5 ms·
Oh boy are you looking at this wrong. Only someone from a western country with a middle class wage could so utterly fail to distinguish between a choice between
by simonh 13y ago
Oh boy are you looking at this wrong. Only someone from a western country with a middle class wage could so utterly fail to distinguish between a choice between two costs in resources to a choice between a cost of resources and one of no resources.
Think of this another way. How many chocolates can you afford at a cost of $0.20 each? How many can you afford at a cost of $0.10 each? Now, how many can you afford at a cost of $0.00 each? The experiment artificially avoids this by manufacturing a situation in which purchasers only had a one-time choice, but the purchasers didn't necessarily know it was a on-time deal. For all they know, they may be faced with the same choice every time they go back to that store, even if it was advertised as a one-time deal. We get on-time offers pushed at us all the time these days.
So, is a marginal decrease in cost of $0.10 equivalent in both circumstances? Of course not. A cost in resources is always a cost. A cost of no resources is not a cost at all. Comparing two different costs is completely different to comparing a cost with no cost at all. To understand this, instead of adding costs together over a few transactions, try multiplying them by many decisions instead and you'll see that multiplying by zero has some very special advantages when it comes to resource preservation.
What I think is happening is that analyses like the above are considering only individual translations, but App store users download many apps. Multiplying costs over many purchases, even small costs balloon while free is always free no matter how outrageously you indulge your App store downloading habit.
That's without taking into account that not everybody considers buying a cup of coffee in Starbucks something that requires no thought or consideration. I certainly don't think that way for a start.
- r0h1n 13y agoSorry, but I found the parent's comment much more insightful, lucid and relevant to the point being discussed (why a large majority always seems to prefer free apps over paid ones) than yours. And the utterly pointless ad hominem attack right at the beginning didn't help either. You also seem to have mixed up "price" with "cost" at places. For instance I don't quite know what these lines mean: > a choice between two costs in resources to a choice between a cost of resources and one of no resources (what do you mean by resources? Whose resources?) > a marginal decrease in cost of $0.10 (the cost of the chocolate is borne by its manufacturer while a consumer pays the price) I'm sure you have a valid counterpoint in there somewhere, but it's not clear what it is.
- digitalengineer 13y ago>App store users download many apps. Multiplying costs over many purchases, even small costs balloon while free is always free I had not thought about this one. But it is correct and explains the resoning of consumers.
- r0h1n 13y agoSure, it's an explanation. But I find no evidence to believe that it is the only explanation. Or even that it is a better explanation than the parent's (that people behave irrationally when presented with anything "free").
- droidist2 13y agoTo me it's about the stress of decision-making. I like simply saying "hey, let me check out _____ type of app" then doing a search and downloading up to a half dozen different ones just to try out. On the other hand if I had to pay a few bucks for an app I'd probably spend a while reading the descriptions, reviews, weighing options, etc. It would turn into work.
- sp332 13y agoThe experiment artificially avoids this by manufacturing a situation in which purchasers only had a one-time choice Well how many times are you going to download the same free app? And how many free apps can you really stomach having crowding up your phone all at once?
- terhechte 13y agoI'm not sure I really understand what you're trying to say, but it really thinks as if you're proving my point: What I wanted to say was that the difference between $0 and $1 is entirely different to the user than the difference between $1 and $2. Just like you say, you're not investing any resources for the $0 case. However, from a purely rational perspective, it looks like this: Imagine that the quality of the chocolate is a utility-function. The cheap chocolate doesn't taste good, so you only gain 0.1 points of utility on a scale from 0 - 1. The Lind chocolate tastes really great, it makes you smile and happy, it has a utility of 0.3. In this case, if you decide to buy Lind instead of Hershey's, you are willing to pay $0.10 more than what's necessary in order to gain more utility. The added value of the better chocolate has a worth of $0.10 which you're willing to pay. In the free case, the utility is the same, and the price difference is the same, so if you, earlier, were willing to pay an added $0.10 for the added utility, you should still be willing to pay an added $0.10. But of course, when there is a free alternative, people don't. You're outlining some of the reasons for that, and they all make sense, I'm just saying that this is standard human behaviour which affects the realities of the app store even though it is not rational. On a Micro Level, human beings are oftentimes not rational at all and this is a good example of that. Btw. there is a limitation in the study: People could only buy the chocolate once, so even if it is free, you could not take 100. So the no-resources point does not totally explain the behaviour either. There does not need to be a logical explanation to this anyway, it may be something that's still stuck from the Lizard Brain that's causing this.
- danenania 13y agoI think the point is that even if it's only a one time study, a default strategy of preferring free to paid can be rational since we participate in a huge number of transactions in daily life. You are viewing this as an irrational sacrifice of quality for $0.10, but it's really a question of longterm strategy, even if the calculation is done on a subconscious level.
- JohnTHaller 13y agoThe point of the original experiment was to have the charges be near-zero but tiered with respect to the other items available. It could easily be adapted to another country and currency. And it wasn't a buy as many as you want thing, it was a one-time-only deal offered in the checkout line. So, it's not about multiplying zero. It's about a single instance. Free breaks the logic of most people.