5 ms·
Rent Affordability Gap in San Francisco
- StavrosK 13y agoAs an aside, I love the needless interactivity on what is essentially an image.
- VeejayRampay 13y agoAs an aside, I love the needless negativity on what is essentially a nice interactive map.
- StavrosK 13y agoI wasn't being negative, I was just pointing out that the map features weren't very useful in this instance, yet they were included.
- mertd 13y agoIt actually makes it unusable on a mobile phone browser.
- notimetorelax 13y agoWorks fine on my tablet with Chrome.
- mrmagooey 13y agoThe overuse of the history api also makes it frustrating to navigate back from as well (at least on ipad).
- Glyptodon 13y agoWhy 2-br instead of 1-br/studio?
- rtpg 13y agoI thought the same thing too, but I guess if there's two of you working, then two minimum-wage jobs "should" work. You can apply the same sort of reasoning by assuming 2 people are paying for it Still frustrating that people will somehow defend the minimum-wage/rent disparity.
- Glyptodon 13y agoI agree that getting by in SF on minimum wage jobs is likely impossible, but at the same time for most of human history separate bedrooms have been a luxury. It'd be interesting to find out if two people could afford a studio or 1-br for 4 jobs or fewer. (I'm guessing not, but you never know.)
- rtpg 13y agoFor most of human history indoor plumbing has also been a luxury. Though you're right that a 1-br + living space should be "decent" for 2 people (the 2-br probably has a living +kitchen too, so is probably not bad in living arangements). Studios are usually a pretty tight fit (euphemism) for 2 people I'd think though.
- nmcfarl 13y agoI've lived in a couple of studios with my previous SO, for something like 3-4 years. In a huge number of ways I prefer it to live living in a 2 bedroom like I do now (however I much prefer living with my wife, so....) It enforces a minimalist aesthetic, excellent cooperation, solid space management and living a good chunk of your life out of the house. Which makes for a nice lifestyle. However your mileage may vary (and I think it certainly matters that we chose to live this way, and where not forced to...)
- rtpg 13y agoI don't know what size your studio was, but as a student I've been in studios around 18m2, and I fill it up well enough with my own stuff. Might be more due to my hoarder personality than other things
- xfour 13y agoWell done, nicely cutup neighborhood polygons on gorgeous base tiles. Obviously something is wrong with Financial District, I don't think the data you are using was accurate there.
- blackjack48 13y agoWhy not? FiDi is home to some of the most expensive luxury units in the city. This fall, voters will consider a proposal to build new luxury units along The Embarcadero.
- ivankirigin 13y agoThis should probably be the number of such jobs needed to rent a room walking distance to BART or Caltrain in the whole bay area. But then it wouldn't have an obvious agenda. Is anyone surprised that cities are expensive or that a city that dramatically restricts construction of high density housing is even more expensive?
- rayiner 13y agoSupply of housing in SF is limited (mostly due to the same sort of do-gooders who make infographics like this one), and demand is what it is, and that sets the price. Living in a 2BR in the city proper is not a necessity. It's a luxury. Living with one income in a two bedroom is by itself a luxury. There is no reason we should expect it to be affordable on a minimum wage salary. Heck, when I lived in New York, I lived in a 430 square-foot apartment with a wife and a baby while making six figures. And I was a 35 minute train ride away from Midtown!
- evanlivingston 13y agoOne concern is that jobs are generally located in the city. It's unfortunate that people who cannot afford to live in the city must also often make long commutes into the city. It'd be a shame if we said it was a luxury to avoid long commutes.
- sologoub 13y agoBut it is a luxury... The demand for housing is affected by convenience. Those with more buying power are able to afford more convenient locations. This is not unique to any particular city or country. I personally have experience with SoCal and Moscow. In SoCal, a 2br condo in Santa Monica costs the same as a house in a nice suburb, the difference is an hour+ drive. In Moscow, inner city is gridlocked 24/7 and unlike most of US, that's where the best jobs are, so the closer to downtown, the more expensive it is. Further out, prices are highest in walking proximity to a metro station (just like BART).
- waps 13y agoAnd then of course, the conversation turns to poor people using cheap cars to get there. And for once this is a "relatively" good deal for the poor, because the savings on car price more than make up for the difference in fuel costs for quite a distance (given that you can easily get a car $20k cheaper than a new efficient car. Needless to say, this must be stopped ! "Not" because it makes life possible for a huge swath of poor people, that's not the problem. It pollutes ! "We" can't park anymore (because unlike poor people we don't arrive at work at 6am). "We" must stimulate public transport usage (without, of course, using it ourselves). Not that public transport even passes through the places where you'd live if you didn't have money, but who cares about that ? The cycle continues.
