3 ms·
Not at all. There are lots of inchoate property rights. For example, the right to cut through someone's land. You don't own the land, so the property right is i
by chongli 13y ago
Not at all. There are lots of inchoate property rights. For example, the right to cut through someone's land. You don't own the land, so the property right is inchoate. Or consider the right to buy or sell another right (an option). Also inchoate, but a property right nonetheless. Indeed, these days, your bank account is an inchoate property right. Just the right to a particular configuration of bits.
Right, but you haven't adequately explained why this principle should be extended to intangibles such as ideas. Hence, you have begged the question.
- rayiner 13y agoBegging the question means assuming the thing you're trying to prove. I'm not trying to prove that patents should be considered property rights. Indeed, I'm convinced they should be part of a tort-like regime. But that's neither here nor there. My original post was about the use of the word "monopoly." Someone claimed that "monopolies are bad for consumers" but as I explained any property right is a legal monopoly, but that doesn't mean it's a monopoly in an economic sense. The issue of whether patents should be considered property is irrelevant to the question of whether they are monopolies in the economic sense.