5 ms·
If You Live Near Other People, You're Probably a Democrat.
- lukifer 13y agoI've recently become fascinated by the concept that one's political affiliation tends to sync up with one's dominant survival strategy. If you rely most on communities and relationships, you tend to be liberal; if you rely most on authority and hierarchies, you tend to be conservative; if you rely most on your own skills, you tend to be libertarian. http://www.meltingasphalt.com/the-ecology-of-personal-politics/ http://www.meltingasphalt.com/the-ecology-of-personal-politi...
- ctdonath 13y agoConsider applying the r/K Selection Theory to politics. Makes a disturbing amount of sense: http://www.anonymousconservative.com/blog/the-theory/rk-selection-theory/ http://www.anonymousconservative.com/blog/the-theory/rk-sele...
- skorgu 13y agoIt lines up in some ways, not in others. Liberals are known for their high fertility rate as well as their opposition to abortion to ensure the highest number of offspring. Likewise the conservative obsession with childhood nutrition, education and welfare lines up well with their high-investment child-rearing instinct. Sarcasm aside the infinite/scarce resource division seems like an interesting one to observe. See also the forager/farmer distinction[0]. [0] http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/10/two-types-of-people.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/10/two-types-of-people.ht...
- sliverstorm 13y agoAn interesting article, but a little politically charged. The repeated emotionally loaded descriptions of liberals and conservatives cannot have been accidental.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoThat blog entry is a load of crap. Firstly, he doesn't actually define r/K selection theory and then map it onto politics by showing an actual mapping. He simply defines r-selection according to his disfavored strawman of "liberalism" and K-selection according to his favored strawman of "conservatism". "The theory was popular in the 1970s and 1980s when it was used as a heuristic device, but lost importance in the early 1990s as it was criticized by several empirical studies."[1] Emphasis mine. Furthermore: if we actually try to make a mapping, we find exactly the reverse of what your blogger describes: it's the highly-educated, urban-dwelling, blue-state "liberals" (as alluded to in the Atlantic article) who are actually observed to have fewer children and invest more in each child, while the less-educated, rural-dwelling, red-state "conservatives" produce more children with less investment in each. It's really, really amazing just how wrong your blogger has managed to get his ecology, how completely backwards. For one thing, if we look at Wikipedia, we find that human beings simply are not considered an r-strategist species at all, at least not modern humans. But hey, let's go ahead and extend the analogy, because I'm feeling particularly evil today and thus see no reason not to map between evolutionary/ecological behaviorism and actual moral philosophy for real people as if such a thing isn't outright blasphemous to the very concept of human dignity. An r-strategist population is held in check from becoming K-selected by... what? Well, some form of external population culling, something that kills off the less-fit in large numbers and thus ensures the population as a whole has no need to evolve more complex behaviors or lifestyles. What, in conservative politics, is the culling agent? Well, capitalism. It's an r-strategist economic system: produce lots of low-human-capital proletarians and then just work them until they either drop dead or manage to reproduce. What, in left-wing politics, follows K-selection strategies? Well, the entire emphasis on social investment in individual lives, actually. And yet half the population feigns moral offense at the notion that human beings, a K-selected species in the first place, should shift further in the direction of K-strategizing by going from capitalism to socialism! And in the face of a slow-motion planetary-level ecological collapse driven by human overpopulation in the most conservative, r-strategist societies, nonetheless! [1] -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R/K_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R/K_theory How much of the above is at all accurate or precise? Well, probably not very much, but more than that godawful "Anonymous Conservative" blog entry, most likely. Do I care? Not entirely, the point was more to rant and to show that you can easily argue either "side" of the so-called political "spectrum" (which is actually far more complex than "liberal versus conservative", a dichotomy produced entirely by the idiocy of First Past the Post voting systems) based on any given ecological/evolutionary theory, because real scientific theories are not moral or ethical arguments!
- whyenot 13y agoThis makes about as much sense as applying continental drift to explain the series finale of Breaking Bad.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWell I don't know. The possible analogies are interesting: a social system is a reproductive strategy, it's a way of breeding and educating your population to serve some defined purpose (the objective of the system). Being able to characterize those systems broadly would be helpful.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI think you are flipping conservatives and liberals. Liberals tend to rely on authority and hierarchies (the state, and similar authority figures), whereas conservatives tend to rely on communities and relationships (church, family, secular community orgs). Or am I misinterpreting something here?
