3 ms·
I hate to be a negative nancy, but for most of these diseases I'm not convinced the answers are in the biophysical properties of amyloids. I still hold out tha
by dnautics 13y ago
I hate to be a negative nancy, but for most of these diseases I'm not convinced the answers are in the biophysical properties of amyloids. I still hold out that biophysics might hold answers for the PrP diseases - mad cow; kuru; FFI, the subject of the OP - but for most of these other conditions (alzheimer's, diabetes, Gelsolin Amyloidosis - not parkinsons, which is, contrary to common grantwriting trends, is not an amyloid), I'm increasingly convinced that amyloid is not, in the general case, causal, because amyloid is a general protein fold. There's amyloids that are not cell-malfunction-related and probably functional (in melanosomes[0], secretory granules[1], and which bacteria use to grow their extracellular matrices[2]), there's amyloids that aren't toxic except for causing physical disruption (beta-2 microglobulin blocks kidney nephrofunction), and there's amyloids which are just garbage binned proteins (bacterial inclusion bodies[3]). Probably in the ur-times, early proteins, which were likely overwhelmingly hydrophobic[4] aggregated as amyloids as an easy, thermodynamically favorable, self-assembling superstructure, that is regulateable merely by producing to concentrations above the critical concentration.
[0] Fowler, et al, PLOSBio 2005, the data are terrible - long story, but I basically redid the experiments and got cleaner, sensical results - but the conclusion is probably true.
[1] Maji, et al, Science 2009
[2] Cherny, et al, JMB 2005
[3] Wang, et al, PLOSBio 2008
[4] Mannige, et al, PLOSCompBio 2012
I have more detailed reasons to believe the things that I do, if you'd like to hear more, feel free to contact me. I especially have some interesting tips on where to look with PrP (I did a short, unpublished project on it that was inconclusive, but the ideas are intriguing). Long story short, if you are dead set on being a biophysicist, and you want to really make a difference, focus on the PrP diseases, the other ones are, in my highly opinionated opinion, red herrings. Otherwise, focus on the biology. Also, learn your chemistry well, in either case. Good luck with your PhD. It's a minefield out there.