3 ms·
I thought the most interesting point was the one about what happens when you bring in a big, flat-screen TV -- you are introducing a highly culturally influenti
by grandalf 17y ago
I thought the most interesting point was the one about what happens when you bring in a big, flat-screen TV -- you are introducing a highly culturally influential meme-blaster into your environment. I think it's debatable whether to call it pollution, but I have noticed that not having a TV leaves me naive to all sorts of time wasting thoughts.
I also liked the point about trying to be "chosen". I think there is some truth to it. But isn't pretty much any job about being chosen -- entrepreneurs get chosen by VCs and customers, new lawyers by the partners, mcdonalds employees by the regional manager, etc.
- Alex3917 17y ago"But isn't pretty much any job about being chosen -- entrepreneurs get chosen by VCs and customers, new lawyers by the partners, mcdonalds employees by the regional manager, etc." Well for an entrepreneur it's your product or service that's being chosen, not you yourself. It's pretty clear when you talk with entrepreneurs that they see the world very differently because of this. At the end of the day there are two economies, the economy of those who do and the economy of those who do what they're told. And both the children of white-collar and blue-collar workers are largely ending up in the latter economy. My point was that this isn't happening only because of the worldview that parents are transmitting, but rather because the way parents are raising kids is causing irreversible cognitive damage that puts kids at a huge handicap regardless of what worldviews they're later exposed to. I didn't bother to go into the statistics about how ECE stuff affects later outcomes like adult literacy and such because I thought it would be excessive. But it's all there if you're looking for it.
- grandalf 17y agoInteresting point. I would be interested in any links you might have... I wonder about this question now and then in the context of the thought experiment "describe a capitalist utopia". In my musings, such a utopia might eliminate the distinction between work and play, and possibly even between learning and play. If such a scenario came to exist, doing what one was told would surely be the lowest form of existence and would be viewed as outright subjugation. Or would it -- maybe many people enjoy structure and thrive when being told what to do. In reading about Myers Briggs it seems that the "guardian" personality type enjoys structure and respects authority. Doesn't it follow that if one respects authority he will do what he is told by said authority? Guardians are over 10% of the population... Are these (often high functioning) people actually the victims of the cognitive damage you describe? I know this comment is a bit out there :)
- Alex3917 17y ago"I would be interested in any links you might have..." The Hart & Risley book is the best source for understanding how parenting styles affect language acquisition. If you then want to see what how high-SES and low-SES children diverge even more after age five, check out Equality and Achievement by Riordan. If you're interested in ECE stuff other than language then there are a ton of interesting academic papers, but it really depends what you're looking for.