5 ms·
While it obviously appears to shorten the brushing time, it also looks like it would be much harder to keep the device itself clean - everyone who has had a ret
by zdw 13y ago
While it obviously appears to shorten the brushing time, it also looks like it would be much harder to keep the device itself clean - everyone who has had a retainer or other removable dental device could likely attest to this. I'd imagine it would also require more toothpaste.
Seeing as toothbrushes in bulk are about less than $1 each, a $300 ($150 refurbished, but ewwwwww...), hard to clean device seems somewhat difficult to argue for.
- ginko 13y agoMaybe you can put it in a cleaning fluid after brushing.
- TobbenTM 13y agoAnd similarly, a more fluid/watered out paste to ease appliance.
- TheCraiggers 13y agoThere's nothing wrong with a refurbished device like this, provided it's been cleaned. I don't understand why people always have problems with things like this. Or do you have a problem with the cleaning tools the dental hygienist uses? Those were in someone else's mouth the previous day, after all. I agree with your other points, although if the device cleans your teeth better, that may be worth it to some people.
- thedufer 13y ago> Or do you have a problem with the cleaning tools the dental hygienist uses They open a sealed set of new tools for each patient at all of the places I've been. Is this a US thing?
- cvburgess 13y agoThey are not "new" - they are simply cleaned and resealed in packaging. It would be crazy expensive to only use these instruments once.
- DanBC 13y agoThey'd move to disposable items which would be much cheaper. But, even then, people want to reuse items. (http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/crdweb/ShowRecord.asp?LinkFrom=OAI&ID=21998000484#.UksGv9KRC0I http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/crdweb/ShowRecord.asp?LinkFrom=OAI...) Luckily there seems to be lots of research around reusable instruments. (https://www.evidence.nhs.uk/search?q=disposable%20instruments&ps=50 https://www.evidence.nhs.uk/search?q=disposable%20instrument...)
- kaib 13y agoMany of the tools are actually reused again and again. However, between uses they are sterilized using an autoclave and then immediately put into sealed bags to maintain sterility.
- aestra 13y agoJust because the bags are sealed doesn't mean the tools have never been used. They are cleaned, sealed in bags, and put in an autoclave to be sterilized. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoclave http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoclave
- 0ca0 13y agoIt doesn't really look like cleaning that would be as straightforward as cleaning a lot of the equipment that dental hygienists use.
- TheCraiggers 13y agoI use a "dental device" on those nights that I remember to place it in my mouth, and typically I just give it a soak in some water with one of those denture cleaning tablets thrown in. Couldn't be much easier to clean. My assumption is that cleaning this device would be the same.
- sopooneo 13y agoThe refurbished point confused me. Does that mean they refurbish your own old one? If so, I would think that would alleviate most people's cootie fears. And if it's someone else's, how does that work? I thought they had to be custom created for each person's mouth.
- Theriac25 13y agoMaybe they should make custom cleaning brushes that are tailored to each tooth-brush they produce.
- jarel 13y agoBut how do you clean the cleaning brushes?
- Theriac25 13y agoBy making custom tooth-brush cleaning brush cleaning brushes that are tailored to each tooth-brush cleaning brush they produce?
- hamburglar 13y agoAt each iteration, the shape changes slightly, until eventually, the design stabilizes to a device that looks suspiciously like a turtle.
- jessaustin 13y agoSo you hypothesize that there exists a fixpoint for the cleaner function?
- koliber 13y agoIt would be shaped more-or-less like your teeth.
- brd 13y agoLets put aside the cleaning argument and discuss cost for a minute here. Its recommended you brush your teeth for ~2 minutes. Lets say with this thing you shorten it to 30 seconds. That means you save 3 minutes per day every day on brushing, assuming you brush twice daily. This works out to about 18 hours a year. If your time is more valuable than 17/hr it's arguably worth it. Time and time again I see people complain about the cost of daily use items but when you factor in how much you actually use them and the potential benefit you can get out of a them it quickly becomes worthwhile. edit: there is a huge difference between being maximizing productivity and measuring opportunity cost, I'm arguing the latter. I don't expect you to get paid another 18 hours a year. I'm simply pointing out that depending on how YOU value YOUR time spending $300 on a fancy toothbrush is entirely worth it.
- webjprgm 13y agoOnly if you'd be able to use those 3 minutes productively. You can't sit down at a computer and work for just a minute and a half, you'd have to be able to get to work a minute and a half sooner to capitalize on this. If you have a salaried job then this makes no difference.
- Zimahl 13y agoYou know, I see that argument all the time - 3 minutes here, 1 minute there. But I just wasted 5 minutes of my life where I zoned out staring at the ceiling. Sometimes you can justify 'wasting' 18 hours per year. Also, it's not like you stop thinking in those 3 minutes per day, you can still use that time for something constructive, even if that something isn't using your hands.
- 0ca0 13y agoThat's a bit of a simplification. When I brush my teeth, I am often doing something else as well. So it doesn't end up costing me 4 minutes of my free time every day.
- Osiris 13y agoYou are assuming that you'd use those extra 3 minutes a day doing something that's worth >$17/hr. In most cases, it probably just means hitting the sack 3 minutes early. I've always found these types of arguments perplexing because while 18 hours at one time can be used to great effect, 1.5 minutes at a time cannot. I waste that much time just flipping through the HN headlines, which I would not pay $17/hr to do.
- r0h1n 13y agoHow can a product that is "tailor-made to fit into a person's mouth using 3D scanning and 3D printing" be sold refurbished?
- Groxx 13y agoSpecifically to retainer cleaning, there is a huge difference between something that's in your mouth for 6 seconds daily and something that's in there for 16 hours. Retainers need constant cleaning to not smell like death. Your toothbrush does not, though it's in your mouth for longer than this one would be (seriously, go smell it. it's probably fine.).