3 ms·
The problem, defined more concretely, is how to fund the creation of what economists call a "public good": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#The_free_ri
by davidw 13y ago
The problem, defined more concretely, is how to fund the creation of what economists call a "public good":
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#The_free_rider_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#The_free_rider_prob...
Both copyright and government provisioning of the good are ways around the problem. Both are effective in some situations and of course have problems of their own.
I think the government has a role to play in software development in terms of 'basic research' types of stuff. The US government is responsible for the creation of the Internet, and CERN money created the web. But to leave all software development in the hands of the government does not sound like a great solution to me, either, to put it mildly.
- jacquesm 13y agoI think the ransom model can help a lot in cases like this. Develop closed until the software is good enough and then negotiate a pay-day based on the future discounted value of the software, upon receiving the cash the software gets open-sourced. This could work for other creative efforts as well.
- davidw 13y agoPeople tried this out years ago and it never really worked out very well, but perhaps with stuff like Kickstarter, things will change. Part of the problem with it is that it involves a lot of "make me think" on behalf of the acquirer, rather than simply "ok, I need this, the price seems ok, I'll buy it".
- jacquesm 13y agoBlender?
- dllthomas 13y agoNot that I advocate it, but just for a slightly clearer picture of what that world would look like: a situation where lack of copying restrictions leads to the government being the only one paying for development of software for distribution is a very different one than where "all software development [is left] in the hands of the government" - people would still build on what's there, and may hire people to adapt those solutions to particular needs. And of course that's ignoring the fact that you'd probably have a comparable amount of volunteer FLOSS development going on in general.
- abalone 13y agoDid you know Siri was developed with $150M of government funding?[1] The government sponsors a lot more than "basic" research. They also support the commercialization of technology through procurement, for example. Why would government-sponsored software development be any worse than corporate-sponsored? Governments can sponsor multiple teams that compete with one another, after all. That's why "basic science" works even when the money comes from the government -- right? I'd be interested to here from FSF folks on this. One of the biggest "problems" with our existing Silicon Valley model -- which despite what posturing Libertarians think is very, very heavily based on government support (DARPA, procurement, etc.) -- is basically that the public doesn't receive the full benefit of taxpayer-funded R&D. It's pretty much handed over to the private sector, who take all the profits. This might possibly be a more profitable avenue for the Free Software movement to take. Advocate that taxpayer-funded research stay Free. [1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/22/siri-do-engine-apple-iphone_n_2499165.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/22/siri-do-engine-appl...
- davidw 13y agoI'm not a Libertarian, but still think that markets are the best way to provide a lot of things. > Why would government-sponsored software development be any worse than corporate-sponsored? Let's see: * Free rider problem goes global: everyone hopes some other country pays for useful stuff. * Governments are not going to be as focused or concerned about niche businesses. * Corruption. It becomes worthwhile to pay off politicians to have them choose your team. * Calculation problem: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem * The NSA. Think they're bad now? The current market has problems, but I just don't see any evidence that moving software production to the government would be much of an improvement, and it might be a whole lot worse.
- abalone 13y agoI'm curious, how do these problems appear in the core sciences, if at all? Since that is almost entirely government funded. The results are mostly free and open once published. It's incredibly nichey; many scientists dedicate their lives to a very narrow area of study. Nobody, DARPA and the NSF included, is great at predicating what is going to bear fruit years down the line. And yet science happens. It's not subject to a crippling "free rider problem", even though the whole world benefits. It's not massively corrupted by bribery. Are these just what industry folks say when they want to be subsidized by taxpayers? It's ok for core R&D to be publicly funded, but all these problems will emerge suddenly if they bring it to market, so that last mile has to be left to us.. and the profits too?