8 ms·
Gartner tells IT shops that it's 'game over' for BlackBerry
- chayesfss 13y agoHey Gartner, Dell dude got busted selling pot...
- sambeau 13y agoSerious Question: Why does anyone care what Gartner think? I have worked with companies that cared more about getting into some quadrant of some Gartner graph than they cared about the quality of their products. Is Gartner more than just a corporate badge? Do they purely provide the wall for the giant corporate pissing contest?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- toyg 13y agoIt's all about managers in BigCos. Barely literate as they are, they hardly read anything at all; Gartner reports (well, their summaries anyway) are among the few things they do consider. If you are in the right quadrant, you can say so while playing golf and get the manager to sign a big check for your s*it. He'll never actually use it himself anyway, it will just be forced on his underlings.
- xradionut 13y agoCompanies have been made and destroyed on the golf course. It's a reality that sucks.
- klausjensen 13y agoI was recently involved in a proof of concept for a rolebased access control tool for an enterprise, and we read the Gartner reports on the topic, where they evaluate the products in the space. The tool we were primarily looking at, we could hardly recognize from Gartner's description - it was filled with factual errors. Make you wonder what the quality of other Garner reports are... Edit: Typo
- yogo 13y agoI'm not 100% sure how the process works but from what I've seen, when the analyst is examining a company or product they work mostly with the website and other marketing materials, which makes it possible for the tool to do one thing while marketing copy says otherwise. That information is probably coupled with revenue, maybe some news analytics and relationship with the analyst to come up with the final determination. I believe how it works is still a secret but I'd sure love to know more about how it really works.
- mbesto 13y agoTo answer your question - Yes, they do. I call this "shifting the burden of responsibility"[1] and it basically boils down to this - imagine you're an IT manager and your boss says "Should we support Blackberry anymore?" Who is the authority to say whether the answer is Yes or No to this question? If you (the IT manager) think you are...What happens when you're wrong? Hence why you simply shift this over to someone or some organization who has established themselves as the authority. This is why the analyst industry exists. [1] - http://www.techdisruptive.com/2013/07/18/shifting-the-burden-of-responsibility/ http://www.techdisruptive.com/2013/07/18/shifting-the-burden...
- sambeau 13y agoIn my experience it isn't the IT managers who trust Gartner —it's the IT-managers' managers. Is this just because non-IT managers don't trust what IT managers say? If so then this is a case of shifting the burden of responsibility of “shifting the burden of responsibility”. Non-IT managers blame IT managers for their use of analysts as a comfort blanket. I realise there are analysts for all kinds of industry but I can't think of another example where analysts wield the kind of power that Gartner hold over the IT industry.
- mbesto 13y agoI think you're slightly taking my example too pedantically. In any case... > Is this just because non-IT managers don't trust what IT managers say? Yes, but the non-IT managers are even more uninformed. Everyone at some point is to blame, unless you can point that blame outside of your organization. Imagine this conversation going all the way up to the CEO. "But Gartner said to stop supporting Blackberry" holds some good value to her. > Non-IT managers blame IT managers for their use of analysts as a comfort blanket. I'm sort of confused by this comment, is this a statement you're trying to make? Either way, as you said, the key decision maker is usually the non-IT managers (usually at VP level or higher). > I realise there are analysts for all kinds of industry but I can't think of another example where analysts wield the kind of power that Gartner hold over the IT industry. I don't know many other industries that (1) have so many solutions (2) available to them globally (3) at so many different price points (4) with such a complexity of features. Finance rings a bell, but the competition is much higher. Some good comments about the woes of the analyst industry in big tech: http://blog.softwareinsider.org/2013/08/09/personal-log-the-sad-state-of-the-industry-analyst-business-and-the-need-for-a-code-of-ethics/ http://blog.softwareinsider.org/2013/08/09/personal-log-the-...
- wglb 13y agoIt is paid significant attention to in the Big Freaking Enterprise. And by those who would sell to the BFE.
- ig1 13y agoGartner quadrants are like the App Store for enterprise software. When you're tasked with choosing say an app for handling Supply Chain Management often you're first step is looking at the Gartner report for that space because it gives you a good market overview of who the major players are in that space and how they relate. Hence Gartner coverage can be a great channel for acquiring b2b enterprise customers. It also helps establish credibility. Someones not going to buy a product just because a Gartner paper, but it provides a starting point for evaluating vendors. Similarly no company is going to look at this and stop using Blackberry tomorrow, but it puts evaluating BB usage/potential migration onto their radar.
- harichinnan 13y agoGartner reports are the basis for big corp software evaluations(Wal-Mart's and the banks). If you have to sell software to fortune 500 clients, getting into the gartner quadrant is a must to be considered for evaluation. Gartner publishes magic quadrants for B2B markets(even niche ones).
- andor 13y agoClassy move, Gartner. Did you just move from the bullshit quadrant to the racket quadrant?
- jpswade 13y agohttp://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9242808/BlackBerry_responds_to_Gartner_s_call_for_clients_to_ditch_BB_products_ http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9242808/BlackBerry_re...
- fvrghl 13y agoWho will take over enterprise phones now? Microsoft will definitely try, but how will Apple and Android compete for this space?
- gnaffle 13y agoAndroid and Apple already do compete for this space. They both provide provisioning, encrypted storage, VPN, exchange support and remote wipe, and that's pretty much what 90% of the enterprise needs.
- oellegaard 13y agoWhat a joke. It's like stating AltaVista is 'game over'.
- rdl 13y agoI am kind of pissed that Microsoft hasn't been hitting the Enterprise Phone hard. I have a lot of people I consult for on mobile sec stuff who are still on bb7, never will BYOD, and who need something essentially bb7 equivalent for secure email/messaging/etc. They were willing to tolerate RIM as a partner due to the extensive security audits and certification of the platform, but probably wouldn't trust Apple or Google with the ability to push arbitrary code to their devices.
