3 ms·
From their manifesto: "All non-commercial acquiring, using, bettering and spread of culture should be actively encouraged. The Internet is filling the same fun
by jgrahamc 17y ago
From their manifesto:
"All non-commercial acquiring, using, bettering and spread of culture should be actively encouraged. The Internet is filling the same function today as popular education did a hundred years ago. It is something positive and good for the development of society.
The copyright legislation must be changes so that it is made perfectly clear that it only regulate use and copying of works done for commercial purposes. To share copies, or in any other way spread or use someone else’s work, should never be forbidden as long as it is done on an idealistic basis without the purposes of commercial gain."
So, what's the motivation for me the author of a book or software to actually write a book or software. Believe me that monetary gain is part of the motivation.
If you take this route and say that all works must be freely shared then you have to ask where 'artists' get their money from. If you do not give them a supply of some money then you end up going back to the middle ages and requiring that artists have benefactors who keep them alive.
Sharing a copy of my 'work' may well be non-commercial for the sharer, but it's not non-commercial for me. In fact, I may well have lost money (of course, there are some people who would never have spent the money in the first place).
And the idealistic part about cultural works being good for people seems valid to me, that's why we have art galleries, museums, education and libraries (of books, CDs and DVDs) funded with public money.
- sp332 17y agoIf you don't care enough about writing the book, just don't write it. Someone who cares (is internally motivated) enough, will write it or pay you to write it for them (external motivation). We don't necessarily need legislation to create an extra, artificial external motivation for artists, authors, etc. Writers will write, artists will express themselves, and the world will benefit with or without copyrights.
- mynameishere 17y agoYou're just wrong. Off the top of my head Dostoevsky and Sam Johnson and Charles Dickens all openly wrote for the money. I don't doubt that almost all authors do, without being so open about it.
- jgrahamc 17y agoHemingway
- ThomPete 17y agoThen they are business people and and their products should be judged by the commodity it is not by their wish to make money.
- sp332 17y agoI didn't say they couldn't make money! Actually the opposite, I meant some artists could still make money without copyright. Copyright != making a living.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mynameishere 17y agoI'm not going to spend a lot of time researching this, but I know Beethoven had a publisher for his sheet music, and I'm guessing that it was protected like anything else. Not the point. The business model back then was based around patronage, whether by the church or aristocrats. I'll also guess that the people who voted for the pirate party don't want a move in that direction.
- jgrahamc 17y agoThe "Statute of Anne" (original establishment of something like copyright in British law) dates to 1709 and established exclusive rights on works for a period of IIRC 21 years. Bach died in 1750; Mozart was born in 1756; Beethoven was born in 1770.
- req2 17y agoFrom the long title of the Statute of Anne, "Copies of Printed Books in the Authors or purchasers of such Copies". In other words, the Statute of Anne protected publishers of books. Not musicians.
- jgrahamc 17y agoSo, basically you feel that the situation of 'starving artists' is the way to go. You feel that it's better to limit the creation of artistic works to those who are either able to find another source of income, those lucky enough to have a benefactor or those who are so motivated that they'll live in essentially poverty. I don't see how limiting the number of artists benefits society. Also, you say that "someone else will write it". Try telling that to any great writer (which I am not). I bet they'll be really motivated to know that "hey, if you don't do it someone else will"
- omail 17y agoMost people who paint will not earn enough from their paintings to make a living from it. Yet many people still paint. This is with copyright protection in full force.
- jgrahamc 17y agoTotally agree. But will removing copyright protection fix that problem?
- ThomPete 17y agoCopyright protection IS the problem. It allows the RIAA to criminalize normal otherwise law abiding citizens. The sentences that we see today does in no way match up with the claimed crime. Today artist can argue lost revenue PLUS a penalty on top. That is hardly a fair way of treating the so called crime.
- jgrahamc 17y ago1. The issue of sentences is different from whether the law is worth having or not. It seems silly to me to decide that since current sentencing is harsh we should get rid of the law. 2. I do agree that the RIAA have been acting like idiots. I don't think they've even been acting in their own best interests.
- wlievens 17y agoDesigning a system based on the assumption of internal motivation is like fighting crime by asking people to just be nice. You need incentives, positive and negative, to base any system on, especially one with millions of actors: an economy.
- sp332 17y agoAre you saying that, without laws, people would never get out of bed in the morning? Some people are self-motivated to do crime, some to do more productive things.
- wlievens 17y agoI'm saying that it's a bad basis for society to assume people behave efficiently (in a socio-economical context) without the right incentives. And I don't mean to make that sound like there's an ogre whipping them. Suggested reading: Freakonomics :-)
- req2 17y agoCrime is a zero sum game. That is enough to need disincentives for crime. No one is really worse off if Dylan decides to stop recording.
