3 ms·
"The point is that literature and art is a commodity" No, they are not commodities. Using the Wikipedia definition: "A commodity is something for which there i
by ThomPete 17y ago
"The point is that literature and art is a commodity"
No, they are not commodities. Using the Wikipedia definition: "A commodity is something for which there is demand, but which is supplied without qualitative differentiation across a market. It is a product that is the same no matter who produces it, such as petroleum, notebook paper, or milk."
"because of the low cost of producing and the almost zero cost of distribution"
Literature and art do not have a low cost of production for the writer or artist. They use their time in the creation of those works and are entitled to compensation if they choose to ask for it. Copyright law gives them a framework in which to ask for compensation; an artist can also choose to ask for nothing or some combination. I have done both with different 'works'.
I agree that the cost of reproduction and distribution is low for digital media. Shouldn't the artist be able to benefit from this situation? Surely, copyright law plus Internet actually helps an artist here.
"Further more you can skip the middle man which means that you need to make less money to make money."
I did this with my first book. Self-published, available for purchase on the web. What you miss there is marketing, that's hard and costs real money. Just because it's on the web doesn't mean that people know about it."
The product is a book. Once you enter it into the market it's not art anymore it just a product. If you want to call it anything but a product then you should sell it for 10 million. I know a lot of creators really believe they are doing more than just products but if they want to make money on it that is what they are doing and then that's a commodity the commodity of music, books whatever.
"Literature and art do not have a low cost of production for the writer or artist."
Of course they do which is why there have never been so many books today. If you are writing something truly extrodinary then you will make money on it but it's your choice. The world doesn't owe you anything. If you don't want it to be copied then don't try and sell it or sell it for an insane amount of money.
Furthermore the artist IS benefitting from that namely that it cost the artist 0,- to copy the book digitally.
"What you miss there is marketing, that's hard and costs real money."
No I don't miss that that is the point. It's not a right to get your book sold. It's a right to not have other people sell your book without your agreement but getting your marketing costs is not a right.