- gnaffle 13y agoAt least with Apple, I'm pretty sure that if you're an enterprise customer you can run the entire provisioning / update service in-house, including specifying which apps are allowed and how/when they should be updated. I know at least a few big enterprises with high security risk (banks, oil companies) that have allowed iPhones on their networks.
- Terretta 13y agoWith iOS 7 supporting per-app VPN, you can couple that with corporate provisioning to require particular apps for company email, messaging, file markup, and require those apps to only work over the company VPN. What's more, given that Microsoft is known to have shipped backdoored code, and known to have been the fastest to cooperate with NSA etc., it's not clear where your last sentence comes from, that someone would trust MSFT code before Apple and Google code. That said, yes, Windows phone absolutely should have had an enterprise push to appeal to the IT crowd depending on Active Directory, Exchange, Sharepoint, etc. They should have sidestepped the iOS vs Android battle and defined a "blue ocean" strategy with two prongs: (1) corporate/enterprise (targeting IT departments and white collar wage earners), (2) feature/smart phones (targeting kids in those households). While iOS and Android (as seen in Apple, Samsung, and Droid adverts) are competing to be fiercely individualist choices, MSFT should have gone after groups/communities/companies/families. Groupware is a recognized Microsoft strength.
- rdl 13y agoThe kind of people still using BB7 (in the US/UK/CA are likely to strongly trust NSA, so MS NSA backdoors aren't really a problem; NSA IA review is a feature for them. I agree iOS 7 has the best security and security functionality right now of iOS or Android, but there isn't a single out of the box solution which does what BES/bb7 provides. Setting up Apple's config manager is a pain, and the commercial MDM products aren't amazing.
- danielweber 13y agoIt's amazing that BlackBerry can sell almost 6 million phones a quarter and be considered a failure. Sure, other products vastly outsell it and it's been "defeated" in a product category it created. But in most other markets moving 6 million units of a product that costs over $100, in just 3 months, ought to mean you get to stick around indefinitely, at least as a niche player.
- brk 13y agoMaybe... What is their sales trend though? I haven't bothered to look into myself, but based on what we see and hear, my assumption would be that BB sales are going down. There are still lots of legacy BB shops, and those shops are still hiring new employees, replacing lost or outdated phones and so forth. BB may be selling 6 million units per quarter, but if they are losing marketshare rapidly (as they appear to be), those sales most likely aren't worth much. Additionally, if they are staffed up for 20 million units a month (eg: tons of office space, lots of personnel), then 6 million is not enough to sustain the company. We've already seen signs of this in the form of massive layoffs. Also, this isn't a market where you can stagnate, so they won't be around indefinitely unless they have the R&D team to keep pace with new trends, plus create a couple of innovations.
- gnaffle 13y agoThat's exactly the right question to ask. When they were selling 15M phones a year or two ago, selling 5-6M M phones today is a disaster, especially when the trend continues downward after releasing the BB10 which was supposed to "save" BlackBerry. Then add the fact that they had to take a big loss on unsold BB10 inventory, and the picture is pretty bleak. They can probably stick around for a long time as a niche player, but that's not going to provide the kind of big returns that the investors expect.
- danielweber 13y ago"Bad deal for investors" is something I can't disagree with. I sure wouldn't put any money in them. This doesn't mean that they're going to go out of business and everyone needs to race to abandon ship, though.
- jlebrech 13y agoi'd buy an android Q10 in a heartbeat.
- Pxtl 13y agoZ10, too. BB10 devices are beautiful, they're just duct-taped to a dead-end OS and came too late to save the company. Also, going with non-discoverable gesture-based navigation was a doomed idea. I get what they're going for, but when you're scrambling to keep your users you don't want to create that kind of huge barrier for them. If only. Even if BBOS was forked from an old version of android (like, 2.3 or something) you'd still have some baseline of compatibility, a place to build an ecosystem.
- jlebrech 13y agothey could have made BBOS a fork like kindle os is.
- beedogs 13y agoHas Netcraft confirmed it too?
- S_A_P 13y agoI work in an industry where Gartner used to maintain a magic quadrant. (C/ETRM software) I worked closely with the marketing director to fill out the questionnaire that Gartner sent. Iirc it was about 20 questions that asked about key functionality and product road maps. It literally was about 2 days (8 working hours) of back and forth between marketing, myself, product managers and c-level employees. They filled this sheet out, sent it off and forgot about it. From 20 pretty generic questions that ended up being answered with some pretty fluffy and marketing jargon laden bullshit, Gartner is able to tell if someone is a market leading software vendor or not. It's total bullshit. It turns out that it was just 1 guy doing this quadrant as when he left, Gartner stopped doing it(at least that is what I e been told) The company I worked at even sent 8 people to the Gartner conference in an effort to boost visibility and hopefully quadrant status. I can't believe anyone would take it seriously, let alone base a purchasing decision from it.
- mathattack 13y agoI view them like the ratings agencies. They exist because someone has to fill a void. For the ratings agencies, there is a void where people who don't have a lot of financial knowledge are placed on top of large sums of money. One could argue they shouldn't, but they're there, so they need someone to give them guidance on investments. Gartner exists similarly because there is a void in organizations and their knowledge of technology. In the absence of Gartner, the un-tech-savvy CIOs just buy from whoever they play golf with. We could argue that all CIOs should be hands on current in all the relevant technology, but that's not the world we live in. An interesting question would be, "What's the return on investment in getting into the right quadrant?" It truly is a marketing decision that should be compared alongside advertising, conference attendance and direct mail.
- mbubb 13y agoWhat does the President use these days?