- Zaak 17y agoI would say that crime is most often a negative sum game. For example, a person pays tens of thousands of dollars getting a lead roof installed. Another person comes along and steals the lead from the roof and sells it as scrap for a few hudred dollars. Value has been destroyed, both because the lead was more valuable as a roof than as scrap, and also because of the damage to the building which happened because it was no longer protected from the weather.
- poppysan 17y agoI think top level copyright laws are essential... ie duplication of this material either without purchase or for monetary gain is strictly prohibited. But that's where it should stop. Leave it up to individual companies and their products to handle how they prevent unwanted distribution. That leads to better DRM (although ppl hate it, it should still be explored), more efficient or direct methods of transferring their projects to a consumer, and new innovations to protect their works. Its the same argument they had when VHS tapes arrived. Then came macrovision and other creative ways to either lower copy quality or distort it completely.
- stse 17y agoI think it should be easier to create things, not harder. We should stimulate creation, experimentation, research, remixing and refinement. Copyright laws makes it harder then it should be to create things. Creativity should not be limited by copyright. Having commercial exclusivity for 50, 100 or 200 years won't make creation any easier for original author or any other person following. Being able to make some money is an incentive for certain types of works, and you should also be able to do that in the future. But for most people it not about that, how large a percent of books are really making a lot of money after 10 years? The unpopular are forgotten and the popular are already in paperback with small profit margins. And if there are some books that make a lot of money after 10 years, isn't there already a sequel? And if there isn't, wouldn't it be better to stimulate the creation of one? For most people who are in favor of copyright, it's not about making money, it's about control. Control of information. Society should not accept the control of public information. Ideas, knowledge and information have their value in their non-exclusivity. The Pirate Party is the only group I found who stand up for the right to personal development. To be able to educate yourself with free information. And that, to me, is a really powerful concept.
- jacoblyles 17y ago>"If you don't care enough about writing the book, just don't write it. Someone who cares (is internally motivated) enough, will write it or pay you to write it for them (external motivation). We don't necessarily need legislation to create an extra, artificial external motivation for artists, authors, etc. Writers will write, artists will express themselves, and the world will benefit with or without copyrights." Meanwhile, the most popular pirated materials are movies that big studios spent hundreds of millions of dollars to make, in hopes of earning a profit. Pirates are leeches that kill their hosts.
- illumen 17y agoMarketing budget. Most of the money spent is on the marketing. Surprised that all that marketing and advertising money worked? Many good films never get seen because of low marketing budgets - and are even not allowed good distribution. These businesses with offices disguising themselves as 'studios' are the leeches.
- jacoblyles 17y agoAnd those are the films that pirates want to see. To pretend that they are sticking up for the little guy is to deliberately close our eyes to reality.
- wlievens 17y agoI think what's positive about them getting a seat is that the issue gets attention and the debate is brought into public view a bit more. Their proposed solutions are probably a bit... absurd.
- ThomPete 17y agoThe point is that literature and art is a commodity because of the low cost of producing and the almost zero cost of distribution. In other words prizes are not reflecting the cost of this new reality. Further more you can skip the middle man which means that you need to make less money to make money. You are not loosing money if someone copies a version of your product and give it to a friend. You lost an opportunity to make more money which is completely different.
- jgrahamc 17y ago"The point is that literature and art is a commodity" No, they are not commodities. Using the Wikipedia definition: "A commodity is something for which there is demand, but which is supplied without qualitative differentiation across a market. It is a product that is the same no matter who produces it, such as petroleum, notebook paper, or milk." "because of the low cost of producing and the almost zero cost of distribution" Literature and art do not have a low cost of production for the writer or artist. They use their time in the creation of those works and are entitled to compensation if they choose to ask for it. Copyright law gives them a framework in which to ask for compensation; an artist can also choose to ask for nothing or some combination. I have done both with different 'works'. I agree that the cost of reproduction and distribution is low for digital media. Shouldn't the artist be able to benefit from this situation? Surely, copyright law plus Internet actually helps an artist here. "Further more you can skip the middle man which means that you need to make less money to make money." I did this with my first book. Self-published, available for purchase on the web. What you miss there is marketing, that's hard and costs real money. Just because it's on the web doesn't mean that people know about it.
