6 ms·
The threat that Lodsys represents to anyone doing technology is so large that it would seem to make sense to band together. I'm thinking along the lines of crea
by javajosh 13y ago
The threat that Lodsys represents to anyone doing technology is so large that it would seem to make sense to band together. I'm thinking along the lines of creating a "Patent Defense Cooperative" where members pay a certain amount every month for the three purposes of a) patent lawsuit insurance, b) to fund lobbying efforts to reform the patent system, and c) scrutinize a judicial apparatus that seems biased in favor of patent trolls.
I would certainly join such an organization as an individual inventor and technologist. This can't be a new idea. Has anyone else thought of doing this?
- randomfool 13y agoSweet- so Apple can join this and infringe on anyone's patents and get their legal bills paid for? Seriously though, it would have to have some clear definition of patent troll. It would be interesting to have some sort of insurance- say $5million to be spent in case of patent lawsuit. Make a clear public statement- we will never settle and WILL spend $5m in case of a lawsuit. Would make it very counter-productive for small-time trolls. This is essentially what NewEgg did and it makes sense.
- javajosh 13y agoYou are right. Luckily there is a fairly well known, small list of patent trolls (the people mind you, not the meaningless shell companies) that could be simply enumerated, with the charter of the cooperative allowing additions (but never removals). I mean, I'd pay $20/mo for Lodsys protection alone.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>Sweet- so Apple can join this and infringe on anyone's patents and get their legal bills paid for? Presumably it would cover litigation costs but not liabilities. So if you lose at the end, you still lose and have to pay damages out of your own pocket. >Seriously though, it would have to have some clear definition of patent troll. Not necessarily. You might not classify the likes of IBM as a "patent troll" under some definitions, but having some sort of litigation expenses insurance when they come knocking would certainly be welcome. Why not avoid the hair splitting exercises and just have the insurance kick in whenever someone makes a patent infringement claim against you?
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>patent lawsuit insurance Lawsuit insurance is interesting. The problem seems to be that if an insurance company is funding the defense then they have the same incentive to pay a settlement rather than fight that anyone else does, and that would just cause even more money to go into the pockets of trolls by giving them a deep pocket in the form of the insurance company, exacerbating the problem (and making the premiums unaffordable). But let's suppose we solve that by stipulating up front that the insurance money can't be used for a settlement. If you want the money then you have to fight; it can only go to lawyers, not plaintiffs. That would be an interesting dynamic. (Obviously plaintiffs would hate it with the fire of a thousand suns because it would cause all but the most blatantly liable defendants to fight.) > to fund lobbying efforts to reform the patent system That sounds pretty sensible. > scrutinize a judicial apparatus that seems biased in favor of patent trolls I don't see this going anywhere. It is far, far easier to lobby to have the law changed by Congress after a judge does something you don't like than to actually have the judge punished for the ruling. What you may want to do here is to lobby for sympathetic judges to be appointed to e.g. the Eastern District of Texas or the Federal Circuit (which has jurisdiction over patent appeals), but that's obviously not a short-term solution because the turnover rate isn't that high.
- mbreese 13y ago> The problem seems to be that if an insurance company is funding the defense then they have the same incentive to pay a settlement rather than fight that anyone else does Unless more than one client of the insurance company might be on the hook for the patent. In which case, they'd simply have to figure out if it was worthwhile to fund one lawsuit to the end, in order to see if they could save money for the other client's policies. Lets say that settling will cost $50,000 and taking the case to trial will cost $200,000 w/ a high likelihood of success. For a single company, the calculation is simple - settle, it's cheaper. But, if an insurance company is behind 5 companies that all might be sued for infringement, then it would make sense to fight at least one of the suits in order to try to save the settlement fees from the other four.
- mcherm 13y ago> The problem seems to be that if an insurance company is funding the defense then they have the same incentive to pay a settlement rather than fight that anyone else does Not true at all. The difference is that the individual needs to factor in the cost of one defense (tens of thousands of dollars at a minimum - PLUS the chance of loosing and then going out of business) versus the cost of the settlement (perhaps a few tens of thousands of dollars). Financially, it makes no sense to pursue the case. The insurance pool needs to factor in the cost of ONE defense (tens of thousands of dollars at a minimum -- PLUS the chance of loosing and then owing a court's determination of a "reasonable cost" for licensing the patent for all the pool's clients) versus the cost of ALL the settlements (a few tens of thousands of dollars times how ever many clients the pool has). A pool doesn't need to get very big before it's financially advantageous to pursue cases you are likely to win and to settle cases you are likely to lose. (By comparison, for individual companies, the best short-term benefit is gained by settling in ALL cases.)