3 ms·
you are right - for any given expected unit sales, there is a level where using C first time is sensible. But ultimately there is always a market below that po
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
you are right - for any given expected unit sales, there is a level where using C first time is sensible.
But ultimately there is always a market below that point - people are selling arduinos now for surveillance or monitoring simply because the market is too small for anyone skilled enough in C to bother.
As the price performance of the hardware drops more of these markets will open up - today the "stuff it use C" point is maybe a 100 units or a thousand. tomorrow a million. then 10 million.
Forgive my hardware ignorance but imagine a system on a chip with the cpu and memory and buses of say today's MacBook Air. everything you want, on a thumbnail, just hook up electricity. If I could buy that for 2 cents I would be foolish if I decided to write almost anything in C till I got real time stats from my first 5 million users.
Twitter did not drop Ruby for Java till they were at the billions of messages level. There are an awful lot of markets and price points between 1000 units and a billion units.
(Especially now when we can realistically talk about every human being having a hand held in x years. which blows my mind but for good reasons)
ps - no I do not think Moores law will hold in terms of transistors in a chip for evermore. but we have barely scratched the surface of "everything on a chip".
(Would be interested on the feasibility of literally a PC on a chip ? If we took a literal count of transistors on say a model two years old and then looked at price to fab that many transistors today what would we see?)
edit: rereading it seems to indicate that there is hardware out there were C is the sensible option - I am just trying to say there is a spectrum of / 8 bit assembler / embedded C-like / DSLs / anything a PC might recognise and that climbing that spectrum is inevitable based on hardware price/performance
- jamwt 13y ago> ultimately there is always a market below that point - people are selling arduinos now for surveillance or monitoring simply because the market is too small for anyone skilled enough in C to bother. I agree, and this could be interesting for some of those small volume domains--but their copy in the slide deck is broadly encompassing and far reaching, implying mass-market products like Nest. I'm just taking them at their word and addressing that application.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI argue that each tick of Moore's clock will open up another order of magnitude sized market for just their proposition.
- rapind 13y agoMoore's law doesn't apply to batteries. There's nothing stopping you from putting the MBA chip in a phone... except energy consumption. If your program in javascript takes 14 times as long to run than the equivalent C version and yet still manages to be performant from a user experience perspective, then you'd better be close to an outlet because we're talking about a beefy and energy hungry processor. There's a sweet spot related to programming effort and power consumption. I don't think Javascript can hit that sweet spot yet for most devices. I'd argue that the same problem, but to a lesser degree, is present in other non-mobile devices. I'll buy the one that costs $20 more but costs me $20 less per year on my energy bill. I think we may even see a bit of a reversal in the current trend of programmer productivity over program efficiency. Clusters of cheap multi-core servers consume significant energy.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI remember mobile phones that had to be kept in the car because the batteries were like dumbbells. we lived with it because it was what we wanted. There are going to be physical limits to battery technology, to processing power, all of these things. but those limits are not upon us yet and I have a suspicion the true physical limits lie in a place that will make us 20th century simpletons look like slack jawed savages. I'm betting on science, bitches !
- RogerL 13y agoSo, your conjecture is that physics will continue, but our appetite for new features will plateau? I don't buy that, personally; in fact I think it is exactly the opposite. I want a calendar program that is smarter than me, I want search that understands my tastes in restaurants, shoes, books. I want sw that immediately translates, perfectly and idiomatically, any language. I want to talk to my phone. I want it to compose music for me. I want a pony (okay, that last one is a different list). Now, we do know one limit - the human brain fits in an X sized area, and requires Y sized plumbing and energy store to accomplish what it does. My feature requests exceeds what any one brain can do. I'd be astonished if we could shrink that to phone sized, but maybe, just maybe. At that time we can renew this conversation. Until then, burning batteries, and running data centers, matters. Until then, C (or a safer version thereof) matters.