- jbooth 13y agoSubject to debate, and everyone's gonna want to think that their "side" is the most enlightened... (end disclaimer) I think a lot of liberals see conservatives as authoritarian in that they support the police/military parts of government. Even your tea party libertarians tend to see the police/military as 'our people', culturally speaking and as a necessary part of the state philosophically speaking. Liberals tend to distrust police/military a lot more. So while your libertarian is a lot less friendly to 'The State' and 'Big G Government', typically they're thinking about zoning boards, the FDA, FCC and welfare when they're against those things -- not particularly hierarchical organizations compared to military/police. Basically, you're thinking economics, we're thinking marching orders. (as a liberal, I find it ridiculous when I hear conservatives talk about the tyranny of big govt while pushing for an increase in defense spending and more militarization of police)
- johngalt 13y agoAs a conservative I find it ridiculous when liberals talk of fascist police while pushing to limit civilian gun rights. We can make straw men all day. Regardless of arguing against caricatures of the 'other' side. I think a majority of Americans could agree on a majority of issues. The problem is the gamesmanship of politics.
- jbooth 13y ago"pushing to limit civilian gun rights" is sort of willfully deceptive, as it implies gun-grabbing where most liberals just want registration along the same level as a driver's license. At least you acknowledged that it's a straw man. Most conservatives do actually support more spending on military/security and less spending on everything else -- that's not a straw man position really, I was just describing a slant on it.
- bruceb 13y agoYou tend to be libertarian if you think you rely on your own skills and you think what you do as an individual has no effect on the individuals around you. There is the joke "A conservative is a liberal who has been mugged" One could add: "A liberal is a conservative who just lost their health insurance" or "A liberal is a libertarian whose neighbor just blocked their waterfront view"
- johngalt 13y agoThe reverse of the conservative one is: "A liberal is a conservative who's been arrested."
- i_c_b 13y agoI've observed something kind of similar, although in my view, the axis is, if you rely on abstracted rules and disembodied systems and institutions, you tend to be liberal, whereas if you rely on much more on tightly shared unstated norms and cultural expectations, you tend to be conservative. If you live in a dense, cosmopolitan city, you need local government to make sure that all those diverse transient strangers around you are coordinating their lives properly through the shared explicit protocol of secular government. If you live in a distant suburb, on the other hand, it's not the cops that make you feel safe, its the fact that most people around you look and dress like you do, water their lawns, go to church, and generally display themselves publicly exhibiting the norms of your community. But of course, you better be exhibiting those norms too.
- grecy 13y agoFascinating. I wonder if in the years to come as population density increases, will more and more people vote Democrat, or will the magic number of 800 people per sq. mile. simply increase?
- kcorbitt 13y agoThe density number will almost certainly increase. Both of the major US political parties are very pragmatic -- they're willing to shift their platforms as much as necessary to capture a bare majority (if they weren't, they wouldn't remain major parties for long). So while it's possible that ideals currently endorsed by the Democratic platform will become more widespread that only means that the Republicans will shift their stand to match the majority opinions.
- securingsincity 13y agoAnd certainly much higher population density might breed new political leanings and attitudes that another party could capitalize on.
- sliverstorm 13y agoWhich is of course how it should be; what use is a party that does not represent the people?
- ck2 13y agoWhat I always enjoy reading, from an intellectual sense and not a "ha ha" sense, is "awakening" stories when people are raised super conservative and follow that path - until they have a personal experience that enlightens them that it's not ideal. Watching self-discovery instead of being hit over the head with it is always fascinating.
- evacuationdrill 13y agoDo you happen to have an example of one? Where do you find them?
- johngalt 13y agoI enjoy reading that every generation thought that in 50 years there will be no more conservatives. Every 20 something thinks with absolute certainty that their political views wont change with age. And that it's only a matter of time until the rest of the world catches up to their 'correct' views.