- ThomPete 17y ago"The point is that literature and art is a commodity" No, they are not commodities. Using the Wikipedia definition: "A commodity is something for which there is demand, but which is supplied without qualitative differentiation across a market. It is a product that is the same no matter who produces it, such as petroleum, notebook paper, or milk." "because of the low cost of producing and the almost zero cost of distribution" Literature and art do not have a low cost of production for the writer or artist. They use their time in the creation of those works and are entitled to compensation if they choose to ask for it. Copyright law gives them a framework in which to ask for compensation; an artist can also choose to ask for nothing or some combination. I have done both with different 'works'. I agree that the cost of reproduction and distribution is low for digital media. Shouldn't the artist be able to benefit from this situation? Surely, copyright law plus Internet actually helps an artist here. "Further more you can skip the middle man which means that you need to make less money to make money." I did this with my first book. Self-published, available for purchase on the web. What you miss there is marketing, that's hard and costs real money. Just because it's on the web doesn't mean that people know about it." The product is a book. Once you enter it into the market it's not art anymore it just a product. If you want to call it anything but a product then you should sell it for 10 million. I know a lot of creators really believe they are doing more than just products but if they want to make money on it that is what they are doing and then that's a commodity the commodity of music, books whatever. "Literature and art do not have a low cost of production for the writer or artist." Of course they do which is why there have never been so many books today. If you are writing something truly extrodinary then you will make money on it but it's your choice. The world doesn't owe you anything. If you don't want it to be copied then don't try and sell it or sell it for an insane amount of money. Furthermore the artist IS benefitting from that namely that it cost the artist 0,- to copy the book digitally. "What you miss there is marketing, that's hard and costs real money." No I don't miss that that is the point. It's not a right to get your book sold. It's a right to not have other people sell your book without your agreement but getting your marketing costs is not a right.
- stse 17y agoA book is a poor example from a motivation point of view, as most authors (in Sweden) can't make a living just being an author. Maybe you should ask one of the three well renowned Swedish authors who publicly supports The Pirate Party. (Linda Skugge, Uni Drougge or Lars Gustafsson). I always wonder what world the people who ask these kinds of question live in. Because sharing of copyrighted works has been widespread for nearly a decade now and it is still, at least here in Sweden, almost impossible to get caught. Still somehow authors, artist and others find the motivation to make things. If non-commercial sharing has such a large impact on the creation of new things, wouldn't we have noticed by now? If anything, copyright limits creativity in so many ways. In Sweden we don't even have fair use of images and there is still silent films which won't be free for another 30 years or so. Today making new things are not encouraged, today making one thing, and then exploit it, is encouraged.
- jgrahamc 17y ago"Maybe you should ask one of the three well renowned Swedish authors who publicly supports The Pirate Party. (Linda Skugge, Uni Drougge or Lars Gustafsson)." It amuses me when wealthy people support ideas that they find appealing after they have become wealthy from the opposite of those ideas. I'd rather ask an unknown Swedish author.
- stse 17y agoI think you missed the point. Being a well renowned author in Sweden does not, in most cases, equal wealth. As I said only a few authors make a living being an author. Most of the authors who actually gets wealthy have started their own publishing company or other related businesses, like public speaking or magazine.
- Tichy 17y agoIt is very difficult to make money by SELLING a book - whether you can monetarize the reputation you gain from writing a book is another matter. But I am pretty sure monetary gain from book sales is not the main motivation for most authors (at least for non-fiction books).
- chez17 17y ago"So, what's the motivation for me the author of a book or software to actually write a book or software. Believe me that monetary gain is part of the motivation." So you never lent a friend a book? Never borrowed a movie from someone? Have you ever burned a CD for a friend or received one? I would bet you answered "yes" to one of those questions. How is that any different?
- jgrahamc 17y agoThe answers to those questions are yes, yes and no. Lending != Copying.
- mixmax 17y agoInterestingly the exact same arguments can be applied to open source software.
- spot 17y agoI certainly agree with you that for the economy to work we need a way for (say) authors to make money. But technological change requires adaptation. Just like we ask factory workers to retrain in the face of machine automation, information workers need to adopt to the internet. There are plenty of options: advertising, server/service systems, and customization to name a few. Printing and copyright are just a blip in history. Enforcing copyright in the internet age has a giant social cost that has become larger than its benefit. As this technology develops further and people realize its potential, the Pirate Party will grow.
- dusklight 17y agoWell think about it this way. Status Quo right now, you get only a very small percentage of the actual profits that your work makes -- the rest goes to your distributors. The internet allows you to significantly cut the costs of distribution and thus increase the percentage profits to yourself. We see in the new business model that there are still plenty of ways to make money even if copyright doesn't exist. Bloggers make money from advertising, Chinese pop singers (where piracy > 90%) make money from concerts and endorsement deals. It's been possible for a long time to make prints and posters of famous artwork for cheap, yet famous original artworks still sell for millions of dollars.
- randallsquared 17y agoSo, what's the motivation for me the author of a book or software to actually write a book or software. Believe me that monetary gain is part of the motivation. Of course it is. There are a bunch of ways to make money without copyright, as I'm sure you're aware (and having "artists have benefactors" is one of them, but far from the only one). The problem you see is that you think that you won't make as much money, or that you have a lower probability of making money. Frankly, if you can't figure out how to make money in the free market from your writing, it's not up to us to enact laws to provide you with an income (or a higher probability of an income), even indirectly through copyright.