3 ms·
That's somewhat oblique, easily attributed to misunderstanding (I'm not sure what actual question was asked - it's been a decade since I saw Revolution OS), and
by dllthomas 13y ago
That's somewhat oblique, easily attributed to misunderstanding (I'm not sure what actual question was asked - it's been a decade since I saw Revolution OS), and poorly thought out: a "Red Hat Linux" system at the time was running more GNU code than Linux code (and overwhelmingly more than Red Hat code).
Every damned other thing in there seems to argue precisely the opposite.
I defy you to find anything Stallman said (as opposed to characterizations by others, which could easily be deliberate or accidental mischaracterizations) that implies a position that a system without GNU code (or with insignificant amounts) running Linux should be called GNU/Linux. If such exists, then I will agree with you that Stallman once held the absurd position you attribute to him.
Edited to add:
"It came up in the documentary because there had been a huge firestorm over RMS saying everyone should call it GNU/Linux."
I agree that there was a huge firestorm over RMS saying everyone should call it GNU/Linux. I disagree with what that "it" refers to.
- kunai 13y agoA Red Hat system was running more code for GNOME/KDE than either coreutils or Linux. Should we call it GNOME/GNU/Linux? Probably, because GNOME was designed from the beginning to be a usable desktop for users. There is a GNU, and it is running on their system, but it is just part of the system they use. Also, LOC is a really poor metric for comparing the importance of a piece of software for a system. Many applications have far more LOC than the entire OS itself, and you wouldn't call that app more essential than the OS.
- dllthomas 13y agoLOC is a poor metric, but by any metric GNU contribution was substantial. GNOME, incidentally, is GNU[1]. Coreutils is not the sole contribution of the GNU project to a (typical desktop or server) Linux system. [1]: Certainly currently - I am less confident it started that way, but the G seems to stand for GNU so that's some evidence that it did.
- wildgift 13y agoGNOME = GNU Object Model Environment Also, Linux isn't GNU, but it is GPL. People get annoyed at the RMS self-promotion, or GNU promotion, but that stuff is important.
- dllthomas 13y agoAll true. It'd still be weird for RMS to try and claim the kernel is GNU, but I don't believe he ever did.