- ck2 13y agoThe problem with just saying "conservative" is there are fiscal conservatives and then there are social conservatives. You think 50 years ago they ever thought there would be gay conservatives? Conservatives that would support gay marriage? So they aren't socially conservative, at least not completely. On the other side, I am not sure how to explain this properly but I find I am less liberal with age but even more progressive.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoBasically, cultural/lifestyle issues, military issues, and economic issues are intertwined, but largely separate. You can be a "fiscal conservative, social liberal" proprietarian, and you can also be a "economic social-democrat, social conservative" (like most of the working-class population in most countries, by the way). Or you can go "full partisan retard", pick one "side" of the "spectrum", and take that "side" on every separate spectrum, thus resulting in the traditional strawmen of "liberals" or "conservatives". Personally, I've actually become more culturally liberal the further I get out of university. College liberals are awful and horrendously stupid to boot, but seeing people who've left their parents' support and still manage to hold liberal positions drives me towards that position. Kind of like how conservatives tend to oppose gay marriage right up until meeting the average actual gay couple, and realizing that, hold on, those "godless liberals" are just like us "normal, decent folk"!
- thejteam 13y agoI'd like to know if more fine-grained data on population density is available. Congressional districts have a very broad array of population densities within them. I'd love to have access to density information at the voting precinct level and see if that correlation still holds.
- ctdonath 13y agoPrecinct data is available. Depends on your state elections department. Example data: http://results.enr.clarityelections.com/GA/Forsyth/42336/112362/en/reports.html# http://results.enr.clarityelections.com/GA/Forsyth/42336/112...
- alex_young 13y agohttp://www.saltwaterwitch.com/img/WhatAmericaLooksLike-2012Election-ChrisHoward.jpg http://www.saltwaterwitch.com/img/WhatAmericaLooksLike-2012E...
- ctdonath 13y agoI realized this a decade or so ago when digging thru election precinct maps and noticed how bright the "red/blue division" line was around urban areas.
- tokenadult 13y agoThe huge amount of scatter around the line of best fit in the scatterplot shown in the article demonstrates that there is a HUGE degree of uncertainty in this model. I know plenty of counterexamples to this in my high-density townhouse neighborhood.
- logicallee 13y agoIf you're a person in America, you're probably a woman.
- asgard1024 13y agoWhile in China, you're probably a man! Conclusions?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sgustard 13y agoExcept in the military, which is high density but pretty conservative. Anyway, the usual causation question arises: do people become more liberal as they gain neighbors? Or do they choose to live somewhere with more neighbors because they are already liberal?
- oostevo 13y agoThe military isn't as conservative as many people think -- it's actually a pretty good representation of the voting preferences of the public at large. "It is true that the upper echelons of the military tilt right," but "only 32 percent of the Army’s enlisted soldiers consider themselves conservative, while 23 percent identify as liberal and the remaining 45 percent are self-described moderates." [1] For reference, the officer corps of the military only makes up ~16% of the total number of service members.[2] [1] http://andrewgelman.com/2009/05/05/how_soldiers_re/ http://andrewgelman.com/2009/05/05/how_soldiers_re/ [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Armed_Forces#Personnel_in_each_service http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Armed_Forces#Pers...
- saosebastiao 13y agoAs an urban republican, I find this intuitive, although there is significant variation from neighborhood to neighborhood even holding density constant. Even amongst republicans, you still see major policy opinion differences that are divided by urban vs exurban. I'm hoping the urban variant becomes more prominent :) That aside, please please pretty please do not do statistical analyses with Excel.
- johngalt 13y agoThis is just a re-telling of a well known fact. Rural areas tend to be red and urban areas tend to be blue. Only this is retold with the connotation that republicans are somehow antisocial. I'd just like to point out that proximity is not equivalent to interaction. In my experience social interaction was higher in rural settings. In a small town you will know all your neighbors, and probably half the people at your local stores. In a city it's the opposite, strangers abound.
- smtddr 13y agoAgreed, in my mind I like to picture republican areas like the "King of the Hill" cartoon. All really nice & sociable people, just have a few opinions that differ from my own only because of different life experiences. Also, the areas that see the most foreigners will give more points of view to consider. I'd like to see political-affiliation related to distance from a major airport.
- tomkarlo 13y agoWe tend to know the same number of people total, so when you're in a more densely populated area, you're dividing the same number (or even a larger number) by a much, much larger number of people around you. Maybe it's not that people in small towns are more social; they just have a smaller pool.
- johngalt 13y agoExactly, the smaller number of total people results in meeting people you know more often. This is exactly what happens. I wasn't trying to imply that rural people are different, merely that the setting creates more opportunities to have social interaction.
