5 ms·
> How about vastly easier access to most of the resources in the Solar System? Is that really true though? Mars isn't vastly close to the asteroid belt and Jup
by SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago
> How about vastly easier access to most of the resources in the Solar System?
Is that really true though? Mars isn't vastly close to the asteroid belt and Jupiter systems.
A quick and dirty lookup in Wolfram Alpha tells me that the distance from Mars to main asteroid belt is comparable to the distance from Earth to Mars. Given that we've yet to land or park in orbit a single earth-grazing asteroid, isn't that actually still vastly far ?
- stcredzero 13y ago> distance from Mars to main asteroid belt is comparable to the distance from Earth to Mars. "Distance." Ahem. http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png Vastly easier in economic terms. The gravity well of Earth is just deep enough that it becomes annoying for creatures whose technology depends on molecular bonds to escape. EDIT: Take a look at this thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of_the_solar_system/ http://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of_... "This is the simple physics fact that I use to blow peoples minds. It takes more energy to crash a rocket into the sun than it does to crash a rocket into Pluto."
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoRight, so mining asteroids from Mars won't take as much raw energy, but it will take good long-range space robotics. And patience.
- cmsmith 13y agoSo low earth orbit and the moon are both 'closer' to Jupiter than Mars is, in terms of energy requirements.
- stcredzero 13y agoYes, but Mars low orbit is closer to Jupiter than LEO and the moon. Building space elevators for Mars is going to be a lot cheaper, so economics is still going to favor industry controlled by Mars, at least until the difference becomes insignificant between Mars and Earth for building space elevators/some form of access to low orbit. (At which point cultural and human capital (sentience capital?) of Earth might make it dominant in the Solar System once again.)
- dalke 13y agoWe don't build oil refineries above deep-sea oil wells. We don't build foundries next to iron mines. We don't cut diamonds next to diamond mines. We don't put textile factories in the middle of cotton fields. We ship bauxite to where electricity costs are the cheapest. South Africa is the major producer of many important minerals, but it doesn't control the world's industries. Why then would economics "favor industry controlled by Mars"? I can conceive of a future where that's so, but only in timescales of several centuries, and it's not at all obvious that there will be any time when Mars will be more important economically than the Earth.
- kevinpet 13y agoWe used to. We stopped when transportation costs came down far enough. We do not ship raw materials to the space station, because transportation costs are high.
- dalke 13y agoOh? When did we ever have a refinery above a deep-sea oil well? When was the diamond cutting industry ever primarily located at diamond mines? I can think of any number of examples where high transportation costs were never high enough to cause the production site to control "industry" in general, or even the specific industry it was in. Consider ivory. For several hundred years, Greenland was the main supplier of ivory - specifically walrus ivory - to Europe, until elephant ivory from Africa became more abundant in the 1400s. But Greenland's dominance of a handful of goods (polar bear fur being another), did not lead to "industry controlled by" Greenland. Beaver pelts would be another example. The market was in Europe, the trapping was done in the US (due to near extinction of the Eurasian beaver). The individual trappers in the American wilds did not control or dominate the fur market - it was the trading companies which did that. And again I mention South Africa. Its "estimated share of world platinum production amounted to 77%; kyanite and other materials, 55%; chromium, 45%; palladium, 39%; vermiculite, 39%; vanadium, 38%; zirconium, 30%; manganese, 21%; rutile, 20%; ilmenite, 19%; gold, 11%;" and so on. But the market is so large and complex that domination of those niches doesn't naturally lead to domination of the entire market by South Africa. And overall market domination is what stcredzero proposes for Mars. But I can be wrong. What is your scenario for how economics will "favor industry controlled by Mars"?
- dalke 13y ago"It takes more energy to crash a rocket into the sun than it does to crash a rocket into Pluto" I don't believe that's what the chart shows. It talks about the energy differences of orbits. You need to knock off delta-v if you want to orbit at the chromosphere, but not if you want to crash into it. And in fact, CuriousMetaphor pointed that out in a child comment to that quote.
- stcredzero 13y agoWell, if you want to cancel your orbital velocity, such that you are drawn into the sun, it does take a lot of energy. But you could also transfer transverse momentum in a fly-by with a planet and head straight into the sun, which is a cheaper way of doing it. Still, it's something that might well seem counterintuitive to people not familiar with orbital mechanics.
- dalke 13y agoCertainly it takes a lot of energy for that. Which is why no one does that, and every probe sent to Mercury or to Pluto has used an assist. I submit that the comment "It takes more energy to crash a rocket into the sun than it does to crash a rocket into Pluto" focuses wrongly on energy, when the important factor is time. Delta-v computed by Hohmann transfer orbits are simple to compute, yes, but leads to an "intuition" which excludes things like low-energy transfer trajectories.
- stcredzero 13y agoOne thing at a time. We first need to get people away from the "intuitive" terrestrial mindset that distance = difficulty. The example, that it would take more energy to drop a rocket on the sun than to hit Pluto (directly, absent more advanced tricks) is a good starting point.
- dalke 13y agoAs a first approximation, the terrestrial mindset is that distance = difficulty. However, rivers, swamps, oceans, forests, deserts, and mountains all modify that statement. Anyone on a river knows that it takes longer to go upstream than down, and someone who has been in eddies, rip currents, or the Gulf Stream well knows that distance and difficulty are only roughly correlated. So it's not that hard to convince terrestrials to use an alternate-but-still-terrestrial energy model, where the Sun is at the top of a high peak, the Earth is on the flank of the mountain, Pluto is near the base, and the terrain is rough enough that things don't just roll down the hill. That image you showed, with delta-v based on Hohmann transfer orbits, maps directly to that terrestrial energy model. As that energy model is obviously wrong - there is no friction in space - it means that that delta-v map is inadequate as a teaching method. Yes, you've gone from crystal spheres to epicycles, but you can't use that new knowledge to understand most of the routes that we actually use for spacecraft. Take the planned Solar Probe Plus as a quite relevant example. Its original plan was to fly by Jupiter, but now it's expected to use multiple flybys of Venus. You cannot explain that with a delta-v map. Moreover, I argue that pointing to a delta-v map as an explanation is itself a sign of a terrestrial mindset. To get back to the topic of "crash into the Sun" and "crash into Pluto" - to the best of my understanding, it's easier to build a rocket that can crash into the Sun than can crash into Pluto, and it takes less time to achieve that goal. Once you can reach L2, you can crash into anything in the Solar System, if you're willing to wait long enough. Reaching Pluto takes a very long time, so it's much more likely to be affected small unforeseen events, like solar storms. Corrections require propulsion. Propulsion control requires computers. Computers require energy. All of these require mass. A Pluto-crash mission requires more mass than a Solar-crash mission, so is harder to build to get to L2 in the first place.