the last few years: http://www.emarketer.com/newsroom/index.php/apparel-drives-retail-ecommerce-sales-growth/ http://www.emarketer.com/newsroom/index.php/apparel-drives-r...
- VLM 13y agoThat's a good, general, factual article you've linked to. Superficially I saw mostly general sector wide results in the article. However I have bought a lot more tee shirts and cafepress-type products and cheap identical non-designer shoes than $200 scottevest products. My impression of the article is it was focusing solely on high end whereas I'm arguing the bigger action is probably at the low end.
- jamiequint 13y agoYou are correct, I was mostly talking about wholesale designer brands which are mid-to-high end (priced at the cost of someone like J. Crew or Gap or above). It's actually interesting though, at the mid-to-low end similar disruption is happening in a different way. There are 'designer' brands that exist at these price points, but they are being disrupted by the department stores that previously purchased them shifting to private label production (brands the stores produce themselves and label with their own brand), and shifting fast. In 1970, 25% of department store retail was private-label brands, in 2005, 50%, in 2010, 60%. [1] [1]: The New Rules of Retail - http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004AP9TQM http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004AP9TQM