2 ms·
Then let's try this again. How do energy/transportation costs make Mars the natural industrial hub of the Solar System? You have made a hypothesis, now justify
by dalke 13y ago
Then let's try this again.
How do energy/transportation costs make Mars the natural industrial hub of the Solar System? You have made a hypothesis, now justify it.
I can come up with no scenario where that's possible in the next 200 years. Indeed, the only way I can do it is to have a sizable population on Mars first, so it builds upon its own internal economy rather than through any sort of trade. It's expensive to get people from Earth to Mars, and there needs to be a big enough population to be self-supporting, even in terms of education and training, so we're talking generations to get to that point.
And if we can put a nucleus of 10,000 people on Mars, to start that colony, then we'll have developed Earth-to-orbit technologies a lot better than we have now.
The explanation you gave - "based on energy/transportation costs" - has not a good predictor of industrial control in world history. Why should it be a given in the Solar System's future history? What is the essential difference between space and ground?
At the very least, you have to show that life-support costs do not dominate the equation. Why wouldn't we have automated mines on Mars, with at most a skeleton oversight crew? Why is it economically more feasible to have a self-supporting colony instead?
Over and over again, in reading about asteroid mining and Lunar and Martian colonization, the answer I read is at best "we have no idea if it's economically feasible" and more often "not economically feasible". While you posit that the answer is obviously weighted in favor of Mars, and not in need of further explanation.
Give me at least a vaguely reasonable scenario for how Mars becomes the natural industrial hub of the Solar System. Otherwise you're handwaving your religion at me.
And for any argument you give, explain why the Moon isn't a better choice.
- stcredzero 13y ago> And if we can put a nucleus of 10,000 people on Mars, to start that colony, then we'll have developed Earth-to-orbit technologies a lot better than we have now. If your argument depends on this, it is already flawed. > The explanation you gave - "based on energy/transportation costs" - has not a good predictor of industrial control in world history. Actually, it was quite a good predictor up to the earlier part of the industrial revolution. It does a nice job of explaining where the industrial centers of the northeastern US appeared. Technologies developed in the industrial revolution are the very ones that changed this situation. > ...the answer is obviously weighted in favor of Mars Read The Case for Mars. I don't have the time or desire to discuss this with you in particular.