- tomkarlo 13y agoHaving fewer places in town results in meeting people you know more often. Having fewer people doesn't - your probability of meeting someone is the number of people you know (which is arguably larger in a city) divided by the number of places they could be. The number of people you don't know in a place is mostly irrelevant.
- rayiner 13y agoI wonder what the data looks like when you account for the fact that our biggest, densest cities also have huge minority populations which vote democrat for reasons that have little to do with population density.
- tomkarlo 13y agoI'm pretty sure it maps out the same if you filtered for, say, non-Hispanic white voters. The curve might shift towards GOP overall, but the correlation would still be there, because the cities also tend to skew more educated and that correlates in a positive way with voting DNC.
- GigabyteCoin 13y agoIf that statement were true, we will never see a republican government in the USA again. Considering the fact that more people live in cities than don't, and this percentage of people has only been rising for the past century: http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2009/aug/18/percentage-population-living-cities http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2009/aug/18/percent...
- jerf 13y agoThe line between "Republican" and "Democrat" moves, which is why it tends to be so close to 50% (all things considered) for so long. If the line becomes lopsided in one direction or the other, the parties shift.
- svachalek 13y agoIt's pretty early to say that, and a lot of things can change in the meantime. But for the short term, remember that in the U.S., representation is not entirely proportional to population. Voters in Wyoming have quite a bit more influence than those in California due to how the Senate and electoral college works, and voters in Iowa have more influence than either due to the whole interaction between media and the election process.
- AutoCorrect 13y agothere have been studies discussing density of population and rising mental illness rates in rats & mice. I wonder if the two are connected?
- mindcrime 13y agoAs a present-day Urban Libertarian, who grew up as a Rural Conversative (in name) with some Liberal tendencies (eg, I was a Libertarian all along, but didn't know it, because I didn't know the term), this seems fairly reasonable to me. More urban areas tend to attract people from lots of different places, and you get a blending of worldviews and ideas, which - from what I've seen - has a generally "liberalizing" effect (using "liberal" here in the "classical liberal" sense, not necessarily anything to do with modern day Democrats). So I find that urban areas tend to have more "modern liberal" / "democrat" types, AND more Libertarians, than more traditionally conservative / rural areas. I think you also see a lot of "small l" libertarians in more rural areas, who are very libertarian but maybe don't describe themselves that way for one reason or another.
- williamcotton 13y agoWhy don't we have laws that are based on population density? Why don't we have mathematical formulas written in to the law itself?
- switch007 13y agoI've never understood the staunch support of a political party to the extent that you label yourself one or the other. Is it really like that - people go out of their way to identify as a party member? Is it not a hindrance in finding common ground and working together? On this side of the pond, I find that people "support" a party, rather than consider themselves a member of one (even if they are).
- presidentender 13y ago"If you live close to a large number of strangers, you're probably a Democrat." "If you know many members of local government personally, you're probably a Republican."
- downandout 13y agoMother Jones, Huffington Post, or CNN will undoubtedly make a post shortly entitled "New Study Shows Republicans are Anti-Social and Despise Their Neighbors". However, all this data shows is that Democrats tend to be on the lower income side ( see http://n.pr/QFg1Yo http://n.pr/QFg1Yo ). Lower income people tend to live in higher density areas.
- foob 13y agoBut you may also be struck by the shape of that trend line (Sen is quick to note, by the way, that he's not a statistician). It roughly suggests a political tipping point somewhere around a population density of about 800-1,000 people per square mile. My guess would be that this is a linear fit using a least squares minimization. The fit is dominated by the upper right portion of the plot and has a relatively arbitrary x-intercept of around -10. Population density going negative doesn't make sense and shouldn't be a feature of a reasonable model. There's no tipping point, it's just how the line shows up on a log plot and it's almost entirely determined by the data with population density much great than 1000. I think it would make a more sense to plot population density on the x-axis because the scatter in the data is really coming from the Cook PVI rather than the population density and the Cook PVI can be interpreted as a dependent variable. We know very precisely what the populations are and we can also see that the magnitude of the Cook PVI scatter looks roughly constant as a function of population density. After this a simple least squares fit would be more reasonable to apply but again a line would not fit the data at all. Just by eye I would say that (Cook PVI)=AxLog[ (Population Density)xB ] would do a much better job modeling the distribution. Overall, it's a nice plot to motivate discussion but the fit doesn't really add anything to it and might even detract from it.