3 ms·
So, basically you feel that the situation of 'starving artists' is the way to go. You feel that it's better to limit the creation of artistic works to those who
by jgrahamc 17y ago
So, basically you feel that the situation of 'starving artists' is the way to go. You feel that it's better to limit the creation of artistic works to those who are either able to find another source of income, those lucky enough to have a benefactor or those who are so motivated that they'll live in essentially poverty.
I don't see how limiting the number of artists benefits society.
Also, you say that "someone else will write it". Try telling that to any great writer (which I am not). I bet they'll be really motivated to know that "hey, if you don't do it someone else will"
- omail 17y agoMost people who paint will not earn enough from their paintings to make a living from it. Yet many people still paint. This is with copyright protection in full force.
- jgrahamc 17y agoTotally agree. But will removing copyright protection fix that problem?
- ThomPete 17y agoCopyright protection IS the problem. It allows the RIAA to criminalize normal otherwise law abiding citizens. The sentences that we see today does in no way match up with the claimed crime. Today artist can argue lost revenue PLUS a penalty on top. That is hardly a fair way of treating the so called crime.
- jgrahamc 17y ago1. The issue of sentences is different from whether the law is worth having or not. It seems silly to me to decide that since current sentencing is harsh we should get rid of the law. 2. I do agree that the RIAA have been acting like idiots. I don't think they've even been acting in their own best interests.
- ThomPete 17y ago1. But it shows that something is completely wrong and needs to be changed, hence the Pirate Party 2. Yup
- omail 17y agoThat is completely irrelevant to the issue. Copyright law does not exist to guarantee an income. It exists to bolster creativity. In fact, it limits creativity. Here is an example. Disney made a fortune by adapting numerous fairy tales and folk tales, none of which were copyrighted. Yet, it is illegal to adapt Disney's works as they are all copyrighted.
- sp332 17y ago"You feel that it's better to limit the creation of artistic works to those who are either able to find another source of income...." What can I say? That's life. Either someone cares enough to do it, or it doesn't get done. My point is that there is plenty of motivation (internal and external) to do lots of kinds of work. We don't need artificial "protections" like copyright. As long as people want art and literature, it will get funded.
- req2 17y agoYou are not entitled to a life of your own choosing.
- dusklight 17y agoremoving copyright doesn't reduce the number of artists, it increases them, because more people are exposed to the art and more people will become inspired by it.
- cabalamat 17y ago> I don't see how limiting the number of artists benefits society. I don't see how DRM or 3-strikes laws benefit society. The Internet exists. Its purpose is to copy enormous amounts of data and sent it around the world quickly and cheaply; that's not a side-effect, it's what the net was designed to do. This spells death to business models based on selling copies of digital data. Society must therefore either accept that a good deal of unauthorised copying will take place, or it must castrate the Internet. It may harm society if artists earn less money; but it will harm socierty a lot more if we castrate the Internet.