- dspeyer 13y agoAs usual, "afford" means "make roughly three times the rent". Take a look at Outer Mission, which has a monthly rent of $2150 and an affordability of 4.0. 10.24 $/hour * 8 h/workday * 21 wd/month = 1720 $/m 4.0 * 1720 $/month = 6881 $/month 6881 \approx 3 * 2150 So while having 4 incomes is recommended for living there, it isn't actually needed. You could live there on a smaller income by being careful about your smaller expenses.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- heyitsnick 13y agoA 4x factor sure sounds very high, though maybe the costs in SF (or in the US in general) are different to my own;from my experience over the last 6 years, living in a variety of setups in different cities in Europe, I spend 50-60% of my monthly outgoing on rent (then about 10% on bills, 10% on transport, leaving ~20% on misc and recreation). A 2x factor seems much more reasonable.
- huxley 13y agoAre you including food in there somewhere?
- heyitsnick 13y agoGood point :) Grocery shopping is such a small part, maybe 5%; going out to eat once or twice a week would be part of recreation budget.
- potatolicious 13y agoYou won't find an apartment in SF with a 2x ratio, landlords will run screaming away from you. This is a city where you line up with other prospective tenants to see apartments, and deals are sealed frequently on the spot - and where bidding wars are not unheard of. If you come to SF intending to rent an apartment on a 2x factor, you will be homeless. The insane rents in SF is an express of the extremely constricted supply - which has other effects beyond merely just rent. It's a landlord's market and they can afford to be extremely choosy about who they rent to.
- NelsonMinar 13y agoMade by Stephanie May. Here's some comments about this map on her blog: http://www.mizmay.com/2013/05/Rental-Housing-SF.html http://www.mizmay.com/2013/05/Rental-Housing-SF.html
- rayiner 13y agoRead her other posts. It's basically the same litany of views (supporting highly paid municipal workers and rent controls while opposing aggressive policing) that have pushed people out into the suburbs, simultaneously destroying American cities while putting their finances in shambles.
- bostonscott 13y ago"destroying American cities" Is she arguing SF is or will soon be "destroyed"?
- pessimizer 13y agoNo, rayiner is.
- pessimizer 13y agoPeople ran to the suburbs because of rent controls and highly paid municipal workers? In what narrative?
- spikels 13y agoBoth of these policies drive up the cost of living causing families to move out[1]: Rent control makes apartment rentals more expensive (and lower quality). Overpaid municipal workers must be supported with higher taxes and/or higher fees. [1] http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Families-exodus-leaves-S-F-whiter-less-diverse-3393637.php http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Families-exodus-leaves...
- huxley 13y ago
- wozniacki 13y agoAs a purely informational resource, can someone add how those minimum wage earners can avail themselves of affordable housing, which seem to dot every neighborhood in the city? What does it take and how many, indeed, do?
- tallowen 13y agoWhat do the numbers you get when you hover over a neighborhood mean? They seem to be somewhat contradictory. Household income to afford this rent is always way higher than the median income of those who actually live there. Is there an error in the way these numbers are being calculated or am I misunderstanding the headings?
- dmckeon 13y ago1) A mismatch between the "2 bedroom" metric and the actual mix of occupied dwelling spaces. 2) Marginal demand - current supply and demand has more effect on currently available properties than on previously existing leases. If rent control is in effect, long-time rentals may cost much less than the current market rates.
- schoper 13y agoNo worries, the government subsidizes the living arrangements of the lower classes so that they can continue to live and breed in pathological concentrations in expensive cities. The supply of people to mug/rape you is still higher than out in the suburbs.
- bostonscott 13y agoSeems to me the premise of many comments on this post is that people should have a right to live in San Fran.
- nattaggart 13y agoI think you nailed it. I've noticed this a prevalent opinion in SF.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWell, if someone was born, grew up, and spent their whole life in SF before being forced out by rent increases... why not? Should we just say it's perfectly fine that housing markets keep forcing the middle and working classes further, further, ever further out of the urban cores?
- nattaggart 13y agoIt sounds like you are suggesting a rather perverse sort of inheritance where the "right" to San Francisco stock is granted to those who are born into it irregardless of that man's wealth, merit, or ability. Allocating resources this way would be bad enough if housing stock was a public good, but it's not. It's owned by landlords who are then required to subsidize the lifestyle of the beneficiaries of this "right".
