2 ms·
Maybe look at it this way: There is no X for which "X / 0" is defined. There are many, many, many X (in fact, potentially all X such that X is a set) for whic
by ubernostrum 17y ago
Maybe look at it this way:
There is no X for which "X / 0" is defined.
There are many, many, many X (in fact, potentially all X such that X is a set) for which "X is a member of itself" is defined.
In other words, division by zero universally leads to contradiction no matter what you put in for X. But self-membership is perfectly well-behaved for lots and lots of values, and only starts to get troublesome on certain particular cases. This is curious: why should something which works well in many, many cases end up at a contradiction based not on the logical form of the statement, but rather on the particular values we substitute in place of its variables?