3 ms·
I personally prefer not to own a home in these circumstances but if you really want to buy a home I’ll happily help you by writing a letter. A coup
by aaronbrethorst 13y ago
I personally prefer not to own a home in
these circumstances but if you really want
to buy a home I’ll happily help you by
writing a letter.
A couple reactions:
1. The employee in an early stage startup should know better, but:
2. You, as their CEO, someone they hopefully trust and respect, shouldn't be doing anything to encourage them getting into a financially untenable position.
edit: I want to mention another scenario. Let's say you have six weeks of cash left, and prospects for a bridge round are shrinking by the day. For whatever reason you've decided not to tell your employees what's up.
What do you do then? Still tell this poor bastard, "if you really want to buy a home I’ll happily help you by writing a letter"? That's incredibly risky at best and morally repugnant at worst. Maybe things work out and you get more cash. Maybe you don't, but he's able to get another job within days. Maybe you don't, he can't, and he loses his house.
That's a serious gamble you're taking not with your own life and livelihood but with someone else who has placed their trust in you. What's your reaction? 'Them's the breaks with working at a startup,' perhaps?
I know Mark lives in L.A., but I've seen similar behavior occur in both Seattle and SF companies, and I find it abhorrent.
Here's another part that bugs me:
If you find employees building spreadsheets
and spending time on exit scenarios and what
their take would be then you know your company
has “optionitis.”
Or they're about to figure out that it doesn't matter if the company exits when they own 0.75% or 0.49%, because their percentage is going to net them exactly dick either way.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brudgers 13y agoThe cultural memory of stock options revolves around the Microsoft IPO, where in a pre-internet age, secretaries (which indicates how long ago it was) became millionaires via tiny slices of equity. The Google chef brought the misconception into the internet age. Even at a billion dollar exit, 1% is borderline fuck you money after taxes.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoAbsolutely right, but, as I'm fond of pointing out to friends who join startups: you are not joining Google, Facebook, or Microsoft. The odds of you even joining Zillow or Yelp are so remote as to be a rounding error to a rounding error.
- sliverstorm 13y agoNo, but don't you see- that's everybody else who doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell. We're different.
- judk 13y agoWhat possible reason could someone have for legitimately thinking that working a professional job for 4 years would pay FU money. Hint: I would work 4 years for 50% FU money. Imagine what the equilibrium price of such an auction would be.
- walshemj 13y agoWell the 5 year share save for BT due next year will return about £60k (tax free) and I know there will be a lot of people taking redundancy after that.
- judk 13y agoThat is good money, pays for 1-4 years of good living. Hard put to call that "FU money", though. (Maybe it is in the UK with its high level of basic social services?)
- walshemj 13y agoIt is when you have enough years in and with BT's redundancy terms you can max out your pension (ie if you worked any longer you would not get any more pension) get a huge tax free bung plus £60k ss on top.
- 13y ago
- btilly 13y agoRule of thumb. Deliver bad news all at once. Let good news leak out a bit at a time. Furthermore the CEO's advice was not bad. I looked for a job, in tech, in Los Angeles, in 2003. I know what that market was like. Even if the company folded, the employee would have had a good shot at finding another one quickly. Whether or not to trust the ability to do that is another question. But whether to take the risk really is a question of choice.