4 ms·
> For those who are keen to travel to Mars: may I suggest a stint in the Peace Corps first, or on a nuclear submarine, or a tour in Antarctica. If that's not am
by stcredzero 13y ago
> For those who are keen to travel to Mars: may I suggest a stint in the Peace Corps first, or on a nuclear submarine, or a tour in Antarctica. If that's not ambitious enough, please try attempting to terraform a desert, or establishing a colony under the ocean or on top of K2, or constructing a city that's mostly buried underground.
Actually, it would be like signing up for a Peace Corps tour in Antarctica, first travelling there for 6 months on a tiny 4-man nuclear submarine, then arriving to build then live in an underground city where the outside atmosphere is more rarefied than at the top of K2 and drier than most deserts.
> it's basically a hostile shithole
The only reason we think the Earth is so great is that we evolved to live there. Otherwise, it would be a shithole at the bottom of an annoyingly deep gravity well and annoyingly dense corrosive atmosphere.
Technology changes everything, though.
- mikeash 13y agoI don't see the impetus for colonizing Mars until we've started building serious cities in Antarctica. What does Mars buy you that Antarctica does not? Even the doomsday scenarios of "all your eggs in one basket" don't really seem to work; an Antarctic colony could be made self-sufficient and survivable in the event of an asteroid strike or nuclear war more easily than a Mars colony. I think it's a cool idea, but people seem to severely underestimate the difficulty.
- stcredzero 13y ago> What does Mars buy you that Antarctica does not? Geez, Mike, I know this isn't your first reading of such threads on HN. How about vastly easier access to most of the resources in the Solar System?
- mikeash 13y agoOf course, how silly of me. I knew the answer all along and just wanted to waste people's time. I'm so sorry to have wasted yours. It couldn't possibly be that I'm actually curious what people think and haven't seen a good answer yet. Jerk.
- stcredzero 13y agoThe repeated question can act as a sort of propaganda. (See the CO2/climate "debate.") If you know what people will probably say in response, then it would be the civic thing to do to mention it. It would also make it more likely for you to see the alternative answers. I call that "progress."
- mikeash 13y agoWhat repeated question? What makes you think I know what people will probably say, beyond the doomsday scenarios I already mentioned? I actually found your idea of better access to space intriguing. I'd love to discuss it. But not with someone like you.
- stcredzero 13y agoOh come on. I just did a search. Considering the amount of times you've been around such threads on HN alone, is this really the first time you've seen the "solar-system wide resource" rationale? I find your pose of victimhood incongruous here.
- mikeash 13y agoI don't actually recall taking part in a Mars colonization discussion on HN before. I frequent SpaceX threads, but that encompasses many topics besides Mars. Between that and you calling me "Mike" even though I have no idea who you are, I have to wonder if you think I'm somebody else. In any case, it's the first time I've seen that rationale. Believe it or not, I don't really care, but it's true. As for "victimhood", I think you've mistakenly identified "calling out a jerk for being a jerk", which is a different thing.
- alphakappa 13y ago>Between that and you calling me "Mike" even though I have no idea who you are, I have to wonder if you think I'm somebody else. I'm not the person you are responding to, but why would you be surprised that someone is referring to you as 'Mike'? Your username is, after all, mikeash, and just this week your post on arm64 was on HN and you were participating in that discussion.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> How about vastly easier access to most of the resources in the Solar System? Is that really true though? Mars isn't vastly close to the asteroid belt and Jupiter systems. A quick and dirty lookup in Wolfram Alpha tells me that the distance from Mars to main asteroid belt is comparable to the distance from Earth to Mars. Given that we've yet to land or park in orbit a single earth-grazing asteroid, isn't that actually still vastly far ?
- stcredzero 13y ago> distance from Mars to main asteroid belt is comparable to the distance from Earth to Mars. "Distance." Ahem. http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png Vastly easier in economic terms. The gravity well of Earth is just deep enough that it becomes annoying for creatures whose technology depends on molecular bonds to escape. EDIT: Take a look at this thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of_the_solar_system/ http://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of_... "This is the simple physics fact that I use to blow peoples minds. It takes more energy to crash a rocket into the sun than it does to crash a rocket into Pluto."
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoRight, so mining asteroids from Mars won't take as much raw energy, but it will take good long-range space robotics. And patience.
- cmsmith 13y agoSo low earth orbit and the moon are both 'closer' to Jupiter than Mars is, in terms of energy requirements.
- stcredzero 13y agoYes, but Mars low orbit is closer to Jupiter than LEO and the moon. Building space elevators for Mars is going to be a lot cheaper, so economics is still going to favor industry controlled by Mars, at least until the difference becomes insignificant between Mars and Earth for building space elevators/some form of access to low orbit. (At which point cultural and human capital (sentience capital?) of Earth might make it dominant in the Solar System once again.)
- gnoway 13y agoDistance and independence, I think. A truly self-reliant Mars colony could basically ignore Earth altogether. For that reason I think it's likely we will never see a real permanent Mars colony effort, only small research stuff, just like what we have w/ Antarctica.
- visakanv 13y agoI think you've got the whole thing backwards. We'll probably get the technology we need to build serious cities in Antartica FROM the attempt to colonize Mars. Colonizing Mars is completely irrational, correct. But so was going to space in the first place, so was sailing around the Earth, so was any sort of flight. It boils down to what motivates and excites people. What makes the future a compelling, interesting one.
- javert 13y ago> Colonizing Mars is completely irrational, correct. But so was going to space in the first place, so was sailing around the Earth, so was any sort of flight. No, no, no. Those were not irrational.
- tg3 13y agoNot in the long-term sense, the same way that colonizing another planet is not irrational in the long-term sense. We'll need to be a multi-planetary species if we expect to survive longer than most of the other species on Earth. Putting all your eggs in one basket (especially one that we seem keen on destroying ourselves) is an inherently risky proposition. When the first explorers were sailing around the Earth, it was for the sake of exploration, and the possibility of riches/gold/spices. But it certainly wasn't entirely rational, as a lot of them didn't know where they were going, and had no idea of what they'd find when they got there.
- javert 13y agoIt was entirely rational. Aviation pioneers and explorers were pursuing things they valued. They were fully aware of the risks, and it was worth it to them. I think the current most significant effort to colonize Mars is also rational: Elon Musk wants to do it because it's something that's valuable to him personally to accomplish. I don't think doing something (e.g. colonizing other planets) for the sake of our distant ancestors is rational. That is self-sacrificial. No value is being pursued.
- 13y ago