- MrMorden 13y agoIf TPTB wanted affordable housing, they'd get out of the way, ditch rent control, let developers build more of it, and subsidize rental for the poor. There's one showstopper problem with a more free-market approach--the overriding purpose of rent control is to subsidize rich parasites like Charlie Rangel. It would be a lot harder for such people to have their housing paid for by others if subsidies were explicit and means-tested. Sure, poor people wouldn't come out worse, but they're not the ones making the rules.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIt sounds like you are suggesting a rather perverse sort of inheritance where the "right" to San Francisco stock is granted to those who are born into it irregardless of that man's wealth, merit, or ability. Hmm... owning a city as a cooperative? I don't see why not. There are certainly institutional frameworks in which it can and would work. Further, you could take inheritance tax from the value of the urban citizenship when someone inherits it by coming of age as a citizen/resident of the city. If someone couldn't pay the tax (which could be charged as a portion the market price of rent/purchase in that city), they would be forced out of the city, as today. However, when their citizenship/residency right would be outright sold, the tax would be less than 100%, so they would at least partially recoup on a financial level the loss of their home. Sounds like a bizarrely good idea. Thanks for thinking of it.
- w1ntermute 13y agoThis is all due to regulation and zoning laws. Given the demand, SF should look like Hong Kong by now: http://photomichaelwolf.com/#architecture-of-densitiy/8 http://photomichaelwolf.com/#architecture-of-densitiy/8
- toufka 13y agoIt's starting to. Having been here since ~2008 - there was literally no new construction until about last year. And now there are about a dozen high-density apartment buildings going up (on Divis, Market, Duboce, 3rd, etc.). Likely that the greater housing crisis coupled with an explosion of local jobs at the same time greatly increased the burden.
- njharman 13y agoI thought it would be much higher. I'm a socialist. I believe in Universal Housing (that is every one should be guaranteed/given shelter (also healthcare, education, and sustenance)). But, I definitely don't believe in Universal Housing for whereever you want to live. I'm thoroughly unconcerned that it requires 4-8x times minimum wage to live in of the best / most popular cities in the world. Around 1991 my self and 3 other 20-21 yr old college dropouts moved to SF, rented a two bedroom. Can't remember wages, doubt minimum wage cause most jobs pay more than that in SF. I did temp work, two waitresses, and I don't remember what 4th did. There were trade-offs. But we wanted to live in the city even when everyone else our income bracket was being forced out to Oakland. I lived all over SF for 14 years with increasing income and decreasing roomates. It'd doable, if you want it bad enough.
- twoodfin 13y agoBut, I definitely don't believe in Universal Housing for whereever you want to live. Interesting. How do you think such a system of Universal Housing should work? One alternative is to build high density public housing which, IMHO, has been shown to be an utter disaster from which many poor communities are still suffering. Another alternative is to incentivize the poor to leave high cost areas and spread out to where they could be housed more affordably/safely/sanely. I'm not sure that's as terrible an idea, but it certainly has downsides, including potentially sacrificing whatever culture and community already exists in poorer areas. I am not a socialist; my currently preferred form of welfare is simply to give people cash (and more cash, rather than less, if they obtain a job). But I'm definitely curious to hear the other side.
- dkokelley 13y ago> Another alternative is to incentivize the poor to leave high cost areas and spread out to where they could be housed more affordably/safely/sanely. That incentive exists in the form of cost-of-living savings.
- twoodfin 13y agoSure, but is that enough? How do you create "Universal Housing" if some poor person living in San Francisco stubbornly refuses to buy a bus ticket to Montana?
- nonchalance 13y agoOne thing to note is the word "Average". In the financial district, for example, the apartments along the water have far higher market rates than those even a few blocks away
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- avty 13y agoTime to move to low cost areas such as Texas.
- kyledrake 13y agoRichmond is a great part of town, my friends used to live there and I enjoyed visiting them. But the transit accessibility is terrible. Even with express busing it takes up to 40 minutes to get downtown. If they put in better mass transit options, it would be a much more suitable place to live and I think you would see this map even out more. That said, the people that live there tend to be older families that have been in SF for a long time, and to them that's probably not a high priority (they often live under rent control and probably don't work downtown in tech). If you change the status quo, you threaten their ability to live there by raising prices. I don't think this is going to go away until the exorbitant valuations on tech startups does. It's the main force that's driving these price increases, just like it was during the first bubble.