7 ms·
Conscientiousness and online education
- VLM 13y agoI did a quick search of the linked article, did not find any historical analysis of conscientiousness as relates to all previous distance learning initiatives, from correspondence courses to radio classes to film-strips to VCR tapes to analog laserdiscs to multimedia cdroms. I'm assuming the brain has no magic way to respond differently to a video lecture delivered over analog NTSC on a PBS station in 1960 than to a .h264 file delivered over the internet in 2013. It would be interesting to know if this was all figured out WRT postal mail correspondence courses circa US civil war era or whatever.
- jerf 13y agoJust musing: Many of the learning methods you cited lack user control. If you miss something on PBS in 1960, you don't rewind it, you just lose. Same for most classroom experiences (except for the 10% who actually raise their hands). That's a difference big enough to matter. Postal mail correspondence sound like a interesting comparator, though. (I started with "valid"; it probably isn't. Online education also has the possibilities to incorporate a ton of extremely swift feedback. But at least interesting in terms of measuring the effects of conscientiousness.)
- VLM 13y agoGood points. Although even a brief comparison of similar yet somewhat inapplicable examples might be handy. I'm old enough to have spent considerable time doing interactive arithmetic drills on a Commodore PET... Other than not being online, and having much lower res graphics (as if that matters) I'm not sure if there is a difference in the last 30+ years in that small sub-genre, so that tiny sub-genre would be a good area to explore. Its still a good article, within its self imposed bounds. There's so much interesting / exciting stuff just barely over that boundary...
- nswanberg 13y agoIf you would like to read studies on self-paced learning with immediate feedback going back to the 1960s, search for "programmed instruction": http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=programmed+instruction http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=programmed+instruction
- gwern 13y ago> I'm assuming the brain has no magic way to respond differently to a video lecture delivered over analog NTSC on a PBS station in 1960 than to a .h264 file delivered over the internet in 2013. Besides the differences in image/sound quality, you have differences in how much interaction there is, and I don't know if any of those video lecture courses had equivalents to discussions forums or peer grading of assignments. And obviously any programming course (or course with automatable grading) wasn't going to be nearly as good. More importantly, the Big Five/OCEAN model wasn't nailed down until the 1980s, so you wouldn't expect to see any useful research examining Conscientiousness until then. (There might be MBTI studies since that came into use in the 1940s, but I think it's more or less junk...)
- hooande 13y agoThis article raises some interesting science fiction-y ideas. Quite a long and in depth read, but worth it because gwern's mind is one of our real treasures. Two things I found interesting: 1. If everyone in the world had the exact same Khan Academy style learning experience it would control all of the random factor associated with education. This means that the only differentiating factor would be raw intelligence, which is scary for those of us who were born as geniuses. 2. Conscientiousness (aka discipline or work ethic) is more important in online classes. So future Einsteins might be too bored by mundane assignments to take their work seriously. Improvements to IQ and personality testing might mitigate both of these problems in the future. If we can accurately measure a student's IQ we can give him or her harder or easier questions, essentially baking a curve into every assignment. Personality testing might yield the ability to identify students who are lacking Conscientiousness in order to target them with more interesting problems at a challenging pace. As usual, I think that machine learning and data science could lead to great benefits for everyone. This was an incredibly well researched piece that provided some interesting hypotheticals regarding online education. As Gwern points, out drastic technological changes rarely benefit everyone equally. Education tech is going to create some big winners and losers over the coming decades.
- VLM 13y ago"the only differentiating factor would be" And language / cultural stuff. I can't imagine trying to do trig or calculus with Roman numerals or Mayan numerals. And that's sticking to obvious math examples. There have been theories that (insert language) has always been superior for (insert hard science) because of inherent linguistic advantages. You haven't lived until you've heard William Shakespeares plays in their original Klingon and all that. I have a decent sorta-classical education and I find it much easier to read modern translations of ancient greeks than to try to puzzle thru Olde English. I do wonder about some subjects like somewhat advanced physics, is the "charm" factor of a subatomic particle "charm" when Chinese talk about it, or does it get localized? WRT making every assignment challenging, I was near the top of my class in most subjects in K12 and that would have driven me completely bonkers with the unfairness of it all. Teens are all, and always have been, a bundle of angst but I would go nuts if little Bobby Tables only had to power on the computer without hurting himself or the machine, but I had to write a malloc() function for the same assignment or similar. There's more than a little prison time mentality in contemporary K12 (intentionally?) and arbitrarily giving people hard time or easy time is going to make social issues. I would probably have gone on strike until grade 12 by coasting.
- dpatrick86 13y ago> if every child is in an environment that lets them develop and flourish to their fullest extent, then any remaining differences in their development will be due to hereditary factors! Well, almost! There's also variation in diet and other aspects that fall in the "nurture" category.
- dragonwriter 13y agoAll of those are part of the environment, and, consequently, addressed by the premise "if every child is in an environment that lets them develop and flourish to their fullest extent".
- wcbeard10 13y agoThis topic was also discussed on the most recent EconTalk episode [1] with Tyler Cowen. [1] http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2013/09/tyler_cowen_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2013/09/tyler_cowen_on.html
- gwern 13y agoIndeed! I actually have a whole laundry list of Cowen quotes I need to incorporate at some point - not just from that podcast, but also from his book _Make Your Own Economy_.
- strlen 13y agoWhile data is not the plural of anecdote, I've found the same things with friends who have taken MooCs or previously have followed along MIT OCW -- for some it has worked out very well, for others they fell prey to procrastination and taking easier routes. I've also noticed similar things in community colleges: I attended a community college and then transferred to a university; this saved me a great deal of money. My community college (De Anza) has been known as a "federal school" for UC Berkeley and UCLA, yet very few of my classmates took that route. I wondered why, but came to the same conclusion: unless you're strongly motivated and self-disciplined, it's too easy to fall through the cracks in a community college (no requirement to graduate by a certain date, no financial pressure, no residential learning, no exam study sessions, etc...). To me the desire to study upper division math/physics/EE/CS is what drove me; was already used to working independently and learning from textbooks. On the other hand, those who have always studied in groups, who didn't have quite a clear educational or career goals in mind tended, or who were not used to having clearly spelled out requirements ("you complete these classes in four years with this GPA, otherwise you can't get in" vs. "these sets of universities demand these classes and usually accept students these with these GPAs") would languish, either dropping out without transferring, transferring only after 4+ (3 years was very common), or doing poorly once they've transferred. As is think MOOCs and any other high-autonomy self-structured educational programs are of great benefit[1] to autodidacts with great motivation and self-discipline. However, nothing says they can't be combined with traditional teaching environment. As an example, consider the case of Calculus -- it's the foundation of all modern mathematics; you have to get it to study all even slightly quantitative disciplines from Computer Science to Political Science. Yet, we entrust its teaching to high-school AP (or IB for rest of the English speaking courses) teaches or graduate TAs. With MooCs we could have these classes taught by professors distinguished for their teaching ability, but conducted with the structure of a regular high-school/lower-division college environment. ... or take the case of a machine learning, a specialized and quickly evolving discipline. A small university might only have a single professor who specialized in it, but she may not have the resources to teach the class (or teach enough sections of the class). She would, however, likely have the resources to organize an experience around a MOOCs and assist the MOOC students.